List Mgmt. Collingwood Trade Talk 2016

[TradeDraft]

What I don't understand about Sam Weideman is that if his father Mark played 28 games for us why did he not qualify for father son. I honestly have no clue what the father son system is now and how it works so he might not have been eligible.

He had to play a 100 Games to be Father Son

 

[4tone]

Pies should go to the dogs and get a swap with Tom Boyd and Cloke, The sell would be how do they keep 3 players over a million each which Stringer, Bontempelli and Boyd will be on each within the next 3 years. The Dogs get a guy who needs a change and will dominate with there midfield service and will have another 4 years minimum of good footy, this could be their next Barry Hall. They also easy their PPP. I'm guessing clubs like the blues will be hitting up Bontempelli perfect fit for them and clubs like the Tigers will chase Stringer with huge dollars. The dogs know this is coming, its their own fault by signing Boyd on bid money. The Pies get a 10 year gun, Boyd and Moore WTF. Hibberd would be nice, swap him with Langdon, maybe throw in a Commodore, $ 2000 saving account with Westpac and a trip to Dubai.

 

[Matt_352]

Pies should go to the dogs and get a swap with Tom Boyd and Cloke, The sell would be how do they keep 3 players over a million each which Stringer, Bontempelli and Boyd will be on each within the next 3 years. The Dogs get a guy who needs a change and will dominate with there midfield service and will have another 4 years minimum of good footy, this could be their next Barry Hall. They also easy their PPP. I'm guessing clubs like the blues will be hitting up Bontempelli perfect fit for them and clubs like the Tigers will chase Stringer with huge dollars. The dogs know this is coming, its their own fault by signing Boyd on bid money. The Pies get a 10 year gun, Boyd and Moore WTF. Hibberd would be nice, swap him with Langdon, maybe throw in a Commodore, $ 2000 saving account with Westpac and a trip to Dubai.

Ill have what he's smoking

 

[Stoods]

would Jesse White and a 3rd rounder to the dogs or someone in need of a forward get us a 2nd rounder?

 

[Dynamics]

Pies should go to the dogs and get a swap with Tom Boyd and Cloke, The sell would be how do they keep 3 players over a million each which Stringer, Bontempelli and Boyd will be on each within the next 3 years. The Dogs get a guy who needs a change and will dominate with there midfield service and will have another 4 years minimum of good footy, this could be their next Barry Hall. They also easy their PPP. I'm guessing clubs like the blues will be hitting up Bontempelli perfect fit for them and clubs like the Tigers will chase Stringer with huge dollars. The dogs know this is coming, its their own fault by signing Boyd on bid money. The Pies get a 10 year gun, Boyd and Moore WTF. Hibberd would be nice, swap him with Langdon, maybe throw in a Commodore, $ 2000 saving account with Westpac and a trip to Dubai.

Putting aside the rest for a moment, the thought of Bontempelli in navy blue made my beard shrivel up at least a couple of inches.

 

[4tone]

Putting aside the rest for a moment, the thought of Bontempelli in navy blue made my beard shrivel up at least a couple of inches.

have a think about it, Carlton, Lygon St, Shit load of Italians follow the blues, previous ethnic greats of the club. Bontempelli at the Blues, goes like a coke and a smoke. The blues would have a shit load. The rest, although delivered with late night recklessness, it all makes perfect sense to me. D Hine should give me a call, and things will get done.

 

[Quicky]

have a think about it, Carlton, Lygon St, Shit load of Italians follow the blues, previous ethnic greats of the club. Bontempelli at the Blues, goes like a coke and a smoke. The blues would have a shit load. The rest, although delivered with late night recklessness, it all makes perfect sense to me. D Hine should give me a call, and things will get done.

What other trades would you wrangle?

 

[4tone]

Another one would be maybe Brown to say Brisbane, restricted agent, highly paid player, compo pick if the pies finish bottom 4 or so would immediate pick after final finish, First pick still goes top GWS but the very next pick, would exactly what The deess got for Frawley. Have a feeling Grundy or Witts will go, not sure to who but this will happen. My Crystal balls have never let me down.

 

[ChubbyGallon]

Another one would be maybe Brown to say Brisbane, restricted agent, highly paid player, compo pick if the pies finish bottom 4 or so would immediate pick after final finish, First pick still goes top GWS but the very next pick, would exactly what The deess got for Frawley. Have a feeling Grundy or Witts will go, not sure to who but this will happen. My Crystal balls have never let me down.

Brown would be lucky to get 3rd round compo let alone First round.. YOu have to think Carlton got nothing in compo for Jarrad Waite and I reckon brown would be on par with that.

 

[steelebottom22]

Option 1. For late 1st rounder from bulldogs

Option 2. To Gws for Josh Kelly

Option 3. To Freo for 2nd round pick + connor blakely

Option 4. Keep Him


Would love to get peoples thoughts also other options

( sorry if thread not aloud delete if need be )

 

[sirlothie]

It's not aloud but I don't know if it's allowed.

Should have put it in the trade thread.

FWIW I think we should just get the highest pick we can, might get somewhere between 10 and 15 for him. Definitely don't need another midfielder, we need key position players.

 

[Seedsfan]

Think before you post, there is already a trade talk thread also why trade Witts? Grundy couldn't win a hitout in a stampede at the moment.

 

[Mateyman]

Trade for Pick 1+2nd rounder

 

[Jelly Bean]

The time to do it was last trade period. His value will have diminished by end of year, and a replacement will have been less gettable (as Kruezer was last year).

 

[SApies]

Some of these trade hypothetical are embarrassing lol. Not sure if some are a piss take thought. Cloke for Tom Boyd? Haha classic.

 

[boxy99]

Witts would be lucky to land us a 3rd rounder

 

[Kappa]

Buckley was a big reason why Treloar choose us.

How do you know that?

 

[Vicky Park]

There's Witts discussion going on in the trade thread, so merging threads.

 

[loki04]

Agree I want Tom Lynch. He should be our main target if he's out of contract

Didn't he recently sign a massive contract to stay a Sun?

 

[loki04]

If we wanted him traded he'd of been gone in 2012, He's not going anywhere.

His old man is shopping him around from what I have read.

 

[Soups]

Some of these trade hypothetical are embarrassing lol. Not sure if some are a piss take thought. Cloke for Tom Boyd? Haha classic.

I thought I clicked on the trade hypothetical thread on the draft and trade board Wow.

 

[Finnishpie]

Witts would be lucky to land us a 3rd rounder

I reckon we'd get a second rounder for him. But I wonder if Grundy is also in danger -- his tapwork has been average and the same for his work around the ground.

 

[mattys123]

Yeah let's put 6-7 years of development into a ruckman then trade him for a 2nd rounder, just as he might be developing into his best.

The Hawks would take Grundy or Witts off our hands tomorrow, and develop them into ruckman to play in their next 3 premierships.

 

[CFC2010]

Yeah let's put 6-7 years of development into a ruckman then trade him for a 2nd rounder, just as he might be developing into his best.

The Hawks would take Grundy or Witts off our hands tomorrow, and develop them into ruckman to play in their next 3 premierships.

Didn't Wright make a play for Witts in the past mattys123??

 

[GoalSneak07]

Option 1. For late 1st rounder from bulldogs

Option 2. To Gws for Josh Kelly

Option 3. To Freo for 2nd round pick + connor blakely

Option 4. Keep Him


Would love to get peoples thoughts also other options

( sorry if thread not aloud delete if need be )

Umm.. are we trading thin air?