Remove this Banner Ad

List Mgmt. Gibbs - 2017 Trade Discussions! V2.0

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Status
Not open for further replies.
Absolute max price but still makes last year look stupid.

Hopefully Galluci is a 200 game gun, which I think he will be
Except last year we didn't HAVE two firsts.
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

I wouldn't do 10. At 10 there is always a chance that there is a slider. At 12, you are hoping for the stars aligning.
We swapped 10 for 14 and got Lever (who we wanted at 10).... so it is possible.
 
We swapped 10 for 14 and got Lever (who we wanted at 10).... so it is possible.

In fairness we got Lever because Clubs were gun shy about his ACL history. He was meant to go very high in the draft before his ACL.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

How the f**k are we still going to pay picks 10 and 16 for a player that is one year older and at 29 in R1?????

Its a terrible trade. I think Gibbs will be good, but not worth two 1sts.

I was all for 2 first last year.... seems ducking ridiculous now!
 
I was all for 2 first last year.... seems ducking ridiculous now!
absolute bullshit to be paying that much.

Seriously its massive overs.

I dont care what anyone says, I would rather Rocky than Gibbs and to keep all our 1sts.
 
Im confident that Carlton will f**k up next year if they lose Gibbs. Gibbs had a great 2017 and they were still a bottom 4 Club.

That second rounder could be as high as ~pick 19.
Don't know that it could be 19 if you take into account the academy picks, compensation picks and potential F&S picks. More likely to be between 20 and 25 which is still a pretty good pick. Matt Crouch was pick 23.
 
I wonder if we knew we'd be top four if we'd have done it?

Imagine the loss if Gibbs plays less than 100 games for us as well and his son is a gun.

Moderators in the decades of the 2030s will have a field day. lol
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Don't know that it could be 19 if you take into account the academy picks, compensation picks and potential F&S picks. More likely to be between 20 and 25 which is still a pretty good pick. Matt Crouch was pick 23.

Wasnt Impey pick 22. It can also go sideways.
 
I stepped away for awhile, someone fill me in. Apparently Gibbs’ wife said their staying in Melb. I skip ahead a few pages and we are still talking about a Gibbs trade.

Did I miss something?

Nothing really.

Gibbs is still at Carlton. lol.
 
Interested to hear an Adelaide perspective on this:

10/16 + 39 for Gibbs + our second round pick next year

I'd think Adelaide would probably want something else, exchange of thirds next year might be an option but think that Carlton would want to the points for possible F/S pick ups. Feel free to tell me to get f*****.
 
Interested to hear an Adelaide perspective on this:

16 + 39 for Gibbs + our second round pick next year

I'd think Adelaide would probably want something else, exchange of thirds next year might be an option but think that Carlton would want to the points for possible F/S pick ups. Feel free to tell me to get f*****.

Sold!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top Bottom