Burgaton's Phantom Draft

[Stiffy_18]

Over the years he has decent strike rate with our first picks so here is who he thinks we will select this year.


I don't mind the picks, especially the first 2, but he has gone a bit too local happy IMHO. Salter will be snapped up before 71 and I suspect Petrenko could well not get drafted considering he has had a shoulder reco.

Still pretty good effort overall. Hope he is right on at least the first pick

10 – ADELAIDE – BRAD EBERT

Port Adelaide Magpies, VIC, Medium midfielder, April 2 1990, 188.2cm, 85.4kg

Ebert could fall to the Brisbane Lions (No.8) and Jack Grimes to Adelaide: he is also in strong contention here. Ebert has also been linked to Essendon, Fremantle, St Kilda and Hawthorn, but realistically he seems set to be chosen in the No.8-12 range. Alex Rance and Scott Selwood, who appears to be climbing up the pecking order, are also in Adelaide's thinking. The Crows also seriously considered Patrick Dangerfield and Cyril Rioli, but it believed those two players are now unlikely to be selected at No.10.

Bio: Noted for his strong attack on the ball, overhead marking and his versatility. He is a graduate of AIS-AFL Academy and touted as potential leader. Captained South Australia at the 2007 NAB AFL U18 Championships, averaging 22 possessions throughout the carnival and he was the only South Australian to earn All-Australian honours. Nephew of Russell Ebert and cousin of Port Adelaide's Brett Ebert. From Henley FC.

27 – ADELAIDE – LEVI GREENWOOD

Port Adelaide Magpies, SA, Medium defender, 19 February 1989, 181.2cm, 92.9kg

It will be fascinating to see where Greenwood is taken. He is widely regarded as a 15-30 selection and could be plucked as early as No.16 by Port Adelaide. At worst, he is unlikely to slip past Adelaide (No.27). If the Power opts for Veszpremi at No.16, Greenwood could genuinely fall to its cross-town rival here, as the Crows are very keen. Essendon (No.23) and the Brisbane Lions (No.25) are also in the mix, although it appears Hawthorn (No.29), Kangaroos (No.32) and Carlton (No.36) will miss out on his services.

Bio: Strong in-and-under player who is renowned for his uncompromising attack on the ball. Played 11 matches at senior level with Port Adelaide in 2007, averaging 17 possessions. Recorded excellent results in both the repeat 30m sprint (24.22sec) and vertical jump (71cm) at the 2007 NAB AFL Draft Camp. From Whyalla FC.

30 – ADELAIDE – MITCHELL FARMER

Calder Cannons, VIC, Small midfielder, January 4 1989, 180.3cm, 77kg

There is plenty of interest in Farmer, who has been touted as a likely second or third round selection. West Coast has shown considerable interest and could jag him with one of its final two selections at No.20 or No.22, but realistically he appears to be a No.25-35 prospect. This is where Adelaide comes in. The Crows are genuinely keen on him and if available, Farmer should land at either No.27 or No.30. If taken earlier, Melbourne is a chance at No.21, and later Collingwood (No.31) and Carlton (No.36) are right in the mix.

Bio: Quick, durable and aggressive small defender/midfielder who kicks very well. Impressive member of Vic Metro team in NAB AFL U18 Championships. From Craigieburn FC.

38 – ADELAIDE – JOHN McCARTHY

Dandenong Stingrays, VIC, Medium forward, November 19 1989, 188.6cm, 79.6kg

McCarthy has come right into the mix in recent weeks with four clubs – Adelaide, Geelong, St Kilda and Melbourne all strongly linked with him. Although McCarthy could feature in several different scenarios in the draft, he now looks a genuine prospect to be taken at this pick. Adelaide will strongly consider him, particularly with the recent loss of forward Scott Welsh. The Crows may also look at local products Jared Petrenko or Nick Salter with these choices or potentially with one of their later selections.

Bio: Very good one-on-one player who is strong overhead and a good kick. Has pace and a sound understanding of the game. From Sorrento FC.

58 – ADELAIDE – JARED PETRENKO

Eagles, SA, Small midfielder, December 22 1989, 177.3cm, 74.6kg

Petrenko has been strongly linked with Adelaide for quite some time. He has even been touted as a possible second or third rounder for the Crows, although he looms as a player who could slot anywhere in the draft. It is possible he may be a rookie as well. Still, he is one of South Australia's best junior prospects this year. Mature-age SANFL stars Ian Callinan and Brant Chambers have been linked with Crows, but it appears they are now unlikely to be drafted, despite their outstanding seasons in the local competition.

Bio: Extremely quick midfielder/defender whose attack on the ball and courage are features. Impressive member of the SA U18 team this year.

71 – ADELAIDE – NICK SALTER

Eagles, SA, Tall forward, 30 July 1987, 191.3cm, 94.6kg

There are two schools of thoughts for Adelaide's final selection. It is believed a mature-age SANFL player is in the mix, with Salter the most likely. The other is somewhat of a smokey – James Moss, a promising wicketkeeper, who has been named for the Australian under-19 World Cup cricket squad. Moss could be the bolter, after just five reserves matches with Central District. Others linked with the Crows include Tim Walsh, Austin Wonaeamirri, Henry White, Myke Cook, Matthew Lobbe and Tom McNamara.

Bio: Salter is a solidly built player who has played senior SANFL as a key forward/defender and in the midfield. Penetrating right foot kick, strong at the contest and with good hands.

75 – ADELAIDE – TAYLOR WALKER

NSW/ACT Rams, NSW, Tall forward, April 25 1990, 191.5cm, 86.4kg

Rounding out the five pre-selected players in this year's draft is Walker. He will be the second player chosen via the New South Wales scholarship program, joining Craig Bird (Sydney – No.59). The Crows had the option of keeping Walker as a scholarship player for another year, but they opted to elevate him to their senior list. Recruiting manager Matt Rendell believes Walker is in the top 20 players in his age group in the country.

Bio: Strong marking tall forward from Broken Hill. Goalkicking was a feature while representing NSW/ACT at U18 level in 2007.

 

[crowman_23]

Would definately be very happy if our first few selections pans out like that. Looks good, now we'll just have to keep the fingers crossed for Saturday.

 

[Crow Envy]

No small forward? wouldnt this be more pressing than McCarthy who is another mid range forward.

 

[fightingdreamer88]

Above all else it is incredibly critical that the AFC gets it right with the first pick. DO NOT **** THIS ONE UP RENDELL!!

 

[J-Ro-20]

im very happy with those selections.

im pretty happy with my tips too..i have tipped 5/7 the same players as Burgo.

Mine..
10 - Ebert
27 - Greenwood
30 - Simpson
38 - Jacky
58 - Salter
71 - Petrenko
75 - Walker

 

[Wizard]

im very happy with those selections.

im pretty happy with my tips too..i have tipped 5/7 the same players as Burgo.

Mine..
10 - Ebert
27 - Greenwood
30 - Simpson
38 - Jacky
58 - Salter
71 - Petrenko
75 - Walker

Picking the same as Burgaton isnt really a positive J-Ro.

 

[J-Ro-20]

Picking the same as Burgaton isnt really a positive J-Ro.

hahah that is a point! In my defence I tipped those a couple of days before Burgo so im going to say that Burgo copied my predictions!

 

[macca23]

If Burgatron has it right, then I for one would say that we had a good draft.

I know nothing about McCarthy but all the picks address areas in which we have the greatest need.

Ebert would be the jewel in the crown if we get him.

 

[Crowked]

No small forward?

I wouldnt be all that upset if we didnt get one. We have Johncock, Edwards and Macca who could play that role. All we need is replacements for them in their current positions to free them up. I think one of Macca or Johncock needs to stay down back to provide the run out of D, but one could be our answer to the small forward problem. Edwards has proven he can do it too.

On Burgatrons picks, I like it, I like it a lot!! Ebert is IMO our very best option and I am very much liking the thought of Greenwood on our list too.

 

[Jars458]

I thought Greenwood would go much later in the draft. We are not picking him just because he is from SA and to get him before Port are we? (If we indeed we are)

 

[Crow Envy]

I wouldnt be all that upset if we didnt get one. We have Johncock, Edwards and Macca who could play that role. All we need is replacements for them in their current positions to free them up. I think one of Macca or Johncock needs to stay down back to provide the run out of D, but one could be our answer to the small forward problem. Edwards has proven he can do it too.

On Burgatrons picks, I like it, I like it a lot!! Ebert is IMO our very best option and I am very much liking the thought of Greenwood on our list too.

Edwards and Macca have about 1-2 years left, and Johncock is more valuable than a small crumbing forward. Those players tend to be in and out of the game and we need Johncock to be a constant contributor. It would be nice if he got off his arse and got fit so we could chuck him in the midfield!

 

[Stiffy_18]

I thought Greenwood would go much later in the draft. We are not picking him just because he is from SA and to get him before Port are we? (If we indeed we are)

I very much doubt we would be doing it to get one up on Port. I can see why we would like someone like Greenwood. Tough, hard, has a bit of pace and is a jack of all trades, master of none. Your typical Craig type player.

 

[bus24]

I'd be giving serious consideration to taking Farmer at #27. He's very good.

From what I've heard about Greenwood, he doesn't really sound like a Top 30. Although in this draft, that's probably debatable.

Delighted if Ebert slides to 10, however I just can't see it happening.

And who the **** is John McCarthy? I can't remember ever seeing his name touted around here. Vic Crow, any chance of filling us in?

 

[Macca19]

Greenwood is one of those picks who might go anywhere from from pick 15 through to about pick 70. Just dont know. If you dont get him with your 2nd pick Id half expect us to. We might get him with our first even. Or he might fall heaps late.

If you can get those picks though you'd be laughing. Would be a great draft for you. I think this draft is potentially deeper than a lot of people think

 

[hey shorty]

Edwards and Macca have about 1-2 years left, and Johncock is more valuable than a small crumbing forward. Those players tend to be in and out of the game and we need Johncock to be a constant contributor. It would be nice if he got off his arse and got fit so we could chuck him in the midfield!

Stopping him from smoking would go a long way.

As for Burgatron's draft predictions for us, I have to say I dont mind them too much but we do need a crumbing forward. Having watched Greenwood a few times im not sure we will take him that high up but he wont be there for our next pick so I wouldnt be too unhappy with that. I would love to see Ebert in a Crow jumper but I think its unlikely, we can only hope.

 

[Gets!]

I really want Farmer.

 

[Drummond]

I'd be giving serious consideration to taking Farmer at #27. He's very good.

From what I've heard about Greenwood, he doesn't really sound like a Top 30. Although in this draft, that's probably debatable.

Delighted if Ebert slides to 10, however I just can't see it happening.

And who the **** is John McCarthy? I can't remember ever seeing his name touted around here. Vic Crow, any chance of filling us in?

I had my first draft dream the other night, and we ended up getting David Myers.

I wasn't overly excited with the prospect of Ebert but the more I'm reading the more I like him. Strong, versatile bottom aged midfielder who has good skills and a great mark. We needs midfielders who are tall and can take a strong mark so he would be a good fit.

I’m still hoping Rhys Palmer somehow slips but there’s about a 0.5% chance of that happening.

I hope we take McNamara and I would imagine he'll still be there by 38. I really rate him as he'll be a good replacement for Bassett.

 

[hey shorty]

Greenwood is one of those picks who might go anywhere from from pick 15 through to about pick 70. Just dont know. If you dont get him with your 2nd pick Id half expect us to. We might get him with our first even. Or he might fall heaps late.

If you can get those picks though you'd be laughing. Would be a great draft for you. I think this draft is potentially deeper than a lot of people think

I think its got less absolute gun players than past drafts but after the top few its relatively even all the way as you mentioned with Greenwood. Theres a fair few players in the same boat.

 

[Cap]

I really want Farmer.

there is a TV show for people like you on Ch.9 ?

 

[cocka]

No small forward? wouldnt this be more pressing than McCarthy who is another mid range forward.

Agree completely here Envy. Would of thought crows would take Jacky before McCarthy, and according to Burgan still available at this stage.

 

[Stiffy_18]

there is a TV show for people like you on Ch.9 ?

 

[jumpman5]

with pick 27 (crows) and pick 28 (power), what happens when we grab Greenwood, the safe bet...who will toil in the SANFL for the first three years, play 6 senior games and then gets delsited....

and the POWER pick Marlon Motlop who wins a NAB rising star this year, setting the league alight...

seems all to familiar to me....

what i'm sayin is maybe the crows should take a risk on draft day and possibly reap the benifits as CHOCCO continually does....

 

[SA_Stazza]

I'm happy with his views, as they are quite similar to the line of thought I took with my draft prediction and Burga is usually pretty close to the mark

Ebert would be fantastic at 10 but as I mentioned I believe it will more likely come down to Rioli, Myers, Grimes, Vez or Collier as I expect Ebert to go earlier (fingers crossed he slides!).

I had Greenwood at 27 and Farmer at 38 so not much difference there.

I had Rockliff as a safer out-and-out forward option than McCarthy, mainly due to McCarthy's plagued history of injury (OP) and the fact we will be looking for a specialist forward type and Rockliff fits the bill in that regard more so than the versatile McCarthy who plays further up the ground.

He has earmarked Petrenko and Salter at exactly the same stages I had us to take them so happy with that and also happy I was close to the mark with thoughts of us looking at Callinan as a mature age crumbing forward recruit

He also mentioned a few local players I had deliberated over as Rookie picks in Walsh, Lobbe and White and ofcorse Wonaeamirri who I had us to take as a Rookie

All in all, would be very happy if the draft panned out this way for us, would be a fantastic group of young men coming to the club and a few with strong leadership qualities in Ebert, Greenwood and Farmer which I think we need to focus on attaining out of this draft. It will go a long way towards fast-tracking their development and the development of the other youngsters we bring in not only this year, but just as importantly next year when these blokes are made mentors for our next year's crop of draftees - that and the fact we will be losing the core of our leadership group in that period I'm referring to

 

[Stiffy_18]

with pick 27 (crows) and pick 28 (power), what happens when we grab Greenwood, the safe bet...who will toil in the SANFL for the first three years, play 6 senior games and then gets delsited....

and the POWER pick Marlon Motlop who wins a NAB rising star this year, setting the league alight...

seems all to familiar to me....

what i'm sayin is maybe the crows should take a risk on draft day and possibly reap the benifits as CHOCCO continually does....

Based purely on the balance and needs, I would prefer if we get Motlop instead of Greenwood with pick 27. We need to pinch a goal sneak somewhere and Motlop appears to have those qualities. I would especially take Motlop if we end up with Ebert at our first pick.

That means we get our gun midfielder and then more on and get the goal sneak and hopefully add a tough nut defender/midfielder in Mitch Farmer at 30.

 

[fightingdreamer88]

Based purely on the balance and needs, I would prefer if we get Motlop instead of Greenwood with pick 27. We need to pinch a goal sneak somewhere and Motlop appears to have those qualities. I would especially take Motlop if we end up with Ebert at our first pick.

That means we get our gun midfielder and then more on and get the goal sneak and hopefully add a tough nut defender/midfielder in Mitch Farmer at 30.

Well my son, unless the AFC is planning to bite the bullet and send Johncock forward (or even try McLeod up there), the club would be ****ing stupid not to grab at least one genuine goal sneak. Hell even if they WERE seriously looking at the Johncock move it'd be poor form not to grab one; we've got so many picks, no excuses this year. The pressure is on Rendellion.