Edwards v Goodwin

[Mong]

Who's more valuable to us?

I suspect I know which way the vote will go but I think it is an interesting subject.

 

[DaveW]

At the moment, Edwards. He's getting more of the ball and making better use of it.

 

[marvin]

It's a hard question.

There's been very little difference between Edwards' best and worst the last 3 years - and it's all been at a very high level. R/U in last year's B+F, and if the season stopped now, he'd be at least top 3 for this year I would have thunk.

Goodwin has struggled at times this year, but I think his best is just a skerrick ahead of Edward best. Goodwin is also a little more versatile, in that he can (if required) play a tight tagging role, and is a slightly better overhead mark.

I pick Goodwin (though like Dave W, for this week I'd pick Edwards), but I'd like 3 of each cloned thanks.

 

[Jars458]

This poll is like asking a man to chose between beer and footy

You just need both.

 

[Stiffy_18]

Originally posted by Jars458
This poll is like asking a man to chose between beer and footy

You just need both.

Couldn't have said it better myself Jars.

 

[iceman21]

Goodwin....... Easily his possesions just seem more damaging and you just don't see him make the amount of mistakes that Edwards makes- alot of Edwards' mistakes end up as opposition goals

I'm not trying to bag Edwards, he is a good consistant player , but IMHO we are going to miss Goodwin more than we would have missed Edwards