Unofficial Preview Changes v Giants Round 7?

[M Malice]

Finally we have something to talk about, I don't think Fages will be making too many changes after 1 bad game.

Reminder- We only have 5 players to consider for prospective changes ie. Answerth, Matheison, Skinner, Witherden and Robertson.

Outs- Linc McCarthy, Stef Martin.

Ins- Sam Skinner, Noah Answerth.

 

[MSB ROYS]

Finally we have something to talk about, I don't think Fages will be making too many changes after 1 bad game.

Reminder- We only have 5 players to consider for prospective changes ie. Answerth, Matheison, Skinner, Witherden and Robertson.

Outs- Linc McCarthy, Stef Martin.

Ins- Sam Skinner, Noah Answerth.

Mitch very unlikely.

 

[M Malice]

Mitch very unlikely.

Yer forgot about Mitch, Mitch out Matho in.

 

[Dylan12]

Reminder- We only have 5 players to consider for prospective changes ie. Answerth, Matheison, Skinner, Witherden and Robertson.

Call in the replacements I say.

Get on the blower to Christensen and Cox and get them down. Skinner and Mathieson also in.

Out - Robinson (injured), Martin (rested / injured), Birchall (omitted), McCarthy (omitted)

 

[MSB ROYS]

Out. Mitch (injured), Birchall and McCarthy.
In. Matho, Answeth and Robertson.

 

[dlanod]

Reminder- We only have 5 players to consider for prospective changes ie. Answerth, Matheison, Skinner, Witherden and Robertson.

Not really true. We can fly players down from Brisbane.

 

[MSB ROYS]

Call in the replacements I say.

Get on the blower to Christensen and Cox and get them down. Skinner and Mathieson also in.

Out - Robinson (injured), Martin (rested / injured), Birchall (omitted), McCarthy (omitted)

I like the idea of Christensen playing as well.

 

[jackess]

Out: Robinson (injured/dropped)
In: Robertson

Out: Birchall (rested/dropped)
In: Witherden

 

[Big Sauce 21]

Robinson, Martin, Ah Chee, Berry all out

Witho one of the ins

 

[MSB ROYS]

Out: Robinson (injured/dropped)
In: Robertson

Out: Birchall (rested/dropped)
In: Witherden

I'm still worried about lack of pace in defence with Witherden against the Giants.

 

[M Malice]

Robinson, Martin, Ah Chee, Berry all out

Witho one of the ins

Ah Chee was good tonight, Tom Berry I assume?

 

[MSB ROYS]

Robinson, Martin, Ah Chee, Berry all out

Witho one of the ins

No chance Ah Chee gets dropped.

 

[Big Sauce 21]

No chance Ah Chee gets dropped.

Offers nothing.

 

[Dylan12]

We need more pace off half back and for that reason I'd like Cox in.

As for Christensen, the little fella just makes things happen and is generally good for a goal or two a game and always worries opposition into giving a free against him.

 

[MSB ROYS]

Offers nothing.

Did tonight but I agree that he was lucky to be in the team. At least he offers run.

 

[Nunez]

If Robbo is out (11 days is a long time)

I'd be going:


Out: Robbo, Birchall
In: Witherdon, Dev Robertson

Robertson to play HFF and have McCluggage and Ah Chee on the wings with Berry etc rotating.

I'd also be bringing in CEY for Berry Jr if he's fit and able. Missed that second big bodied mid to block for us this week. Matho may be an option too

 

[M Malice]

It's going to be a looooonng wait to find out the team for Saturday week.

 

[Jivlain]

Out: Stef (managed), Birchall (omitted), Robinson (injured)
In: Skinner, Answerth, CEY (or Mathieson if unavailable)

 

[CarterS]

If Witherden can't find a way in next week I'll be shocked.

 

[Dylan12]

I'd actually be dropping Starcevich too.

You can't be making some of the most elementary mistakes he did tonight and retain your place. That major clanger of even attempting and then missing your target from 20m out when a sea of Geelong players was around whoever he was trying to hit was appalling.

Even in the first half he was exposed on multiple occasions.

I'd bring in Witherden and see what he can do; let's just hope its more than some of the crap he dished up last year.

 

[StevoJenkins]

Witherden in for Birchall - he's really starting to show his age

Christenson or Dev for Robbo - I'd prefer to put in Dev as it's about time we gave some opportunities to the younger players

Skinner in for Steph - with Omac in full time ruck

I'd also like to see Payne get a game, but it's not going to happen against the giants.

Edit: I'd put Matho in for McCarthy as well. Might get some good goals through free kicks

 

[Mighty Lions]

Finally we have something to talk about, I don't think Fages will be making too many changes after 1 bad game.

Reminder- We only have 5 players to consider for prospective changes ie. Answerth, Matheison, Skinner, Witherden and Robertson.

Outs- Linc McCarthy, Stef Martin.

Ins- Sam Skinner, Noah Answerth.

Answerth cant get a possession in the praccy match's...why would you promote him? Witherden if a backman needs to come in

 

[jackess]

Answerth cant get a possession in the praccy match's...why would you promote him? Witherden if a backman needs to come in

Then why was he part of the touring squad?

 

[Berry Picker]

Bundy for McCarthy needs to happen. He's not making much of an impact when rotating to the mid. Down forward he's playing as a marking forward, which is getting in the way of our bigger guys. My opinion is we need a guy who can sit in front of hipwood, McStay and Oscar to feed on the scraps.

 

[dizzysquizz]

Witherden in for Birchall - he's really starting to show his age

Christenson or Dev for Robbo - I'd prefer to put in Dev as it's about time we gave some opportunities to the younger players

Skinner in for Steph - with Omac in full time ruck

I'd also like to see Payne get a game, but it's not going to happen against the giants.

Edit: I'd put Matho in for McCarthy as well. Might get some good goals through free kicks

I tend to disagree, I am a massive fan of Payne and think this would be a perfect game for him, GWS have 3 taller forwards, Finlayson, Cameron and Himmelberg.
I would love to see Matho get a shot, we really missed another bigger body around the ball last night.