Grant Thomas - Then and Now

Remove this Banner Ad

Patron Saint

In his most revealing interview, Grant Thomas explains to Jenny McAsey how he is using his wild past to build a new St Kilda
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
August 19, 2006

GRANT THOMAS is hanging out in the players' lounge at the St Kilda football club, downing a huge ham and salad sandwich.
Stephen Milne is presiding over the ping pong table as other players help themselves to lunch. Outside on the lush green of Moorabbin Oval, a dozen kids are kicking footies in the sun.

They're indigenous secondary school students, defender Troy Schwarze explains, who come to the club each week as part of a mentoring program set up by his Aboriginal team-mates Xavier Clarke and Allan Murray.

Thomas has been hanging around in this room - formerly part of the infamous Saints social club where the players of the 1970s and 1980s drank themselves silly after games - on and off for 33 years, since he arrived as a talented, knockabout 15-year-old from bayside Frankston.

It was not a place for salad sandwiches and social welfare programs during Thomas's 10 years at St Kilda, which ended in 1983 after 72 games as a tough centre half-back. As he admits, it was the venue for some of his maddest moments.

"All the players here know I wasn't a saint, so to speak, or didn't have saintly habits," Thomas says.

"I actually had very St Kilda habits, but not saintly habits - and there was a difference back then."

But not now, if Thomas achieves what he believes is his mission in life.

"It is really difficult to have 40 men together and not have issues," he says. "But I see a huge improvement in that area and I see if there are any, albeit slight, indiscretions there is genuine remorse."

Thomas's prime aim since he took over as coach in 2001 has been to ensure the club earns the respect it never had during his playing career.

He was part of the club's laughing stock days, lived its culture of failure from the inside, and is driven to see it erased forever.

"If St Kilda footy club has 100 per cent respect and I don't have any, it doesn't concern me in the slightest," Thomas says.

"It is not about Grant Thomas per se. I have a real passion and determination for St Kilda football club to be respected and successful. Perhaps it is because I came here at 15 and I didn't like what I saw even though I motivated much of it. There is a guilt there from that."

Twenty-five years ago, as now, Thomas was a commanding presence in the room. A leader of the lads with a dangerous charm.

Back then, though, he was more likely to be leading his team-mates astray, rather than his role today leading a group of professional young men into successive finals series.

Post-match in those days, he would have had a beer in one hand and his other around the waist of a buxom blonde.

"I was socially professional," Thomas recalls. "Loved a beer, loved the camaraderie and the spirit of mateship. In the early days football was just a vehicle to get together with the blokes and have fun."

As party animals, the Saints of that era had the best reputation. "Exactly, and we had the worst performance," he says.

At club headquarters this week, Thomas was happy to reflect on the bad old days, something he had not been comfortable doing previously.

Now, as the club sits fourth on the ladder and has gained the credibility he craves, he can talk more freely about the days when it didn't have any.

"You can vouch for my bad behaviour," he says in confessional mood.

(I should also confess to frequenting the Saints social club and disco for a brief period long ago.)

At 15, he learned street smarts from the ultimate 1970s role models - hard-nut players like Carl Ditterich, Jim O'Dea and Cowboy Neale.

"Training and having showers with guys like that ... you grow up pretty quick," he says. "I learnt most things from the mistakes I made. We didn't have trailblazing saints here."

Thomas's wild ways began to temper in the mid-1980s.

Twenty-two years ago he married Kerry, sweet-natured and pretty, who had previously been the girlfriend of team-mate Michael Roberts.

"Kezza", as Thomas calls her, is now mother to his eight children, aged between five and 20. Responsibility brought out the best in him and he went on to have success coaching country football at Warrnambool in Victoria and then in business as a senior manager.

There is permanent chaos with eight kids, but he says he and Kerry love having a full house and don't notice the noise. What interests him most, both at home and the football club, is relationships and understanding why people behave the way they do.

"I like asking why, I do it with the kids and the players," he says. "I say why and you get an answer and then I say why and get an answer and you can keep drilling down to the root cause of the whole issue.

"The players have a bit of fun now, they jump to the root cause rather than going through the process."

In that regard, his chequered past comes in handy, equipping him to guide his own kids as well as the players he considers his mates.

"That forms part of your life and then you have kids and you try to impose the right values on kids and walk away thinking, 'you hypocrite'," he laughs.

"And you have the other dynamic where you are coaching 41 players and there is not much they can get past you because there is nothing I haven't tried."

At a time when players behaving badly make regular headlines, his personal experiences are part of the education process at St Kilda.

"I still remember quite clearly walking into hotels when I was playing footy and you could think of nothing better than to have a few beers and let the hair down and whatever else happens then," Thomas says.

"But I learnt very early to assess the crowd and who was there. There were several times when I evaluated it wasn't the place to be, I just got a bad sense or feeling and convinced the others to go somewhere else and you found out later there was a huge all-in brawl there that night."

When he tells his charges the cost of playing up is too high, it is not theory.

"There is nothing worse than going into a contest with a bit of guilt, because you are living in hope a bit," he says.

He harbours regret from those days, when he didn't do the best for himself or the club.

In 1999, as St Kilda continued to falter, he decided he had to stop complaining and pitch in to help. He went on the board and then in July 2001, as football director, he pushed for the sacking of dual premiership coach Malcolm Blight.

The move shocked the football community and when Thomas was appointed coach, he was vilified by the media.

"Ridiculed is too soft a word," he says. "The way the whole thing came to fruition didn't help the perception (of me) and it is taking a long time for people to rid themselves of that.

"I treat the lack of respect out there as a constant motivation. Not to prove people wrong, because I really don't care externally what people think. If this was about Grant Thomas well I would but it is not, it is about St Kilda footy club.

"I am not about to go and coach another team; this is the task, this is the life-ending venture, I don't know what has happened, or why it has happened.

"I ask myself that question on a regular basis, why am I doing what I am doing? I don't know, I don't know how it came about and I don't know why I have the passion and desire to help St Kilda footy club to be successful."

He does know part of it relates to the death from cancer at age 40 of his revered team-mate Trevor Barker.

"There is a bit of Barks and ... I suppose I got sick and tired of people belittling St Kilda," Thomas says.

"I thought I either have to join them, because it was hard to disagree with, or I have to help change their perception."

This year, at last, he detects a healthy change in attitude towards him from people in the media he says he respects. It is the hard-earned result of lifting the team into the finals three years running despite a devastating series of injuries to key players including Nick Riewoldt last year, Aaron Hamill, brilliant midfielder Lenny Hayes, Justin Koschitzke and most recently defender Matt Maguire.

"It seems like anyone in the leadership group or anyone who is captain ends up getting the curse," Thomas says.

The coach's great strength, according to star player Riewoldt, is his ability to inspire and lift the group to triumph over adversity.

Riewoldt spoke this week of feeling flatter than ever when Maguire broke his leg two weeks ago.

After a sleepless night, Thomas worked a miracle with the group, according to Riewoldt, reminding them of a memorable win against all odds over Adelaide in last year's finals series.

Thomas says he just told the players what Maguire would want.

"I say there are two paths to go down," he says. "One is to compound it and have pity and be victims and have everyone feel sorry for us.

"Or the other one was to continue on a road that has just been made a little bit harder and if we are up for the challenge, when you get harder roads you get more enjoyment when you get through them."

Thomas says adversity has been a great teacher for the team, but he admits the string of injuries has taken an emotional toll.

"What I have found most difficult is you pick yourself up first because you have to, otherwise you are dead, and then you have to pick the team up," he says.

"But I've always found the most difficult period is after that. I have always been reasonably proud of how I am able to pick a group of people up, whether in business or sport or whatever, but it is in that post period when you go home, that next 24 or 48 hours, when you feel so drained, mentally and physically and it is who coaches the coach."

Apart from his wife and kids, he has two mentors who pick him up when he needs it and whose identities he wants kept secret: one a businessman and the other a legend of the club.

His ability to lead is now acknowledged, although queries are still raised about his tactical abilities in the coaching box on match day.

"I usually put up with it and say nothing but you have got me in a good mood and I will say it is just a load of crap, it is ridiculous," Thomas says.

"I have coached for a fair amount of time now, you want to add up five years at Warrnambool with four premierships, and I have either been in a coaches' box or coached for nearly 15 years now. I don't pay any weight to that whatsoever."

Thomas believes that every day in life, we carry a hammer and chisel, slowly carving out the words on our headstone.

He wants his to read, "Hard, fair and helpful", and his legacy to be that he left the St Kilda football club a very different place to what he found it.

"I'd like my legacy to be a spirit of respect. It is something this club has never had a lot of, and I am really determined for the club to be respected on the basis of performance," he says.
 
Also of interest in today's Age sports.

In praise of Thomas
Robert Walls
August 19, 2006

THE Saints sit fourth on the ladder, with 12 wins, and are set to make their third finals appearance in a row. Tonight, in the match of the round, the Saints take on the Dockers, who are heading for their seventh victory on the trot.

This will be some contest. By reaching three successive finals campaigns, coach Grant Thomas will do something no one has achieved at Moorabbin since Allan Jeans in the early 1970s.

Despite that, there are still many who question whether Grant Thomas is a decent coach.

All coaches have strengths and weaknesses. Let's look at some of the strengths of Thomas.

SPIRIT AND MORALE

It's hard to find an unhappy St Kilda footballer. The Saints are a tight-knit bunch who have great faith in the club's program. Injuries to key players have hurt the club this year, but you never hear a whinge. Aaron Hamill has played only six games, Lenny Hayes nine (with no more to come), Justin Koschitzke three, Xavier Clarke nine and brother Raphael one.
Two weeks ago, regular centre half-back Matt Maguire broke his leg. A week later, a committed group was too hard for the Cats in a crunch game. The coach got this group up. He convinced them it was effort, not personnel, that was important.


The Saints train hard but it's one-in, all-in. Rarely are the players split up. Players are encouraged to drive the session, to take ownership. Good relationships with the players' families are fostered. Parents are made to feel welcome and important. It keeps everyone happy. And when you're happy, you perform well.

YOUNG PLAYERS NURTURED

In recent years, St Kilda has been able to draft exciting talent. That's fine, but those players have needed to be taught. Thomas has done a good job in this area. St Kilda's youngsters have learnt to play football the way it should be played. Opponent accountability and being able to win your own ball in contested situations are priorities.
Three players in particular who have made the sacrifices needed to be harder, tougher and stronger are Nick Dal Santo, Brendon Goddard and Leigh Montagna. All look set for fine careers.

Off field, the Saints' young men present well, too. They look the part and speak well, aided by the development courses they have been put through. Is there a more charming, modest, well-spoken young footballer in the AFL than Xavier Clarke?

TELLING MOVES

Match-day moves is an area Thomas is improving at. Will Nick Riewoldt be on a wing or at full-forward? No longer is Stephen Milne stuck in the forward pocket. Who would have expected Michael Rix to line up at centre half-back last week? Montagna is now a top-line midfielder — ignore him at your risk. Dal Santo, if tagged, could become the new full-forward.
The back line is full of runners, led by Jason Gram. A year ago, Gram had nine games to his credit. Now Thomas has transformed him into the competition's best defensive runner, who is in line for All-Australian selection. Sam Fisher, too, has graduated into a top-liner capable of playing on bigs and smalls. Brett Voss is a swingman. Will he play forward kicking goals, or will he hold up the last line of defence?

This is a team that increasingly keeps you guessing.

THE OLDIES

A major triumph of Thomas' coaching had been his handling of the veterans. You sense they have been kept on edge, being told that each game and season could be their last.
Robert Harvey, 35 on Monday, Andrew Thompson, 33, Justin Peckett, 33, Fraser Gehrig, 30, and Max Hudghton and Stephen Powell, who both will soon turn 30, are leaving a fine legacy for their young teammates.

They give their all, and in the past couple of seasons have played some of their best football. The "G-Train" leads the goalkicking, Harvey continues to have 20-plus possession games, Peckett fixed Gary Ablett up last week, as did Thompson on Joel Corey, and Hudghton has had another fine season at full-back.

It is a credit to coach and players that the oldies have excelled.

YOUNG LEADERSHIP GROUP

By rotating the captaincy, year by year, as Thomas has done, the Saints will end up with a group of 25-year-olds who will have a far better understanding of what leadership is all about. Luke Ball, Riewoldt, Koschitzke and Hayes will all have experienced AFL captaincy in their early 20s. This may well be a huge plus for the Saints in years to come.
GROWTH OF PEOPLE

Thomas does not have a football manager. Instead, he spreads responsibilities onto his football coaching staff. All coaches and players have done AFL-approved coaching courses. Individuals are extended to benefit the whole.
THOMAS'S PERSONALITY

The coach is a loyal St Kilda man. He was at Moorabbin when a blonde and a beer beat winning a hard ball. He wants St Kilda to be successful and respected.
Thomas would not coach elsewhere. He is loyal and supportive, but demands on-field hardness and accountability. The players respond well. They don't blame others. They accept their responsibilities.

Are the Saints good enough to win a flag? Next year, with a full list, could well be their — and Thomas' — time.


This story was found at: http://www.theage.com.au/realfooty/articles/2006/08/18/1155408020429.html
 

Log in to remove this ad.

Gee... Wallsy was in a good mood when he wrote that...

It's true however, that Thomas IS now getting respect in the media as a coach and he has definitely changed the perception of our club in the eyes of many... well done GT, but the job has yet to be done as we all know.

R Man
 
Doubting Thomas
June 19, 2004

thomas_family,0.jpg

We are family: Grant Thomas with (clockwise) Ally, 9, wife Kerry, Tyson, 14, Kacey, 16, Hollie, 10, Claye, 18, Jordan, 12, Bailey, 6, and Jamison, 3.
Picture: Neale Duckworth


Not even being father of eight children could prepare Grant Thomas for his rollercoaster ride since becoming coach of St Kilda. Liz Porter reports.

St Kilda coach Grant Thomas lounges in an armchair opposite the pool table in his family's recreation room, reminiscing about forever being in trouble with the nuns at Frankston's St Francis Xavier Primary School.

"I was always referred to as 'the ringleader' by the nuns, and that was the part I didn't understand," says the coach, a policeman's son who, according to one of his later teachers, was defiant at school as a reaction to his father's strictness.

"I was proud that I was a leader. But unfortunately I was leading in the wrong direction on most occasions. It took a while for the penny to drop."

Played back, the tape of this conversation sounds as if it's been recorded in a creche. Shrieks of joy are followed by the thunder of small feet up and down stairs, a sudden outbreak of toddler tears and a soothing adult voice (Thomas's wife, Kerry), asking "Now, what happened?"

Meanwhile the evening news is blaring from a giant television in the adjacent kitchen/family room. It being a school night, there's less of a crowd than usual, with Kerry Thomas getting seven of the family's eight children ready for dinner.


advertisement

advertisement

"You go to the Thomases (at the weekend)" says advertising man Brett Jarick, 45, a former Beaumaris High schoolmate of Kerry Thomas's, "and it's like walking into a schoolyard. There's always 16 kids there."

"Dad's on TV," a child calls out. But the coach's ears have already twitched at the words "St Kilda players". Bursting out of his chair, Thomas, 47, strides into the TV room. The report concerns Thomas's sudden cancellation of that afternoon's training, taking his players to the movies instead. A "wellbeing" index, which the club had been calculating daily, had shown that players were fatigued. "I just wanted to see what they made of it," he murmurs.

Thomas has become used to being mocked for innovations such as his decision to rotate the captaincy, and to being derided for his business-speak about the "process", "performance indicators", "meeting targets", "core values" and "our brand" - a language honed in his career as a state manager with the insurance company MLC.

But his induction into the elite brotherhood of AFL coaches in late 2001 was greeted with a level of criticism that former St Kilda and then Hawthorn premiership coach Alan Jeans describes as unprecedented.

Back in 2000, Grant Thomas was the obscure 72-game St Kilda player-turned-board-member and club football director who, along with new club president, close confidant and fellow media "nobody" Rod Butterss, made front-page headlines by hiring legendary player and two-time Adelaide premiership coach Malcolm Blight on a $1 million a year contract, amid hype about changing the club's "culture" of off-field partying and on-field failure.

grant_thomas,0.jpg

Grant Thomas: "I had this unbending faith that I would make it. But I didn't have the urgency or the work ethic to make it happen."
Picture: Neale Duckworth


Less than a year later, the board sacked Blight and appointed Thomas, who had quit his MLC job at the end of 2000, first as "caretaker" then as permanent coach. The rookie AFL coach was pilloried in the sports pages as a both a "greenhorn" and a "Machiavellian plotter" — "Macbeth emerging from King Duncan's chamber, dagger in hand", as one writer put it.

It was alleged that he had undermined Blight and manipulated his mate Butterss into giving him a $400,000 a season job — claims that Thomas denies. So does Butterss, who describes Thomas as the "last man standing" supporting Blight against an increasingly critical board.

For all of 2002 and the first half of 2003 Thomas was "the coach who can't coach" (burdened with "the players who can't play"), famously dubbed "cornflakes" by The Australian football writer Patrick Smith, who likened him to a cereal because he'd been tipped out of so many (coaching) boxes before — a claim Thomas denies.

By the beginning of this year Thomas and Butterss were being credited with St Kilda's turnaround, both financially and on the scoreboard. But two days after the club's victory in the March preseason grand final, it called a news conference to announce claims of sexual assault against two St Kilda players and pundits were once again talking up the team's legendary penchant for self-destruction.

After seven weeks, the investigation closed for lack of evidence, drawing to an end a period that Thomas refuses to discuss any further. "It was a serious allegation and traumatic for everyone involved," he says. "That's the start and the finish of it . . . it had a huge impact on everyone, on the girls, on my family, on the team — on all the parties."

A week after the famous trip to the movies and three days after the club's first loss of the season, to Sydney, ending its record-breaking 10 straight wins, the coach speaks at an $85 per-head "Grant Thomas luncheon" for 200 business world supporters. Surprising a few, he raises the hypothesis that the team could lose the next two games but reassures them that the team would go into this coming week's mid-season break still equal top of the ladder with 10 wins and three losses. "And we would regroup from there," he says quietly.

Despite his team's mid-season slump (a "blip", he says), the prospect of football adversity doesn't panic him. His own football career — characterised, as he says, by "underachievement" — has taught him to deal with it.

At 15, when he was a star footballer catching the train to Moorabbin after school for training with St Kilda's Under 19s, he recalls being awe-struck at being singled out by senior coach Alan Jeans, the heroic 1966 premiership coach, who had just taken the team to the 1971 grand final.

"(Jeans) took me under his wing because I was so young, and he used to wrestle with me because I was big and strong. But that didn't help my personality type either. It made me more familiar — it further reinforced in my head that I had arrived."

Thomas was ready to be yet another blond bombshell St Kilda star — a view of his future shared by admiring peers at St Bede's Mentone. "Grant was a young kid who had the world at his feet," says Father Michael Sierakowski, then school vice-captain and now chaplain of St Kilda. "He knew it and he played up to that.

"He was a jock, tall, handsome, athletic — not his shape now — and a 'king of the kids'. Grant did most of his education on the train from Frankston to Mentone. His best subject wasn't on the curriculum. It was chatting up girls."

The priest, who held a mass baptism of the then seven Thomas children four years ago at Brighton's St Joan of Arc church, recalls wanting to have Thomas in the prefect group purely because of the huge influence he had over the student body.

"But he's not that guy now," he says. "As an adult he blossomed. Then, he wasn't interested in other people's opinions. He is, very much, now."

Father Paul Smith, former deputy head of St Bede's, recalls bawling out Thomas, a "precociously talented" footballer, for failing to turn up to training for the year 10 football team because he was playing for the Frankston league.

"Not many kids had turned up. I said (to him): 'I expect you to be there!' And he humphed away. And I said 'If there's not many there, you'll have a lot of work to do.' Next training day there were about 100 kids on the paddock.

"He was very dominant. And was able to gather others around him, so he was constantly coming to my attention, for being late, for not turning up or for stirring the weaker teachers. He was mischievous — nothing (worse) than that.

"But he seems to have become more articulate than he was at school — and more disciplined. I could see his potential. He had those leadership qualities, not just because of his size. Kids respected him — and there were a couple of kids that he was extra compassionate with, that he took under his wing."

Other teachers agree that Thomas has clearly been a "late developer".

"I'm surprised that he's acknowledged for his business skills," says his former year 10 business studies teacher, Paul Swannie. "But he does have people skills. I took my grandsons down to St Kilda training and he introduced them to the players."

Looking back, Thomas shakes his head when he remembers his naive confidence in future stardom. "I had this unbending faith that I would make it. But I didn't have the urgency or the intensity or the work ethic to make sure it would happen. I thought it was just a matter of course. It's very different being 15, 16, 17, 18 , training and showering and spending all your spare time with legends . . . and going to school and your mates wanting to hear about it. At the time I thought I was one of them. I just thought: 'I'm just on this escalator of success and it will happen.'

"Looking back on it now, I didn't have any prospects to further education or to university or to run my own business. It was the furthest thing from my mind. I saw teammates, 10 or 12 years older, on the end of successful careers, having business opportunities being put in front of them. I thought 'that's how it happens'. You just log in and at the end of it, you log out, and on to another gravy train. It was obviously a rude awakening."

At 21, Thomas was sacked by the then coach, Mike Patterson. "It was a horrific period of my life. Somebody had grabbed me and taken me off the escalator. I thought 'This isn't in the script'." But he was reprieved when the coach himself was sacked and replaced by ex-Carlton premiership captain-coach Alex Jesaulenko.

"Jezza" wanted to assess all the players — and ended up taking an interest in Thomas, who thrived at Moorabbin for a few years but then struggled after transferring to North Melbourne. Moving to Fitzroy, he was briefly happy under Robert Walls but was injured, and then sacked at the end of 1985 when David Parkin took over as coach.

The next year, when Thomas took up an offer to coach Warrnambool, he began to apply lessons drawn from his own failures — and from the example of Alex Jesaulenko, who had recognised that he needed direction and support — and gave it.

"I wasn't as self-motivated as some of the great players I have played with. Call it a weakness, if you like, and it probably is, but at the end of the day, more of your team fit under my category than under the super-star "self-motivated" category. That was a great teacher for me."

On Thomas's watch, Warrnambool won four premierships. "(When he arrived at St Kilda) he was very inexperienced at that level," says former Warrnambool player Lee McCorkell, 47. "But I certainly believed he'd be successful because I had no doubt that he would win the players over. Grant is about self-belief. If you can get players to believe in themselves, you're halfway there."

Lessons learned from parenthood have also played their part in his coaching approach, Thomas says, conceding that his commitment to rotating captains might have a relationship to the "taking turns" that has to be a ritual in large families. And, like any parent talking about his kids, Thomas repeatedly emphasises his desire for his players to be happy.

"You can shove strategy, tactics and opposition videotapes down their throat as much as you like. If they don't enjoy being there, you're not going to get the most out of them."

According to Kerry Thomas, her husband treats the players as if they were his own children. "He looks after them like his family members and I think it's starting to show now.

"He is a brilliant father. He's not here terribly much (leaving at 6.30am every day, usually not returning until 6pm) but when he is here it counts. I think he has taken what he does here to the football club. He has great rapport with the players."

Players, she says, drop in regularly, and spontaneously. On a recent Sunday night when Thomas and his wife had just finished their post-game home ritual of watching the tape of the day's game together, their doorbell rang at 9.45pm.

"The kids were in bed, we were about to go to bed, and it was Aussie Jones, his wife Emily, Milney and Steven Baker. They said 'We thought we'd just come round and have a beer with you.' They stayed until 1, and we watched the whole game again."

Says Brett Jarick: "He is a real father figure and mentor to them.

"You go out for dinner and he always takes phone calls from the players. He's coaching kids the same age as his eldest son."

Still her husband's greatest fan after 20 years of marriage, Kerry Thomas met her husband when she was dating his teammate Michael Roberts, still a close family friend. There was never a decision to have eight kids, says the one-time teenage member of the St Kilda cheer squad.

"Grant would keep going but I've said 'No. I'm (at 45) too old. We've had eight healthy children, four of each. And he does his own little thing with each one. He has a fantastic relationship with Kacey (16). They have the same sense of humour, each always knows what the other one is thinking. And they often go shopping together for clothes, or have a juice down the street. Never, unless they've done something terribly wrong, does he raise his voice. He's always so calm and explains everything."

Division of labour in the Thomas household is clear-cut. "I don't know if it's good or it's bad," says Grant Thomas. "But Kezza and I have very clearly defined roles. She is in charge of 'the house'. I'm in charge of 'outside the house'."

So, that means he puts out the garbage, and does the garden? "No," says the coach, as he tosses his car keys to his daughter, about to go food shopping with a friend from the family's days in Perth who is currently staying with them. "That also counts as 'the house'." He does, however, cook, his wife says, making excellent soups and risottos, creating a vast mess, and leaving it.

Kerry Thomas still shudders at the ferocity of the criticism directed at her husband in the year after the Blight sacking. "I didn't take it well. I used to grab every paper, listen to every radio station," she says.

Meanwhile Tyson, then 12, was being bullied at Middle Brighton station and at school. "It was 'Your father is going to get the sack next'. They weren't winning games," she says. "And Grant was getting bad press, shocking press. (Tyson) never said anything about it — until the school rang me."

Thomas himself shrugs off questions about the impact on him of the criticism. "If something's not true, it doesn't worry me." But former ABC and now SEN sports broadcaster Francis Leach, insisting that he speaks as a commentator, not as a longtime Saints supporter, remains incensed by a "a level of hostility that I've never witnessed before in professional sport".

"What it really told me is that there is a cartel or cabal of people in AFL football who like to protect each other's interests. They are coaches and commentators who look out for one another and protect their power base. They don't like interlopers and they were deeply threatened by him."

David Parkin, a Channel Seven Talking Footy regular and a card-carrying member of Leach's "cabal", agrees. "He'd come a bit from left field and some people in the footy fraternity didn't like the way he'd got the job," says the former Hawthorn premiership player and multi-premiership-winning coach.

"(But) most people are starting to think that (he) has got a very good idea of what a coach's job is these days. It's basically people management and he's applied good management skills to his role."

ABC TV football commentator Phil Cleary, a former Coburg captain-coach, interprets the reaction as the "boys club" of the AFL establishment "looking down its collective nose" at Thomas.

"He hadn't qualified according to their criteria, he hadn't played in a premiership, he wasn't a legend, he hadn't played a mass of games. And he'd only coached down the bush. How did this bloke seriously think he could coach? So of course they were going to bucket him. They don't bucket their own.

"But ultimately he's proved them wrong because he's taken a side to the top of the ladder."

The attitude of the players forms the ultimate verdict on Thomas, says former St Kilda coach Stan Alves, who took the club to the grand final in 1997 and the semi-finals in 1998, only to be rewarded with the sack a few weeks later.

Alves publicly savaged the club in 2001 over the dismissal of Blight. But he changed his mind on Thomas after talking to the players in the first bleak drubbing-filled weeks of season 2002. He was surprised to discover that players who had been considering quitting the previous year were now once again enjoying their football — regardless of their dismal results on the scoreboard.

"They genuinely believed that they knew where they were going. That's when I thought: 'Well, this guy's got something'."
 
So says someone from Carlton. :rolleyes:

We didn't have a ruck coach as such, Bundy filled that role. It's a stretch to suggest because we didn't have a ruck coach he didn't get any coaching. In fact I've seen it with my very own eyes at training so I pay no attention to the comments coming from a specialist ruck coach (of course he wouldn't agree with not having a specialist ruck coach).

Funny thing is, despite having a ruck coach, Carlton's ruckman are worse than ours. :D
 
So says someone from Carlton. :rolleyes:

We didn't have a ruck coach as such, Bundy filled that role. It's a stretch to suggest because we didn't have a ruck coach he didn't get any coaching. In fact I've seen it with my very own eyes at training so I pay no attention to the comments coming from a specialist ruck coach (of course he wouldn't agree with not having a specialist ruck coach).

Funny thing is, despite having a ruck coach, Carlton's ruckman are worse than ours. :D
Yep because Gardiner has been the dominant ruckman in the league over the last three years hasn't he? Has he even started in the ruck during that time?

Good luck to you.
 
Yep because Gardiner has been the dominant ruckman in the league over the last three years hasn't he? Has he even started in the ruck during that time?

Good luck to you.

He means last season :rolleyes:

Anyway next season we will have Gardiner, Kosi, Rix, and Brooks, a ruck division vastly superior to an undersized McLaren and an undersized Ackland.:thumbsu:

Lucky you, you get to see the Saints twice next season so you can draw your own conclusions.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top