Preview Changes v North Melbourne

[Shupe]

I was drawn on that. But Smith finished strongly with some good decision making in defense. It was only 2-3 touches and they where all handballs but they where in scoring chains or generated good attacking movements.

As opposed to 2-3 touches earlier that directly resulted in opposition goals?

 

[Eastern Rangers]

Mate he played four minutes of good footy - far from great

And a lot of solid football to back up those minutes.

 

[Eastern Rangers]

As opposed to 2-3 touches earlier that directly resulted in opposition goals?

It was two.

I was more commenting on the fact that the sub choice didn't work against us.

 

[richcogs]

Surely you won't drop Dalziell played one quarter and got 11 possession and a goal. That is running at a 44 possession 4 goal average over 4 quarters.

 

[Shupe]

I was more commenting on the fact that the sub choice didn't work against us.

Certainly not.

 

[Shupe]

Surely you won't drop Dalziell played one quarter and got 11 possession and a goal. That is running at a 44 possession 4 goal average over 4 quarters.

There's a significant advantage coming on whilst everyone has already been playing for three quarters. It's a matter of Masten v Kerr v Dalziell. Unfortunately for Dazzle, the other two are a class above.

 

[richcogs]

There's a significant advantage coming on whilst everyone has already been playing for three quarters. It's a matter of Masten v Kerr v Dalziell. Unfortunately for Dazzle, the other two are a class above.

Hutchings would be dropped over him 15 possession 4 clangers in 88 % game time!

 

[DickDunn]

Surely you won't drop Dalziell played one quarter and got 11 possession and a goal. That is running at a 44 possession 4 goal average over 4 quarters.

 

[Carbine Chaos]

Surely you won't drop Dalziell played one quarter and got 11 possession and a goal. That is running at a 44 possession 4 goal average over 4 quarters.

That's not how it works.

 

[Shupe]

Hutchings would be dropped over him 15 possession 4 clangers in 88 % game time!

Yes he will. Ok, let's look at it this way then. You must select two of these players.

Masten v Kerr v Hutchings v Dalziell.

I just left out Hutchings before because he was the obvious other candidate to be dropped.

 

[Shupe]

That's not how it works.

Are you telling me he won't have 88 disposals and 8 goals over two games?

 

[jknothimjustafan]

Out: Smith, Hutchings (a little unlucky), Brown (if Waters fit, unlucky)

In: Masten, Kerr, Waters (if fit)

Sub: Gaff

 

[Keys]

Smith was pretty average at times today but I think he'll be kept for next week. Carlton exposed us badly for pace in our back half and north have their fair share of small speedy forwards so smith may be needed

Waters is more likely to come in for Brennan than smith

If masten and Kerr are fit they come in for Hutchins then dalziell

Anyone else pushing to come in?

 

[Shupe]

Anyone else pushing to come in?

Dick fits so perfectly here...

 

[Keys]

Dick fits so perfectly here...

Speak for yourself

 

[Suma Magic]

A few suggesting we drop 2 defenders and only bring in one.

We play 7 defenders every single game. There is zero chance we'll play 6 next week.

 

[anti_]

Whilst Smith is fast, you hardly see him use it. He surely has to be dropped, he was deplorable.

Out: Smith, Hutchings (He was ok), Dalziell (unlucky)
In: Masten, Kerr, Waters

Dalziell played well as the sub today, but looking at the big picture, he's not in our best 22. He has shown some worth this year though.

With those 3 ins, i reckon we're just about at full strength.

Wouldn't mind seeing Dick in there at some stage too.

 

[stralia]

we are all meant to change our avatars now for this week only.

In: Brad Scott avatar
Out: your original avatar

seriously

In: Kerr, Masten, Waters.
Out: Smith, Brennan, 50/50 between Hutchings, Dazelle, maybe even Gaff

I support this endeavour.

 

[Chris_6678]

Think we give Gaff a rest for a week or 2 and let him get some confidence in the WAFL.

 

[Convocation]

With Kerr, masto and waters all coming into the side next week, Gaff and Shuey will all of a sudden look a lot better, because they won't be tagged and if they are someone else will get off the chain.
Shep was good today, brown was good today as well but a tall needed to come out despite how putrid smith was all day.
Dalziel was ok (Rosa made his handball forgotten) but he is not in best 22. Happy with Hutchins, but might be relegated to a sub, at best case scenario.
Will be a lot more inside 50's next week with ins we have coming back

 

[idmfts]

The three ins are obvious (Kerr, Waters, Masto) - Smith the only obvious out.
Dalziell, Brennan and Hutchy are the likely ones to miss out. Would like to see Hutch retained though.

 

[Carbine Chaos]

Are we all changing our avatars?

 

[Arthaus]

First time in a "change" thread I have not seen Razzles name?
Whats going on haters?

In Kerr Masten Waters
Out Smith Shep Hutchings

 

[squashface]

Time to change the avatars

 

[Carbine Chaos]

Time to change the avatars

Eagles board unite!!!