Changes V Melbourne

[PAFCsince1870]

Keen to see full games from Amon and Ah Chee this week.

 

[Shaucob_Burjan]

Going to go against the grain.

Wouldn't replace Trengove with a defender. I think we're too tall in the backlines. Carlile, Hombsch, Jonas our key talls.

 

[vonno]

Out: Cornes, Trengove, S. Gray

In: Hoon, Moore, Clurey because why not

 

[Arsene Wenger]

Going to go against the grain.

Wouldn't replace Trengove with a defender. I think we're too tall in the backlines. Carlile, Hombsch, Jonas our key talls.

I don't mind this either. Get another good ball user back there.

 

[edgie]

Going to go against the grain.

Wouldn't replace Trengove with a defender. I think we're too tall in the backlines. Carlile, Hombsch, Jonas our key talls.

Agree, with Westhoff to fill holes IF necessary.

 

[1954]

Out. Expectation
In. Reckless Abandon

There was a stripper named Gaye Abandon in Adelaide in the 60's, I wonder if Reckless Abandon is related to her.

 

[Shaucob_Burjan]

OUT Cornes, Trengove, White, Krakouer, S. Gray
IN Moore, Ah Chee, Young, Broadbent, Neade

Agree that Krakouer is not fit enough. Broadbent for his poor form is better than anyone except Pittard at dictating play off the half back flank. Stewart in if not Broadbent. Gray back to his 50/50 rotation forward/midfield.

Young as the impact sub. 3/4 sub out is for the one playing worse out of Ryder/Lobbe.

 

[Andre]

We're too tall down back, but whether we bring in Clurey and drop Jonas as the quasi-tall or leave Jonas in, comes down to, does Melbourne play 3 genuine talls forward usually? I haven't watched them enough in 2015 to know that.

If they are going to play 3 talls (or 2 talls and a resting ruck) most of the game I'd bring in Clurey for Jonas.
For the rest:

Outs: Cornes, Trengove, S. Gray, White
Ins: Moore, Ah Chee, Neade, Young.

Young sub. I definitely want a full game from Amon, with Polec out and White playing slow through something we need his injection of pace across 4 quarters. And Wines was passable tonight and will get better the next couple as he gets back up to speed, but we definitely need more grunt in the guts. Time for Moore to stop being 'potential' and start being 'here'. If Ah Chee does across 4 quarters what he's done in his single quarters so far, the Moore or Young debate will soon be which gets picked after the arch.

 

[FishingRick04]

Going to go against the grain.

Wouldn't replace Trengove with a defender. I think we're too tall in the backlines. Carlile, Hombsch, Jonas our key talls.

We are when Westhoff is basically a permanent loose back the days

 

[drcollossimo]

What I want:

OUT: S.Gray(******* duh), Trengove, White and Cornes
IN: Neade, Moore, Clurey and Ah Chee
Jonas gets spared thanks to Trengove going down

What we'll get:

OUT: Cornes, Trengove
IN: Colquoun, O'Shea or some bullshit like that.

I remember when baffling selection decisions were a weekly occurrence like they are now .....ah 2011-12 good times those

 

[Chokito]

OUT: Cornes (forever), Trengove (injured), S Gray (not good enough)
IN: Young, Broadbent, A MOTHERF***ING PLAN B.

 

[Sneeky]

I'd really love to see Stewart get a crack. Just have a feeling he'll take the opportunity and actually show some grunt and heart. Hammer, although an average game, was the only one willing to take it up to the dirty Richmond players today. We need some big bodies and people who aren't afraid to throw their weight around

 

[Dopamine]

Out: soccer player's physique
In: AFL player's physique

 

[ROBBBO]

Hartlett MUST be dropped, he needs to go back and go find the footy again, accepting mediocrity is why this team is where it is. In so many ways I'd prefer Youngy who gets in and has a go. Hammer YOU ARENT AS GOOD AS YOU THINK YOU ARE AND ONLY HARD WORK WILL GET YOU TO WHERE YOU SHOULD BE! HARDEN UP OR BUGGER OFF!!! STOP BEING A PUSSY
Carlisle looks to be overweight again, yes has a bad back, so strengthening the abs surely is a priority - he is no good to us being 5 yards behind his man like he was tonight. He was woeful tonight. Stick him in the pool until he has webbed feet this week.
Sam Gray inclusion was baffling - selection committee, if you could be dropped for this error, then quite clearly you would be in the ressies next week - an absolutely horrendous call that had every Power supporter wide eyed and shaking their heads in disbelief.
In: Neade or Colquhuon for Gray, Moore for Cornes and then bring Stewart as a third tall defender

 

[TeeKray]

OUT - Cornes (retired), Trengove (injured), White, S.Gray, Impey
IN - Young, Stewart, Neade, Ah Chee, Broadbent

 

[HighBudget]

Out- Schulz kicking no goals
In- Schulz doing what he's paid to do and kick goals

We could have won today had he done this simple task instead of missing every set shot

 

[Wargreymon90]

Don't know why ken loves playing impey. Doesn't have the composure for AFL yet. I'd much rather Broadbent

Out: Cornes, gray, imp, Trengove
In: Moore, NEADE!, young, Broadbent

Ah chee for either of Moore or young also works

 

[Schulzenfest]

Impey's OK but he needs to learn the art of infringing on your opponent without making it look super obvious that he's doing so. Jonas is great at it. #taliaisacheat is the master of it. Impey can't seem to defend without it being quite apparent that he's scragging.

 

[PowerLil]

Size please. Footballers not runners.

 

[Adz2332]

OUT Crones (ret.) Trengove (inj) Krak (inj?) Sam Gray (stupid selection) White (or sub)
IN Moore, Broadbent, Hoon, Young

Jonas and westhoff on thin ice

 

[JimmyBeerCans]

Gotta pick Moore and Young for mine I'd have them a touch ahead of Ah Chee but he's in the mix too

Drop S. Gray for Neade... I'll never understand the S. Gray upgrade

 

[finbarr]

There seems to be a perception amongst some that Moore and Young are slow. They're not. Bring them both in.

 

[JimmyBeerCans]

There seems to be a perception amongst some that Moore and Young are slow. They're not. Bring them both in.

Young is a good mover can regularly find space on opponents and Moore ain't slow either not sure why people think he's a plodder.

 

[bomberclifford]

Out: Cornes (ret), Trengove (inj), Hartlett (omit), White (omit)
In: Moore, Clurey, Young, Achee

We just need to win this next game.

 

[Holden Hillbilly]

In: At least 2 forwards (1 big and 1 small) to stay in the forward 50 at all times.

Out: 18 players in the other teams half