EDFL Premier Discussion 2025

[Gremlin77]

In all honesty Douttas ground is not a great surface and worse if any rain as large centre area is a mud pit. Great viewing from the deck or in front of the away rooms and decent social rooms but being a big ground in an open type space not much atmosphere other than the deck area. Playground is handy for families with young kids as you can watch the footy from that area of the ground and it’s decent viewing.

Bit harsh on Deer Parks ground as fine it’s a pretty decent surface and good viewing ground. Could do with netting behind goals though and more parking.

Pacco’s facilities are pretty good overall and can see the game good from in front of social rooms. Hearing ground still has drainage issues so patchy.

Unfortunately most grounds are not great and almost all social rooms are placed in the pocket so lack atmosphere and if rains nowhere to go..

Keilor and Abers probably the best but haven’t ventured to EK for a while since my picture was on the wanted list up there a few years back..

Where did I say anything about Deer Park’s ground ? Pacco’s a dump on and off

 

[Nepotism]

Looking forward to Strathmore v Aberfeldie.

Should be a ripper game.

 

[1OUT1BACK]

Interesting outcome at the tribunal. Can someone explain how a drone was used as footage in Dion's striking case, and the video used was edited (as mentioned earlier in the week) with only Dion's retaliation. This was sent in by the umpire himself, so l assume the drone was owned by the umpiring team on the day!

Clarification please.

 

[TheOldCodger]

Interesting outcome at the tribunal. Can someone explain how a drone was used as footage in Dion's striking case, and the video used was edited (as mentioned earlier in the week) with only Dion's retaliation. This was sent in by the umpire himself, so l assume the drone was owned by the umpiring team on the day!

Clarification please.

Retaliation or not... it's a strike! Stop crying about it and admit Hill messed up

 

[torpfrom50]

Interesting outcome at the tribunal. Can someone explain how a drone was used as footage in Dion's striking case, and the video used was edited (as mentioned earlier in the week) with only Dion's retaliation. This was sent in by the umpire himself, so l assume the drone was owned by the umpiring team on the day!

Clarification please.

Got ya right whack

 

[Gremlin77]

Looking forward to Strathmore v Aberfeldie.

Should be a ripper game.

Doubt that, they play again in the Qualifying final next week. Both sides will be keeping a few things up the sleeve you’d imagine.

It’s all about Deer Park v Airport West this week.

 

[wce06]

Doubt that, they play again in the Qualifying final next week. Both sides will be keeping a few things up the sleeve you’d imagine.

It’s all about Deer Park v Airport West this week.

Who would Deer Park prefer to play against Stars or APW, the ball is in their court on who they want to play, throw the match and they play APW, win and they play Stars.

Then again if APW legitimately beat Deer Park I am sure people will say they threw the match anyway...lol

 

[Nepotism]

Deer Park would rather play Doutta Stars.

 

[1OUT1BACK]

Retaliation or not... it's a strike! Stop crying about it and admit Hill messed up

You missed my point. Yes Hill will serve his time accepted, but crying about it isn't my view here.
Intrigued by the drone footage and it's use and the selected frames used on one particular player in the same incident. Something tells me I'm wasting my time asking for a non bias view on this.....with you anyway!!

 

[1OUT1BACK]

Got ya right whack

So did no12 from Abersville according to the retaliator!!

 

[Gstar64]

just saw heard suns post about anti social behaviour from the weekend, which clubs were the junior game?

 

[The Longblow]

Hi all,
My player of interest might heading be to the EDFL next year.
Out of curiosity, which clubs in Prem div have the best following and support at games?
Anyone willing to do a ranking? (Except Longblow)
Anything would be helpful. Cheers.

write in English champ or at least try proofreading before posting.

 

[The Longblow]

Interesting outcome at the tribunal. Can someone explain how a drone was used as footage in Dion's striking case, and the video used was edited (as mentioned earlier in the week) with only Dion's retaliation. This was sent in by the umpire himself, so l assume the drone was owned by the umpiring team on the day!

Clarification please.

I would say the drone was an Aberfeldie initiative as it was being flown above the tennis clubhouse. Makes sense that Aberfeldie in conjunction with their favourite umpire would conspire to pot Hill and let any other incident go as though it never happened. If footage of Hill was provided and no other footage provided and or requested by the edfl then the fraud and corruption in the edfl in my opinion is obvious. Match day footage shows Hill running away from the perfect tackle and being chased by Aberfeldie players who must have done something untoward for Hill to try and defend himself. What number was the player who Hill apparently stuck?.

 

[1OUT1BACK]

I would say the drone was an Aberfeldie initiative as it was being flown above the tennis clubhouse. Makes sense that Aberfeldie in conjunction with their favourite umpire would conspire to pot Hill and let any other incident go as though it never happened. If footage of Hill was provided and no other footage provided and or requested by the edfl then the fraud and corruption in the edfl in my opinion is obvious. Match day footage shows Hill running away from the perfect tackle and being chased by Aberfeldie players who must have done something untoward for Hill to try and defend himself. What number was the player who Hill apparently stuck?.

Don't expect a logical response mate. The hatred runs deep on this forum. You can only imagine if the shoe was on the other foot. Definitely a different code of conduct in this league.

No 12 was the player who bit off more than he could chew. The kicker l believe!!!
View attachment Messenger_creation_9CBC6153-4D76-49B1-85A2-A20C834D84B3.mp4

 

[heritage]

What’s the big issue with Deer Park? Their ground is paradise for a boundary umpire. Never really heard anything too negative about the club.

Oak Park is a mud pit once winter sets in. Pascoe Vale’s ground is also a bit challenging.

Listen to the 1st half of Aberfeldie Vs Deer Park.

 

[1OUT1BACK]

Listen to the 1st half of Aberfeldie Vs Deer Park.

Yeah especially the 19 minute mark of the second 1/4. Once again tell the whole truth instead of painting a picture of one club. Little tiprats lost interest when things got willing though. Hats off to the Aberfeldie board member who suggested they venture off down near the nets in the second half. Maybe cut their alcohol content to 1 vodka cruiser next week.

 

[BlueJet]

Another day, more squealing from Deer Park fans.. <yawn>

 

[Orfullrules]

I would say the drone was an Aberfeldie initiative as it was being flown above the tennis clubhouse. Makes sense that Aberfeldie in conjunction with their favourite umpire would conspire to pot Hill and let any other incident go as though it never happened. If footage of Hill was provided and no other footage provided and or requested by the edfl then the fraud and corruption in the edfl in my opinion is obvious. Match day footage shows Hill running away from the perfect tackle and being chased by Aberfeldie players who must have done something untoward for Hill to try and defend himself. What number was the player who Hill apparently stuck?.

Thoughts on the Covid pandemic?

 

[weapons#again]

Don't expect a logical response mate. The hatred runs deep on this forum. You can only imagine if the shoe was on the other foot. Definitely a different code of conduct in this league.

No 12 was the player who bit off more than he could chew. The kicker l believe!!!
View attachment 2402244

Onya diesel the bloke would think about doing that again ..... Went down like a sack of spuds .....

 

[Grechy Bombers]

I haven’t seen anything too bad from anyone from Deer Park but then again I don’t go to many premier games.

When they were in Div. 1 they were fine from what I saw.

I’ve boundary umpired some of their u/18 games and never had the slightest issue.

Gremlin’s comments were pretty strong and a bit surprising.

 

[1OUT1BACK]

I haven’t seen anything too bad from anyone from Deer Park but then again I don’t go to many premier games.

When they were in Div. 1 they were fine from what I saw.

I’ve boundary umpired some of their u/18 games and never had the slightest issue.

Gremlin’s comments were pretty strong and a bit surprising.

I guess his sides 0-4 since we've arrived in this elite comp.

 

[Gremlin77]

I guess his sides 0-4 since we've arrived in this elite comp.

Yep that’s the only reason

 

[Donald D]

6 weeks for what striking??

Yet if you play div2 for NS and kick someone you only get 8. FFS only known Dion to be a fair player.

You can be a playing coach and king hit someone 100m off the ball and get the same

 

[The Longblow]

Don't expect a logical response mate. The hatred runs deep on this forum. You can only imagine if the shoe was on the other foot. Definitely a different code of conduct in this league.

No 12 was the player who bit off more than he could chew. The kicker l believe!!!
View attachment 2402244

Wow. Hill had 2 Aberumpires hanging off him when he clocked the 'kicker' whose name is Stefanie Rasinac if it is number 12. A bloke has every right to defend himself if being attacked.
So who provided the footage from the drone and who edited the footage to remove what happened immediately prior to the strike? Keep in mind Hill was chased from the tackle immediately prior to this incident.
Has 12 been suspended for the kicking incident later in the game?
Has 11 been suspended for the hit on Galea ?
Has 22 been suspended for his flip or hit on Gill?
* If the drone caught this footage the incidents raised above would be on the same footage. Who flew the drone and has the footage?

 

[The Longblow]

Don't expect a logical response mate. The hatred runs deep on this forum. You can only imagine if the shoe was on the other foot. Definitely a different code of conduct in this league.

No 12 was the player who bit off more than he could chew. The kicker l believe!!!
View attachment 2402244

went down like a sack of ballarat spuds from spuds uncles place.