Dal Santo Better Than Judd?

[Chris_Judd]

Re: Re: Re: Re: Dal Santo Better Than Judd?

Originally posted by noodle
i believe that the comparison going around is 'Robert Harvey with a turbo charger'.

Was it Bruce McAvaney who said Judd was 'Robert Harvey with a turbo charger'?? I can't remember...

 

[The Passenger]

Re: Re: Re: Dal Santo Better Than Judd?

Originally posted by Joffaboy


As far as Judd goes, I dont really know who he can be compared to in style. Anybody have any suggestions?

the closest I can go to is a taller version of Andrew McLeod

 

[MightySaint]

Originally posted by MightySaint
PS, when Dal gets BOG vs the blues this week, i'll bring this thread back up and see how people's perceptions change. Else, you will never see this thread again.

Well, Banger was BOG, with Dal in second. The opposition was almost non existant, but 26 possies and 3 goals is a great game nonetheless.

 

[HHF]

Dal is a fantastic player and a deffinate future B&F. Judd is also a great talent but I saw him play when StKilda played the Eagles and Steve Baker held Judd to just 4 touches for the entire game, I know its not an even comparison because I have seen Dal Santo alot more than Judd but from what I have seen Judd is good but all the Media and Eagles fans act like he is the second comming of god or something. However, from what I have seen I would give the edge to Judd but only just.

 

[Harvey to Hayes]

Originally posted by The Clokes
Chris Judd's finger nail has more talent than Dal Santo has in his whole body.

You're an idiot and quite possibly inbred......

 

[Harvey to Hayes]

Originally posted by Chris_Judd
Koschitzke... now talking about overrated... doesn't get more overrated than him... he has basically done nothing... yet people talk about him like he is the next coming of christ..... even Andrew Macdougall a few weeks ago when we played St Kilda.... completley outplayed and outmarked him on a few occassions even though we were playing like trash... and Macdougall is almost the same age and only in his 9th game.

You obviously don't watch non-WCE games do you? Rising Star? Mean anything to you? I think time will tell on this one toolsqueezer.

I'm still laughing about Judd's four possessions against us the other week..... They were all seagulls too.....

 

[Harvey to Hayes]

Originally posted by Chris_Judd
I guess beating a team missing half their best team.... and another team who have just about been the worst side since round 7 is their idea of success... no wonder they have been so bad for the last 37 years.

Half your best team? You are either in serious denial or getting more stupid by the post! You had a few players out as did we and we caned you! You should try and be objective occasionally and maybe everyone wouldn't despise you so much......

 

[daddy_4_eyes]

Originally posted by HHF
but from what I have seen Judd is good but all the Media and Eagles fans act like he is the second comming of god or something.

On the contrary. It was vic supporters and vic media who continually beat up his performances up until he re-signed with the eagles.

Isn't Ablett jr the second coming of god?

 

[statman]

Give them both some time and then we will judge them

 

[AD_03]

This thread is an embarrassment to the forum!!!!! Judd easily

CAN WE PLEASE CLOSE THIS THREAD

 

[raskolnikov]

Originally posted by brentoncowell
crazy call.I think Judd is over rated but he is better than dal santo. Ball is better than dal santo,Koschitzke,Clarke and loveable reiwoldt.

I'd take Riewoldt over Judd anyday.

 

[saintsrule]

Originally posted by Chris_Judd
Koschitzke... now talking about overrated... doesn't get more overrated than him... he has basically done nothing... yet people talk about him like he is the next coming of christ..... even Andrew Macdougall a few weeks ago when we played St Kilda.... completley outplayed and outmarked him on a few occassions even though we were playing like trash... and Macdougall is almost the same age and only in his 9th game.

Kwissy, getting a little overwrought I think. WC not travelling too well? Seems playing like trash is becoming a habit. I seem to recall you having a go at Riewoldt this year, after his performances suffered because of being double and often triple tagged on the forward line. Now you are making similar excuses for Judd.

You really are a moron Dudd!

 

[Duffman95]

Originally posted by Saint4Life
hehehe one thing.. we didnt BEAT WC... we THUMPED them.

My bro played in Travis Clokes team last year. Hes the best 1 Hes pretti big too

How unsuprising that comment came from you

 

[The Oracle]

Maybe Saints did win for a change but one game doesn't make a season. By the way I don't see the Saints in the finals do you ?

 

[Falchoon]

Of the 352 players that played on the weekend these are the only players that average more in the Herald Sun/champion data player rankings than Nick Dal Santo

Ottens
Coughlan
Voss
Lappin
Bell
West
BJohnson
RHarvey
Hayes
BHarvey
Wanganeen
Buckley
Burns
Ricciuto

not bad company really.

 

[Winmar]

Originally posted by The Oracle
Maybe Saints did win for a change but one game doesn't make a season. By the way I don't see the Saints in the finals do you ?

One game?

 

[evertonfc]

Originally posted by DonFan
I'd take Riewoldt over Judd anyday.

Everyone would.

 

[Macca19]

Judd is the better player now. No doubt.

That doesnt mean that Dal Santo is a dud. Hes a very good player and will be amongst the top midfielders in the league in 4-5 years time.

 

[evertonfc]

Originally posted by Macca19
Judd is the better player now. No doubt.

Agreed.

That doesnt mean that Dal Santo is a dud. Hes a very good player and will be amongst the top midfielders in the league in 4-5 years time.

By 2005, Dal will be our best midfielder, and better than Hayes.

Probably better than Goddard, Ball and Clarke, too IMO.