Cotchin Or Gibbs?

[Big Bad Buddy]

Who do you reckon will be a better player.

 

[Monkeyboy]

Too hard to tell. Gibbs will definately be to 5 player in the comp. Cotchin may just join him.
Tigers and Blues both have some up and comers. Cotchin, Gibbs, Grigg, Murphy, Deledio, Kreuzer, Jamison, Bower, Hampson, Walker all look like being stars!

 

[Optus Penguin]

Too hard to tell. Gibbs will definately be to 5 player in the comp. Cotchin may just join him.
Tigers and Blues both have some up and comers. Cotchin, Gibbs, Grigg, Murphy, Deledio, Kreuzer, Jamison, Bower, Hampson, Walker all look like being stars!

i like that ratio of 2:8
cotchin missed the start of the season and still finished 3rd in the NAB Rising star, but ill give the nod to Gibbs

 

[anti.]

cotch for sure.

 

[Willow_2000]

Cotchin, Gibbs will be good aswell but Cotch better.

 

[Rosstickle]

i like that ratio of 2:8
cotchin missed the start of the season and still finished 3rd in the NAB Rising star, but ill give the nod to Gibbs

He forgot Thursfield, Moore, McGuane, Foley, Riewoldt, Morton which would square up the ledger a bit

 

[Windas_Magic]

Cotchin but Gibbs will be a very good player.

 

[Optus Penguin]

He forgot Thursfield, Moore, McGuane, Foley, Riewoldt, Morton which would square up the ledger a bit

You forgot Tambling

 

[mediumsizered]

He forgot Thursfield, Moore, McGuane, Foley, Riewoldt, Morton which would square up the ledger a bit

It continues to fascinate me that Richmond supporters list Moore among the young up & comers. He is only 6 months younger than Chris Judd, so has reached the 24-30 age group, when most players are at their peak. I guess Carlton supporters can claim Chris Judd among our up & coming players.

 

[Carn Hawkas]

Cotch

 

[carn tigez]

He forgot Thursfield, Moore, McGuane, Foley, Riewoldt, Morton which would square up the ledger a bit

And Deledio

 

[matey]

Cotchin easily with his composure, resolve and skill. With all the hype that Gibbs has got and gets he is bloody over rated as so many other players are better.

 

[Big Biird]

gibbs looks to be playin a different range of positions to cotchin.
both great players, but cotchin by a tiny bit.

 

[Rosstickle]

It continues to fascinate me that Richmond supporters list Moore among the young up & comers. He is only 6 months younger than Chris Judd, so has reached the 24-30 age group, when most players are at their peak. I guess Carlton supporters can claim Chris Judd among our up & coming players.

Didn't realise that, yeah you can include Judd too.