Chaplin or Petrie

[powaflag08]

Who is the better player.

Obviously we saw how good Chappy was in the last 8 games of 2007 and has carried his form into this year.

Drew Petrie is now a solid CHB actually went to my high school.

Who is the better player???

 

[Roos4eva]

Petrie because of the different positions he can play.

If we had another Petrie in our team, we'd be top two.

 

[Thewlis Dish]

We wouldn't be close to top two, but Drew has certainly turned his career around in the past two years.

 

[Salopek31]

And here I was thinking North supporters might respect Chaplin after his BOG effort in last year's prelim final.

 

[Roos4eva]

We wouldn't be close to top two, but Drew has certainly turned his career around in the past two years.

Yeah, slight exaggeration but it'd solve a lot of problems in our side if we had two Petries.

 

[Shaucob_Burjan]

chaplin pretty darn easily.

 

[powaflag08]

Petrie because of the different positions he can play.

If we had another Petrie in our team, we'd be top two.

Just because he can play 2 different positions doesn't make him better.

Chappy is obviously a much better defender and if given the chance would go ok as a forward imo.

Did anyone see his 60m goal on the run on sunday?

 

[Thewlis Dish]

Just because he can play 2 different positions doesn't make him better.

Chappy is obviously a much better defender and if given the chance would go ok as a forward imo.

Did anyone see his 60m goal on the run on sunday?

So why start a poll if it's so clear cut?

And he's not a "much better defender".

 

[powaflag08]

Chappy was 9-5 down now has jumped back to 10-9 up.