Blackas87
Brownlow Medallist
Not sure I agree with that, Dusty has been a very good home and away player. Won the Brownlow in 2017 helping elevate his team into the top 4, this is after finishing 3rd in the Brownlow in 2016 with the Tigers missing finals so he performs even when the teams isn’t a contender.I think it can be boiled down to this:
For H&A: Bontempelli
For finals: Dusty
For overall: Depends on your list. If you have a good list capable of winning the flag, you pick Dusty cos he will get you over the line in big finals and make sure you come away with at least 1 flag. If you have a middling or poor list, you pick Bontempelli cos he will be good every week and elevate you into the finals and possible premiership contention.
Martin’s best home and away season is better than Bontempelli’s