How many weeks for eye gouging

[Saint12]

Not sure of the past sentencing for eye gouging, but reckon Lamb on Gresham was pretty ordinary and deserves atleast 5 weeks...and the follow up with the knee in the back might take it to 6.

 

[Orange Agent]

They'll probably give him a fine or some other slap on the wrist. The footage is pretty damning, worth a decent holiday IMO.

 

[Dazzler9]

Got a week

 

[kingswood71]

TBH, I think contact to eyes is worse than punching.....Its a pretty low act. Almost as bad as biting.

 

[Andre the Giant]

That is a disgraceful decision by the AFL, he should have got a month for that.

We all know the Jed Lamb backstory, it is terribly unfortunate what happened to his dad however his behaviour on the park is reprehensible.

He is a dead set dirty sniper and has no place in the game.

I really look forward to him getting cut at the end of the year and not have to endure his antics anymore.

 

[Saint12]

Got a week

Lol unbelievable.

 

[Spongebob]

Surely they have to charge Christian with bringing the game into disrepute.

Not sure what else after this decision.

 

[SterlingArcher]

Not sure how he only got a week.

Other serious misconduct suspensions recently:
Conor McKenna - 3 weeks for biting someone who I can't remember
Chris Masten - 2 weeks for biting Nic Suban
Jimmy Webster - 2 weeks for eye gouging Nic Suban
Chris Judd - 3 weeks for eye gouging Michael Rischitelli

The precedent is clearly 2-3 weeks. No reason for Lamb to get less.

 

[Saint12]

There was talk prior to the match that Lamb was going to target Gresham, so in other words it was also premeditated

 

[Saint12]

Not sure how he only got a week.

Other serious misconduct suspensions recently:
Conor McKenna - 3 weeks for biting someone who I can't remember
Chris Masten - 2 weeks for biting Nic Suban
Jimmy Webster - 2 weeks for eye gouging Nic Suban
Chris Judd - 3 weeks for eye gouging Michael Rischitelli

The precedent is clearly 2-3 weeks. No reason for Lamb to get less.

He is such a shit player I guess to Carlton fans the longer the sentence the better hey.

 

[SterlingArcher]

He is such a shit player I guess to Carlton fans the longer the sentence the better hey.

You'd think so but he's only going to be replaced by some other trash player.

 

[SterlingArcher]

Sicily got 1 week for stomping (treading?) on a leg. I think that should be the difference, when no serious injury occurs, between misconduct to body v misconduct to the head and face.

1-2 weeks for body, 2-3 weeks for face. Eye gouging is an extremely dangerous act.

Obviously if serious injury occurs as a consequence these precedents should be blown out of the water and a player should be looking at 6+ weeks.

For Lamb to get the same punishment as Sicily is ridiculous. Sicily deserved a week but not on the same level as an eye gouge.

 

[Saint12]

Sicily got 1 week for stomping (treading?) on a leg. I think that should be the difference, when no serious injury occurs, between misconduct to body v misconduct to the head and face.

1-2 weeks for body, 2-3 weeks for face. Eye gouging is an extremely dangerous act.

Obviously if serious injury occurs as a consequence these precedents should be blown out of the water and a player should be looking at 6+ weeks.

For Lamb to get the same punishment as Sicily is ridiculous. Sicily deserved a week but not on the same level as an eye gouge.

Agree, there wouldn't be too many more scarier moments for a person who is pinned to the ground helpless with their attackers fingers groping at their eyes.

 

[SterlingArcher]

Agree, there wouldn't be too many more scarier moments for a person who is pinned to the ground helpless with their attackers fingers groping at their eyes.

No doubt.

And I do agree with the opinions in this thread that it should be worth a month+, but would think 2-3 would be more in line with past decisions. It's terrible and there's no defending or excusing it, no matter the colours worn.

 

[Saint12]

TBH, I think contact to eyes is worse than punching.....Its a pretty low act. Almost as bad as biting.

It's worse than biting, at least with biting the offended has put his own fingers in the biters mouth.

 

[kingswood71]

It's worse than biting, at least with biting the offended has put his own fingers in the biters mouth.

Not if the biter isnt biting fingers

 

[Orange Agent]

Ridiculous.

 

[kingswood71]

Not sure how he only got a week.

Other serious misconduct suspensions recently:
Conor McKenna - 3 weeks for biting someone who I can't remember
Chris Masten - 2 weeks for biting Nic Suban
Jimmy Webster - 2 weeks for eye gouging Nic Suban
Chris Judd - 3 weeks for eye gouging Michael Rischitelli

The precedent is clearly 2-3 weeks. No reason for Lamb to get less.

The AFL should really challenge that week!

 

[Randomizor]

The AFL should really challenge that week!

They should. Instead they will probably apologise to Carlton and give them an extra Friday night game next year as compensation.

 

[Donakebab]

Jed Lamb continues to be the biggest piece of shit in the league.

 

[hawkman]

Deserved more than a week but Sicily will be happy he won't be there to annoy him this week

 

[Strapping Young Lad]

There was talk prior to the match that Lamb was going to target Gresham, so in other words it was also premeditated

That's all Lamb does. He's a shitful footballer.

Deisel Williams said it best.
"I also hate the pushing and the shoving and, you know, (Jed) Lamb from Carlton just hassling blokes because he’s not that good a player. They’re allowed to punch and push opponents ... it’s weak as water, that. Carlton are doing it and they can’t even play. They’re s---house and they’re going around acting like they’re tough. I think it’s disgusting. It does nothing for the game and for junior football."

 

[westie]

If there was ever a Christian that should be thrown to the Lions it's him. The tribunal is the joke that keeps on giving.Maybe Baguley knew something after all.

 

[CakeEater]

So he gets less for an eye gouge then Nyhuis getting a tackle ?

Thats an interesting conundrum

 

[Wallaby]

I didn't realise that Jed Lamb was so .............. regarded by the football community (including by Carlton supporters).

It puts the whack he got Bachar Houli into a bit more perspective (Houli got 4 and rightly so - and everyone else was surprised because it was the first physical thing they had ever seen Houli do).

Makes you think.