Dunn not on offer

[munsonned]

You guys would be happy to see this wouldn't you!!!!

http://afl.com.au/default.asp?pg=trade&spg=display&articleid=233425

 

[rgauci]

REad between the lines though. It doesn't say Dunn isn't on offer, it says Dunn + pick 10 was not offered.

 

[Wizard]

I dare say that a few emails sent last night might have prompted the club to put that report up. Maybe they are finally listening to fans.

 

[dockertor]

I dare say that a few emails sent last night might have prompted the club to put that report up. Maybe they are finally listening to fans.

Or the offer was never made and people around here listen to crap from knobs in the media who have agendas too much

 

[Undertaker]

Or the offer was never made and people around here listen to crap from knobs in the media who have agendas too much

I agree all that was offered for Hay was pick 10

 

[Wizard]

I agree all that was offered for Hay was pick 10

Even that was to much, anyway i dont think the offer was made either but becuase of an outcry from Dockers fans they have put up a post to ease everyones mind.

 

[Dr Ralph Dagg]

I dare say that a few emails sent last night might have prompted the club to put that report up. Maybe they are finally listening to fans.

Yeah right. FFC come out in the press and say Dunn won't be traded. Then Brad Hardie gets on his high standing shetland and says this is what they offered Pick 10 & Dunn.

Then knucklehead supporters weigh up who to believe -- FFC or Brad Hardie. And you go "Yeah, I'll believe Brad Hardie."

So then the club issues a denial. And you, Wizzie 9, conclude it must have been e-mails from fans. Just stand back for a minute and re-run the fantasy you've concocted in your head about the football club you reckon you support.

What's coming out on Big Footy is we have some really feral fans who'll believe every negative thing about the club because we haven't fulfilled their dreams of instant success.

 

[sabre_ac]

Hold up.
Comettie said it at the end of the sports report...
Hes not a reliable source now?

Surely hes not in the same league as Hardie as far as sensationalism goes..

 

[Ripper]

Hold up.
Comettie said it at the end of the sports report...
Hes not a reliable source now?

Surely hes not in the same league as Hardie as far as sensationalism goes..

It was only reported in WA as far as I can make out. As I saod in another post , I listened to sen & 3AW yesterday and hea4rd nothing about Dunn & pick 10 until I watched the 10 news on WIN which is 5 hours after trading stops for the day.

Commetti is trolling as well now.

 

[dominguez]

Yeah right. FFC come out in the press and say Dunn won't be traded. Then Brad Hardie gets on his high standing shetland and says this is what they offered Pick 10 & Dunn.

Then knucklehead supporters weigh up who to believe -- FFC or Brad Hardie. And you go "Yeah, I'll believe Brad Hardie."

So then the club issues a denial. And you, Wizzie 9, conclude it must have been e-mails from fans. Just stand back for a minute and re-run the fantasy you've concocted in your head about the football club you reckon you support.

What's coming out on Big Footy is we have some really feral fans who'll believe every negative thing about the club because we haven't fulfilled their dreams of instant success.

Channel ten also reported the Dunn + pick 10 deal and Gossage isn't an eagles supporter.

If Dunn was offered and the hawks weren't keen we have to say Dunn wasn't offered otherwise it will be a long season for Ryley at Freo next year knowing that we tried to ditch him.

I'm not saying that Dunn definately was offered. I don't know if he was or he wasn't. I do know that according to atleast 3 media outlets he was.

My preference is still for Hay to go to the roos and Dunn to be traded for a pick in the top 15.

 

[theGav56]

I dare say that a few emails sent last night might have prompted the club to put that report up. Maybe they are finally listening to fans.

If they are listening to the fans then we are in deeeeeep poo. Imagine how the rotations off the bench will work. I mean, just figuring who the fans are baying for will be tricky. Not to mentiongetting the matchups working.

Perhaps a better idea would be to just get Hardie and Barra to be the voice of the fans, because they clearly know what's going on.

And yes, if Commetti reports something that is wrong then he is an unreliable source, and his credibility is tainted.

The question fans need to ask is "Why was this reported?" It is the sort of speculation that belongs on boards like this, not stated as fact by reporters.

 

[kuepper]

If a couple of angry nerds on a messageboard make the recruiting policies of this club, we should all pack it in.

Turn it up, you clowns.

Hardie, Commetti - who cares - just because some talking head says it on radio/TV doesn't make it gospel.

Wait til Friday, 2pm EST, and then discuss to your hearts content, in the interim, get a nice tall glass of perspective, and drink it all down.