List Mgmt. Collingwood Trade Talk 2015

[JB1975]

Nothing more certain he will be a Cat

I have a feeling we are a chance to get screwed with Trelor

The deal hasn't been done. The only thing that can get screwed in relation to Treloar are our expectations. I think that we should expect less.

 

[Medders123]

Pretty interesting article about how we could feasibly get Treloar and Dangerfield!!! (presuming Adelaide matches any offer)

http://www.theroar.com.au/2015/08/25/where-to-for-patrick-dangerfield/

However if the persistent rumours of Treloar prove to be true, and the Magpies trade their first round draft pick for him, a Dangerfield move to Collingwood could still be possible.

Aish could be on traded to Adelaide for Collingwood’s second round draft pick and a player (possibly Paul Seedsman), while his good mate Scharenberg would join him.

Adelaide get two local boys who were both first round picks, Greater Western Sydney get an important first round selection in this year’s national draft, which they would use for one of their academy players, while the Lions receive a second round draft pick and a player.

And of course the Magpies get Dangerfield and Treloar.

 

[Kappa]

Could we fit Treloar and Danger into our cap? Front end one, back end the other for example?

Not a chance.

Guys like Cloke are taking up wayyy too much of the salary cap.

 

[SpongePie]

Danger is going to Geelong nothing more certain

Apparently the hawks are big into him.

 

[ThePhantom777]

Pretty interesting article about how we could feasibly get Treloar and Dangerfield!!! (presuming Adelaide matches any offer)

http://www.theroar.com.au/2015/08/25/where-to-for-patrick-dangerfield/

Would you give up Scharenberg and Aish for Danger? I think I would. Danger and Treloar are known quantities and we would be an instant premiership contender. Imagine Swan, Pendles, Danger, Treloar rotating mid and forward!

 

[ThePhantom777]

Apparently the hawks are big into him.

But Hawks will lose Mitchell, Lewis, Hodge and Lake over next few seasons. So will eventually come down. Few sides figuring out how to beat them, Tigers and Port recently.

 

[Maggie5]

Would you give up Scharenberg and Aish for Danger? I think I would. Danger and Treloar are known quantities and we would be an instant premiership contender. Imagine Swan, Pendles, Danger, Treloar rotating mid and forward!

I would throw in the kitchen sink and anything else not bolted down for those two.

 

[BEEG]

Apparently the hawks are big into him.

That would be right * me they are good at landing big names

 

[Saintly Viewed]

Are you sure you're certain?

I'm certain danger f is going to Geelong
I'm also certain I could be wrong

 

[Tbone McGraw]

I am not sure we could afford Treloar and Danger. Treloar will be about 700k and Danger over 1mio.

We then have our players on decent coin like Pendles, Cloke, Reid?, Sidey? among any others i have forgotten.

However i am very confident we get Treloar and Aish.

 

[Tbone McGraw]

FWIW, I have a feeling Danger may stay at Adelaide but really no idea. Just a feeling.

 

[Saintly Viewed]

Could we fit Treloar and Danger into our cap? Front end one, back end the other for example?

Dangerfield is the exception, that elite talent, yes you would have to see what we had to give up to get the danger.
Getting both danger and Treloar that's time to wet yourself.

 

[ottoman]

I have read through this thread and it has been very informative. Basically to save others reading through the thread I have made a quick summary below dividing the information into "good news" and "bad news"

GOOD NEWS

There is a very good chance the the trade period will see us picking up
Treloar
Carlisle
Dangerfield
Kruzer
Aish
And Shazza is almost certain to stay

BAD NEWS

We probably will not be picking up
Treloar
Carlisle
Dangerfield
Kruzer
Aish
And Shazza is almost certain to leave.

 

[BEEG]

FWIW, I have a feeling Danger may stay at Adelaide but really no idea. Just a feeling.

He would have signed by now it's not like his value will go up if he plays out the remainder of the year

Bloke is gone just like Ablett

 

[popin]

I have read through this thread and it has been very informative. Basically to save others reading through the thread I have made a quick summary below dividing the information into "good news" and "bad news"

GOOD NEWS

There is a very good chance the the trade period will see us picking up
Treloar
Carlisle
Dangerfield
Kruzer
Aish
And Shazza is almost certain to stay

BAD NEWS

We probably will not be picking up
Treloar
Carlisle
Dangerfield
Kruzer
Aish
And Shazza is almost certain to leave.

What does the fox say?

 

[Tbone McGraw]

He would have signed by now it's not like his value will go up if he plays out the remainder of the year

Bloke is gone just like Ablett

Maybe but i have heard he is massively torn over his decision.

The unfortunate death of Phil Walsh has swayed him in a big way.

He was gone as much as 3 months ago

 

[ottoman]

What does the fox say?

I actually spent some time listening to some of their other songs. They have a few good ones but the fox is the best.
I will forever be grateful to you for introducing me to such musical talent

 

[Medders123]

Would you give up Scharenberg and Aish for Danger? I think I would. Danger and Treloar are known quantities and we would be an instant premiership contender. Imagine Swan, Pendles, Danger, Treloar rotating mid and forward!

I probably would as well. That midfield would be a sight to see!

 

[Scodog10]

Pretty interesting article about how we could feasibly get Treloar and Dangerfield!!! (presuming Adelaide matches any offer)

http://www.theroar.com.au/2015/08/25/where-to-for-patrick-dangerfield/

Thanks for posting, but I have to ask if the author has confused supercoach with real life?

 

[THATSGOLD]

How do we end up with Aish? Brisbane are w***ers and won't do good deals.

 

[Tbone McGraw]

How do we end up with Aish? Brisbane are ******s and won't do good deals.

Aish is out of contract (unlike Beams last year) and he wants out. If he nominates us, which he apparently has, they may struggle to have any say.

Players generally get where they want these days.

 

[Medders123]

Thanks for posting, but I have to ask if the author has confused supercoach with real life?

Yeah it does seem a lot like wishful thinking. The major stumbling block is salary cap.

 

[theteamtobeat]

Aish is out of contract (unlike Beams last year) and he wants out. If he nominates us, which he apparently has, they may struggle to have any say.

Players generally get where they want these days.

He is going to cost a first round pick (10-18) either way. Can't use the PSD as a threat because we got pick 1 and Carlton got pick 2. Plus Bell wants to come home so Carlton will offer Bell + second round pick for Aish. Only option is that 2016 first round pick or a three way trade involving Scheranberg, Crows first round and Aish.

 

[jmac70]

He is going to cost a first round pick (10-18) either way. Can't use the PSD as a threat because we got pick 1 and Carlton got pick 2. Plus Bell wants to come home so Carlton will offer Bell + second round pick for Aish. Only option is that 2016 first round pick or a three way trade involving Scheranberg, Crows first round and Aish.

You can have Karnezis back for him.

 

[si tacuisses]

He is going to cost a first round pick (10-18) either way. Can't use the PSD as a threat because we got pick 1 and Carlton got pick 2. Plus Bell wants to come home so Carlton will offer Bell + second round pick for Aish. Only option is that 2016 first round pick or a three way trade involving Scheranberg, Crows first round and Aish.

Our first rounders are untouchable.