Changes for next week

[Shellz]

In: Presti, Leigh Brown, Didak


Who is out?

 

[jonesy86]

In: Presti, L.Brown, Didak and Johnson
Out: N.Brown, Fraser, McCarthy and Goldsack

 

[Frankie23]

The obvious inclusions are Johnno, Didak, L.Brown and Presti. It's a safe bet that these in's will happen.

My guess on the outs; N.Brown, McCarthy, Fraser and Goldy/Blair (out Goldsack on today's game)

They are big ins! Hard bodies and experience

 

[jonesy86]

I'm not 100% on Goldy going out though due to MM and his horses for courses.

Dogs have lots of rangey medium size forwards (Jones, Grant, Hill, Higgins) who Goldsack could be a good match for.

Davis will play as he has done well against Doggies this year.

Blair could be unlucky one to make way for Johnson if it isn't Goldy.

 

[the mighty T]

In: Presti, L.Brown, Didak and Johnson
Out: N.Brown, Fraser, McCarthy and Goldsack

simple as that

Fraser, 200 and out

 

[the mighty T]

I'm not 100% on Goldy going out though due to MM and his horses for courses.

Dogs have lots of rangey medium size forwards (Jones, Grant, Hill, Higgins) who Goldsack could be a good match for.

Davis will play as he has done well against Doggies this year.

Blair could be unlucky one to make way for Johnson if it isn't Goldy.

i'd be shattered...hes been a gem, really stepped up (and hes good for drawing free kicks if he realizes it )

hes earned himself a spot, give him a go mick!

 

[mattys123]

In: Presti, L.Brown, Didak and Johnson
Out: N.Brown, Fraser, McCarthy and Goldsack

No more need for discussion.

If Presti doesn't come up, Brown or Goldsack get a reprieve, otherwise thats the 4 changes, and they simply are not disputable.

 

[Syphoncom]

In: Presti, L.Brown, Didak and Johnson
Out: N.Brown, Fraser, McCarthy and Goldsack

Agree.

2/4 of those are automatic, N.Brown very likely and Nuts around 50/50.

Fraser = Brown
N.Brown = Presti

Dids will make way if he's fit and the only other spots he could realistically take would be Blair or Davis. I'm liking both of those, and with Johnson being so important to the team can't see him not making his way in either.

Looks good.

 

[daics_35]

No more need for discussion.

If Presti doesn't come up, Brown or Goldsack get a reprieve, otherwise thats the 4 changes, and they simply are not disputable.

Spot on, if Presti doesnt come up i think Brown will be the lucky one and stay but Goldsack deffs needs to be dropped.

 

[Medders_7]

In: Presti, L.Brown, Didak and Johnson
Out: N.Brown, Fraser, McCarthy and Goldsack

This.

Brown, Fraser and McCarthy simply aren't up to AFL standard. Goldsack is, but I think he's simply run out of steam, maybe complacent about his stop in the side even.

Hopefully we can beat the dogs though, I think a week off for us will be paramount.

 

[TradeDraft]

In: Presti, L.Brown, Didak and Johnson
Out: N.Brown, Fraser, McCarthy and Goldsack

I agree 9999999999999999999999999999999999999999999%

 

[Boris the Contradiction]

IN: L Brown, A Didak, B Johnson, S Prestigiacomo
OUT: J Fraser, S Sidebottom, J McCarthy, N Brown

Sidebottom's played 1 good game in 10 weeks. I don't care if people consider him a "good finals player". That's based on 1 juniors game and 1 final last year. His form does not warrant selection and Davis looked promising this week. If we're serious about picking on form, Sidebottom should be nowhere near the team at the moment.

 

[ash84]

I liked Sidebottoms game, shows good composure, which we need in finals.. Would rather him than Johnson

 

[surfer1]

IN: L Brown, A Didak, B Johnson, S Prestigiacomo
OUT: J Fraser, S Sidebottom, J McCarthy, N Brown

Sidebottom's played 1 good game in 10 weeks. I don't care if people consider him a "good finals player". That's based on 1 juniors game and 1 final last year. His form does not warrant selection and Davis looked promising this week. If we're serious about picking on form, Sidebottom should be nowhere near the team at the moment.

mmm I must have watched a different game or should I saw 10 games

 

[rose jam]

The 4 ins are obvious.

3 outs are obvious.

Just leaves Blair or Goldy as the 4th out. Goldy's touch is poor since returning from a week off so I think he might be the one, although generally he has plenty to match up on against the Doggies.

 

[jonesy86]

Just seen fox sports news... ch10 highlighted an incident involving Wellingham and Mitchell.

Wellingham could be in trouble for striking. Intentional/reckless, high contact, low impact. Depending on intentional/reckless would be 1wk/reprimand with early plea, assuming he has no priors.

 

[Dicky_Knee]

Will be a massive shame if Blair misses out, i really like how this kids goes about his business.

 

[zorbadunde]

Sidebottom has to be out for me. Seems to be making some bad decisions as of late and his disposal in the last month has been shocking.

 

[THATSGOLD]

blair is safe.. why even bring him up in this thread. Its like saying swan isn't safe. stupid!

 

[derro]

sidebottom wtf u smoking no way in hell id drop him
3 outs are obvious brown fraser and mcarthy....jonno may come in for someone prolly blair i guess but i woud like blair given a shot

 

[Syphoncom]

If Ben is fit there's no reason he shouldn't come in. He's the most underrated played in our team for mine.

 

[jefffff34]

My changes were in another thread but they were the same four as up above.

 

[pants forever]

Depend on the Dogs a bit, would have thought if Presti doesn't come up and mail is he wont be right until prelim final, then who takes Hall - Brown stronger, Reid athletic.. If Hahn plays, maybe Brown to Hall and Reid to Hahn.

Leaves Johnson in - might be Toovey under the pump, Goldsack has more match ups

Didak, L Brown. = Fraser, McCarthy

 

[knightwheelrqr]

Interesting my combinations has not yet had a mention:

In: Didak, Prestigiacomo, L.Brown, B.Johnson,

Out: McCarthy, N.Brown, Fraser, Davis

With Davis as first emg. Have Blair slightly edging Davis at this stage. Goldsack's form at AFL level has been outstanding and shouldn't be dropped. Sidebottom while his 2nd half to the season has been ok without being great his past 2 weeks have been better than most, so losing his spot now would be a big surprise.

For mine it's out of Blair/ Davis for the final spot.

 

[jonesy86]

Davis has played well against the Dogs this year and was ok today... definite to stay in IMO.