delisted ?

[baconb]

hey guys,
when will this be announced? Some clubs already have any idea when?

 

[zeeCFC]

Hadley and Wiggo retired and word from the Bullants B&F was that Tiller, Fish and Johnson are gone too

 

[GordonBlue]

Hadley and Wiggo retired and word from the Bullants B&F was that Tiller, Fish and Johnson are gone too

so we're persisting with ROK... thats good to know

How about Joe?

 

[blueblood25]

Donaldson delisted also. They have until October 29 for the first list lodgement (which includes rookie promotions etc) Cloke was delisted mid November so there could still be some changes after the first list..

 

[blues4flag]

Disappointed to hear that Donaldson is gone. Was impressed by the little I saw of him.

 

[Sin City]

How about Joe?

There's a rumour on Talking Carlton. A guy from the Northern Territory has posted that Joe Anderson's grandfather told him Joey had been given a two year contract. We'll see.

 

[GordonBlue]

There's a rumour on Talking Carlton. A guy from the Northern Territory has posted that Joe Anderson's grandfather told him Joey had been given a two year contract. We'll see.

that is interesting...

it's pretty hard to understand though...

So lets say

Out of seniors:

Hadley
Fisher
Wiggins
Tiller
Johnson

Into seniors:

Jeffry
Ellard
Collins
Laidler
Pick 18
Pick 33
Pick 41

those 3 picks are at absolute minimum

Meaning the pick we got back for jacobs would be utter useless

and we would need to delist atleast another 3 just to use our 3rd rounder

For rookies

Out

Jeffry
Ellard
Donaldson

So we have only 3 vacancies there

If Joey is safe, then atleast 2 off ROK, Setanta, T Bird or Browne aren't

 

[blueblood25]

We have to use a pick to officially upgrade White don't we?

 

[Stamos]

We have to use a pick to officially upgrade White don't we?

Yes, but assuming we also upgrade Ellard (Garlett is a definite), we only have to use our last 3 picks, being 104, 121, 138

 

[mighty blues luke]

that is interesting...

it's pretty hard to understand though...

So lets say

Out of seniors:

Hadley
Fisher
Wiggins
Tiller
Johnson

Into seniors:

Jeffry
Ellard
Collins
Laidler
Pick 18
Pick 33
Pick 41

those 3 picks are at absolute minimum

Meaning the pick we got back for jacobs would be utter useless

and we would need to delist atleast another 3 just to use our 3rd rounder

For rookies

Out

Jeffry
Ellard
Donaldson

So we have only 3 vacancies there

If Joey is safe, then atleast 2 off ROK, Setanta, T Bird or Browne aren't

You havent factored in Grigg and Sauce leaving just the players and picks we got for them

 

[zeeCFC]

You havent factored in Grigg and Sauce leaving just the players and picks we got for them

ahhhh

 

[Mandragoran]

that is interesting...

it's pretty hard to understand though...

So lets say

Out of seniors:

Hadley
Fisher
Wiggins
Tiller
Johnson

Into seniors:

Jeffry
Ellard
Collins
Laidler
Pick 18
Pick 33
Pick 41

those 3 picks are at absolute minimum

Meaning the pick we got back for jacobs would be utter useless

and we would need to delist atleast another 3 just to use our 3rd rounder

For rookies

Out

Jeffry
Ellard
Donaldson

So we have only 3 vacancies there

If Joey is safe, then atleast 2 off ROK, Setanta, T Bird or Browne aren't

You forgot jacobs and grigg will go off the seniors list too.

Also as Setanta and T Bird have contracts they cannot be delisted.

 

[jd2006]

You forgot jacobs and grigg will go off the seniors list too.

Also as Setanta and T Bird have contracts they cannot be delisted.

They can and would get paid out wouldnt they?

 

[Sin City]

They can and would get paid out wouldnt they?

Yep. Sounds like it won't happen though.

 

[Bluebear]

hey guys,
when will this be announced? Some clubs already have any idea when?

Probably nothing more officially now until the players get back from Hols (end Oct) just before the first list lodgement.

 

[GordonBlue]

You havent factored in Grigg and Sauce leaving just the players and picks we got for them

You forgot jacobs and grigg will go off the seniors list too.

Also as Setanta and T Bird have contracts they cannot be delisted.

Ahh Knew there was something off...

So basically as we speak, there are 7 outs and 7 ins... i expect to use upto that pick 67... so we'll lose atleast one more player

 

[DamoESP]

Oh god, if they've delisted Johnson but given Anderson a contract I'm going to cry...

 

[qldbluesman_43]

So this is pretty much how it stands yeah?

Out:
Hadley
Fisher
Wiggins
Tiller
Johnson
Jacobs
Grigg

Maybe:
Anderson
Browne
ROK

In:
Garlett
Ellard
Collins
Laidler
Pick 18
Pick 33
Pick 41

Maybe:
White
Pick 67
Pick 69

Personally I don't see anything in keeping Anderson or Browne. Neither have impressed me much, especially Anderson.

 

[AndSmithMustScore]

Personally I don't see anything in keeping Anderson or Browne. Neither have impressed me much, especially Anderson.

Same. Both aren't good enough for what we are hopefully trying to achieve.

 

[Silvagnis]

Same. Both aren't good enough for what we are hopefully trying to achieve.

Collingwood had Blight, Corrie and Buckley on their list in 2010.

Every team has list cloggers.

How do you replace Anderson and Browne in the next two compromised drafts?

Anderson or Browne might be of more value to Carlton than a late pick who will have to be re-signed for two years. If it's between another Tiller and Anderson or Browne, I'd choose the latter every time.

 

[Stamos]

ROK 100% wont be delisted.

Thanks BiB. Any info on the others being mentioned on this thread?

 

[GordonBlue]

Pick 69

We have pick 70

 

[TerryWallet]

Only 3 players i didn't want to see on the CFC 2011 playing list:

Bret Thornton
Chris Johnson
Mitch Morton

Very happy we didn't take Morton. Very happy to see ericpascoe suggest Johnson and Thornton will be delisted.

All 3 are selfish, individualistic, below average players who bring nothing to a Team.

 

[Stamos]

Very happy to see ericpascoe suggest Johnson and Thornton will be delisted.

Link please? Cheers.

 

[Blue Dimension]

Oh god, if they've delisted Johnson but given Anderson a contract I'm going to cry...

Anderson is much better suited to our game plan and is constantly improving albeit at a slow rate. Johnson is a struggler at best. Good decision.