List Mgmt. Collingwood Trade Talk 2015

[popin]

He is going to cost a first round pick (10-18) either way. Can't use the PSD as a threat because we got pick 1 and Carlton got pick 2. Plus Bell wants to come home so Carlton will offer Bell + second round pick for Aish. Only option is that 2016 first round pick or a three way trade involving Scheranberg, Crows first round and Aish.

Thanks for sharing schwaby

 

[BEEG]

Looked at Aish's draft preview he had the highest kicking efficiency at u18 titles

That's good enough for me

 

[THATSGOLD]

He is going to cost a first round pick (10-18) either way. Can't use the PSD as a threat because we got pick 1 and Carlton got pick 2. Plus Bell wants to come home so Carlton will offer Bell + second round pick for Aish. Only option is that 2016 first round pick or a three way trade involving Scheranberg, Crows first round and Aish.

So for us trading Scharenberg to get Aish doesn't really improve us.

 

[Chrispiesssss]

I'm gonna go out on a limb and say that Aish and scharenberg will probably be playing at the same club next year.
Great mates according to their earlier Instagram photos. They'll either be at Collingwood or one of the Adelaide teams. #captainobvious

 

[SApies]

He is going to cost a first round pick (10-18) either way. Can't use the PSD as a threat because we got pick 1 and Carlton got pick 2. Plus Bell wants to come home so Carlton will offer Bell + second round pick for Aish. Only option is that 2016 first round pick or a three way trade involving Scheranberg, Crows first round and Aish.

Carlton won't have a say if Aish is to nominate Collingwood. Gone are the days of bidding wars.
If Aish nominates Collingwood a deal will get done. As it will if he were to nominate Carlton or Adelaide.

 

[Babylove]

He is going to cost a first round pick (10-18) either way. Can't use the PSD as a threat because we got pick 1 and Carlton got pick 2. Plus Bell wants to come home so Carlton will offer Bell + second round pick for Aish. Only option is that 2016 first round pick or a three way trade involving Scheranberg, Crows first round and Aish.

Aish would have to agree to go to Carlton for you to be able to trade with them (not saying he wouldn't but worth remembering) that is why we couldn't bring GC into the equation last year for Beams.

Seriously though I have been hearing rumours that the Lions are into Oxley (who is a Queenslander) and/or Seedsman. Would have thought that if one of those players was in the mix that they could be paired with a second rounder, though I agree that if it's a draft pick only the 2016 1st rounder would be around the mark.

 

[left at home]

if we had to loose one of Oxley or seedsman for aish I would pick the ox, but only just.

 

[Jelly Bean]

if we had to loose one of Oxley or seedsman for aish I would pick the ox, but only just.

I'd give them both

 

[left at home]

I'd give them both

fair enough. I just think seedy is not a hbf player , a natural wing type and that's where
I would play him, not a natural defender. the ox a very good mark and kick, but on the slow
side of running

 

[Saintly Viewed]

If we can keep the seed. Mainly think if he gets a full pre season and we going well he will shine - need nice smooth runners. But it will be up to him to take the next steps

 

[gtrain23]

If we can keep the seed. Mainly think if he gets a full pre season and we going well he will shine - need nice smooth runners. But it will be up to him to take the next steps

Seed is a absolute soft ****

 

[Saintly Viewed]

Seed is a absolute soft ****

Ok

 

[Bloben]

If Brisbane are interested in Seedsman and Oxley then would the two players themselves be enough to get the deal done or would we need to throw in a pick?

My ideal trade scenario would be:
Witts > mid-late first round pick
Witts pick, 2nd round pick 2015 and 2nd round pick 2016 > Treloar
Seedsman, Oxley and 3rd round pick > Aish

Then we use our pick 8ish this year and keep next year's first rounder too.

 

[Apex36]

He is going to cost a first round pick (10-18) either way. Can't use the PSD as a threat because we got pick 1 and Carlton got pick 2. Plus Bell wants to come home so Carlton will offer Bell + second round pick for Aish. Only option is that 2016 first round pick or a three way trade involving Scheranberg, Crows first round and Aish.

Come on buddy, I can understand GWS supporters coming up with rubbish like this, but Brisbane supporters more than anyone should know how this works. If Aish nominates a club, other clubs trade offers are irrelevant. You're just setting yourself up for dissapointment if you think there will be a bidding war for Aish between the pies and Carlton.

 

[Unknown Identity]

Seedsman certainly sleeps with the lights on.
If he can be involved in getting Aish, i endorse it..

 

[good4footy]

He is going to cost a first round pick (10-18) either way. Can't use the PSD as a threat because we got pick 1 and Carlton got pick 2. Plus Bell wants to come home so Carlton will offer Bell + second round pick for Aish. Only option is that 2016 first round pick or a three way trade involving Scheranberg, Crows first round and Aish.

Yeah Nah - I reckon this is definitely not the only option.

 

[Mazza12346]

When did they mention this?

Sent from my SM-G925I using Tapatalk

A couple of days ago, they were just chatting about it

 

[jmac70]

Seed is a absolute soft ****

He is not the hardest player going around but it is probably a little harsh to label him a soft ****.

 

[BEEG]

We need to somehow land a pick between 12-17 for a forward

They only way i see us doing that is if we trade Witts to Sydney/Bulldogs

 

[Anzacday]

We need to somehow land a pick between 12-17 for a forward

They only way i see us doing that is if we trade Witts to Sydney/Bulldogs

Witts for Sam Reid?, (+ or - )

 

[NT.Thunder]

Witts for Sam Reid?, (+ or - )

I wouldn't say no to Sam Reid, my only worry would be that if he and his brother are in cycle together with their injury lay off's then we could be in trouble.

Witts is much better than Sam Reid potential wise IMO for their respective roles.

 

[BEEG]

Witts for Sam Reid?, (+ or - )

No we have enough dud forwards

Weirderman would be great have him and Moore developing as future forwards would be massive

 

[Saintly Viewed]

At least everyone agrees that we should trade?
Whom? That's the tricky part.

 

[Unknown Identity]

Lions off Dixon, Leppo says they'll develop forwards internally.

Yes he's a little injury prone but i would love to see him, Cloke and Moore up forward and Reid pushed to defence.

 

[Baird]

Lions off Dixon, Leppo says they'll develop forwards internally.

Yes he's a little injury prone but i would love to see him, Cloke and Moore up forward and Reid pushed to defence.

Gone to Port I think