List Mgmt. Collingwood Trade Talk 2015

[Roverjg]

Paul Seedsman to North Melbourne for their 2nd Round Pick.

North's 2nd Round Pick + Our Current 2nd Round Pick to Brisbane for James Aish.

Nathan Freeman to StKilda for their 2nd Round Pick.

Saint's 2nd Round Pick + 1st Rnd 2016 + 2nd Rnd 2016 for Adam Treloar and Adam Tomlinson

Out: 2015 2nd Round Pick, 2016 1st&2nd Round Picks, Freeman, Seedsman

In: Treloar, Tomlinson, Aish

Leaving us with Pick 7 this year to bring in another gun or use in draft on say Sam Wiedeman or Callum AhChee.

Like it but with the pick I would be happy if we got Ryan Burton who recruiters are describing as a mix of Jack Gunston and Nat Fyfe.

 

[Matz]

Hasn't Hampton nominated Adelaide?

Oh has he? Im still catching up on posts so i havent got that far yet....lol , disregard that post then.

Sent from my SM-G925I using Tapatalk

 

[Babylove]

I reckon if we give up 2 first rounders they will throw in Hampton.

Sent from my SM-G925I using Tapatalk

Hampton has chosen the Crows as his club of choice so he won't be involved in a trade with us unless there is a three way involving Adelaide.

 

[Matz]

Hampton has chosen the Crows as his club of choice so he won't be involved in a trade with us unless there is a three way involving Adelaide.

I don't want a 3 way with adelaide.

Sent from my SM-G925I using Tapatalk

 

[Babylove]

Don't you love though how the media are contradicting themselves with the compo pick for Carlton? In one article they keep saying Kreuzer is almost certain to stay at the Blues and in the next they talk about how the first round draft order is going to be affected by the compo picks for Leuenberger and Kruezer. What are the media expecting that the Blues are going to get a comp pick for keeping him?

 

[jhndos]

Any thoughts of Kennedy / Broomhead or both to either Adelaide club to get us a 1st rounder ?

 

[CasuallyDressed]

Any thoughts of Kennedy / Broomhead or both to either Adelaide club to get us a 1st rounder ?

Kennedy can go but not interested in getting rid of Broomhead.

 

[Matt_352]

Any thoughts of Kennedy / Broomhead or both to either Adelaide club to get us a 1st rounder ?

Kennedy can heck off. Broomhead nope.

 

[ppoiter]

He's living with Mitch and Dylan Orval? How do you know all of this? lol.

If you follow him on instagram theres quite a few pics of them together partying or drinking. Not that theres anything wrong with that

 

[BEEG]

He was told ages ago he wasn't part of our plans mate.

Yeah you could almost see that was high in the plans until about midyear then just dropped off

Good to know we gave him plenty of chances

 

[Scodog10]

Any thoughts of Kennedy to either Adelaide club to get us a 1st rounder ?

6 months ago he might have got us a pick in the 20-25 range. Now though he'll probably be doing well to be in the system in 2017. That's how poor his 2015 was...

 

[Anzacday]

Don't you love though how the media are contradicting themselves with the compo pick for Carlton? In one article they keep saying Kreuzer is almost certain to stay at the Blues and in the next they talk about how the first round draft order is going to be affected by the compo picks for Leuenberger and Kruezer. What are the media expecting that the Blues are going to get a comp pick for keeping him?

If there was a way to do that, the Bluesers would find it

 

[mattys123]

6 months ago he might have got us a pick in the 20-25 range. Now though he'll probably be doing well to be in the system in 2017. That's how poor his 2015 was...

Yep, Kennedy's stocks have dropped dramatically, he won't be traded unless someone offers us overs, or he asks to leave.

I still say we've done ok out of those 3 first round picks, Grundy and Broomhead are going to be long term players, with Brodie being the star of the lot of course.

2 out of 3 ain't bad.

 

[Anzacday]

He's living with Mitch and Dylan Orval? How do you know all of this? lol.

If you follow him on instagram theres quite a few pics of them together partying or drinking. Not that theres anything wrong with that

I saw Mark Orval at the VFL game, he's been in the same paddock as Monkhorst

 

[Shaneprice97]

Seedman and the Orvals have been life long friends, and pretty sure he doesnt live with them, just spends alot of time with them.

 

[wednesdaywarrior]

If you follow him ng. Not that theres anything wrong with that

Sounds like the most fertile ground to plant The Seed would be the Gold Coast.

 

[ant22]

I can't understand why some are suggesting we trade broomhead. He was starting to play good consistent footy before he was injured. Had great composure and good skills which we lack and yet some see him as trade bait. All because he doesn't smile much.

 

[CFC2010]

Sounds like the most fertile ground to plant The Seed would be the Gold Coast.

Hey wednesdaywarrior just noticed your footnote quote......you might want to revise the drug free part!

 

[dlammardo]

Just thought I'd provide some info. in relation to Paul Seedsman and his forthcoming departure.

Buckley and Co have always had very high hopes for Seedsman. His line breaking pace and long kicking always appealed to Buckley and provided a point of difference to our other players.

However, Seedsman has no one else to blame but himself for the fact that he is no longer wanted. The club has been warning Seedsman time and time again this year about his off-field behaviour and his off-field lifestyle in general. When he injured his hip again a week or two after anzac day, they warned him not to go out but he refused to listen. They were disappointed that he chose to live a bad lifestyle instead of dedicating himself to getting his body absolutely right in the way a Pendlebury, or of the new-comers, a Scharenberg would.

All year they have had chats to him about his party lifestyle, yet the penny never dropped for Paul. Paul isn't a bad kid but he lives a lifestyle where he is easily influenced by his group of mates who aren't professional footballers and are able to go out a few times a week. His living arrangements (living with his two mates who do the Angry Dad videos) haven't helped and the club has not been happy with his living arrangements.

It got to a point where the club believed they had spoken to Paul and tried to guide him as much as they could that they have now given up. To put it frankly, they believe he has pissed his AFL career up against the wall. What makes it more disappointing is that Paul loved the club as a kid and if he had a more mature head on his shoulders, would have made a success of his career at Collingwood.

That's interesting. Unfortunately it happens a fair bit. Especially guys that went to private schools. Your school mates usually are using mummy n daddys money and going out every night without a care in the world. Went to one myself so not making assumptions. Libba n Wallis were a year below me at StKevins. From what I've heard from guys in that year, some say Libba's off field troubles are due to his school mates.

Had an inner sactum exp with the club 1st aug when we lost to Melb. Burnsy in his pre match address to us says Collingwood were hopeful Seed would play 150+ games and give us that speed we lacked. Obviously a lot changed in a month.

 

[nahnah]

I haven't given up fully on Kennedy yet but I would trade him for a first rounder, if we don't get Aish then I think there is a spot in our team for Kennedy if he can take it.
Broomhead I would not trade.

 

[Pendles!]

That's interesting. Unfortunately it happens a fair bit. Especially guys that went to private schools. Your school mates usually are using mummy n daddys money and going out every night without a care in the world. Went to one myself so not making assumptions. Libba n Wallis were a year below me at StKevins. From what I've heard from guys in that year, some say Libba's off field troubles are due to his school mates.

Had an inner sactum exp with the club 1st aug when we lost to Melb. Burnsy in his pre match address to us says Collingwood were hopeful Seed would play 150+ games and give us that speed we lacked. Obviously a lot changed in a month.

I was in the same year as Libba through school (Different school, but had mates there) and I started hearing about how much of a loose unit Libba was in year 7. It's a pity for Bulldogs supporters that he isn't more like Mitch Wallis.

 

[spartan-magpie]

I'll miss having little kids because they're... Well, they're amazing. But the sleep thing can go straight to hell. Got one kid out of nappies. Once the second kid masters the loo I'm 'gonna drink Bacardi like it's ma berfday." And I don't even like Bacardi.

I haven't had a full nights sleep in 2 years. Once they get out of nappies, if you're lucky, your son will wake up like clockwork at 12.30-1.30 run in to your room, use your head as climbing apparatus, pull your remaining hair out, wedge himself between you and the wife, and then proceed to kick you in knackers every 20-30 mins like mine does. And the bugger only does it to me. definitely a mummy's boy.



Anyway, I had a trade idea. The gurus here can let me know if it's plausible.

How about. 2016 first rounder and 3 x 2nd rounders (2x 2015, 1 x 2016) for trelaor.


Freeman and pick 7 to saints. For pick 5 and their second.


pick 5 to GC for their second rounder and Bennell.

Seedsman to Brisbane and the fx 2nd rounder for Aish.

We get get treloar, Bennell, and aish. Wouldn't it be nice.

 

[Apex36]

Not allowed

Pretty sure it is, provided we don't trade out this years first. From what I've seen you just can't trade your first and second picks two years running.

 

[wednesdaywarrior]

Hey wednesdaywarrior just noticed your footnote quote......you might want to revise the drug free part!

Well spotted CFC. I was asking for trouble wasn't I!? I'll have to think about an edit and here's hoping for a year of no more Collingwood revelations. Maybe all new recruits should be made to sign a clAuse agreeing to stay away from the st.Kilda festival, rich private school mates and Swannie. By the way are we making a play for Bennell? Oh wait ...

 

[cakewalk06]

I haven't had a full nights sleep in 2 years. Once they get out of nappies, if you're lucky, your son will wake up like clockwork at 12.30-1.30 run in to your room, use your head as climbing apparatus, pull your remaining hair out, wedge himself between you and the wife, and then proceed to kick you in knackers every 20-30 mins like mine does. And the bugger only does it to me. definitely a mummy's boy.



Anyway, I had a trade idea. The gurus here can let me know if it's plausible.

How about. 2016 first rounder and 3 x 2nd rounders (2x 2015, 1 x 2016) for trelaor.


Freeman and pick 7 to saints. For pick 5 and their second.


pick 5 to GC for their second rounder and Bennell.

Seedsman to Brisbane and the fx 2nd rounder for Aish.

We get get treloar, Bennell, and aish. Wouldn't it be nice.

I feel your pain. 2 daughters and both kick like mules. I have taken to using a pillow for protection. Or sleeping on the couch
I'd be happy with treloar and aish. Don't think Bennell is on our radar...