I Will Grant You One Wish BUT

[The Coach]

It is a long time until Saturday and I am bored so here goes

If you could add one of our past champions to our current line up who would it be ?

NOW what if

It could not be someone from our Team of the Century

B:Bruce Comben Stephen Silvagni Geoff Southby HB:John James Bert Deacon Bruce Doull C:Garry Crane Greg Williams Craig Bradley HF:Wayne Johnston Stephen Kernahan Alex Jesaulenko F:Ken Hands Harry Vallence Rod Ashman Ruck:John Nicholls Serge Silvagni Adrian Gallagher Interchange:Robert Walls Mike Fitzpatrick Ken Hunter Trevor Keogh Coach:David Parkin Emergencies:Laurie Kerr Horrie Clover Bob Chitty Rod McGregor

http://www.blueseum.org/tiki-index.php?page=Carlton+Team+of+the+Century

From the TOTC I would go Nicholls marginally over Kernahan - they would both make us walk tall (with honorable mentions to all the others of course)

Outside of the TOTC is even harder to choose, I am going with Crosswell (counting his North record here too) from Rhys-Jones and Kouta (with honorable mentions to Fraser Brown, Maclure, Dean, ....)

 

[Sin City]

Chitty, would be great to watch lol.

Being serious though couldn't go past Kouta at his best.

 

[ESKIE]

Jezza......

(or The Doormat)

 

[TheNumber4]

The Number 4!!!

 

[Quazza]

hmmm if i was picking a fave, it would be Diesel but I'm going to pick mine on team need. A young Stephen Kernahan

outside of "the team" I would say Rhys-Jones, but lets face it, he'd only play 2 games a year. So I'll go a fit Kouta

 

[blue gunslinger]

WA - Hunter or Fitzpatrick please
Otherwise Jezza

 

[Silvagnis]

Angwin.







I mean Andrew McKay so we can show Reimers the true definition of reimered...

Sorry Deano.

Brett Ratten or Kouta would be handy too.

 

[Hayashi_62]

Jezza or Kernahan, someone who can kick some goals.

 

[as0l0]

i wish i had never clicked on this thread

 

[BlueDevil]

from TOTC big nick i say. move young kreuz to CHF

outside of that kouta.

 

[HBF]

From TOTC, I would go for Silvagni, ahead of Kernahan, and then The Dominator.

Outside TOTC, Kouta at his best would be my selection, although a rampaging Peter Bosustow would be handy inside 50 with Fev.

 

[The Old Dark Navy's]

SOS from the TOTC as he is a key position player equally adept at playing FB, CHB and FF. Dominator is my fave but our midfield is good already and Jezza is a general and a genius but we have Judd for that.

Would consider changing my opinion for Diesel though. Never known a player to bring others into the play like Diesel could.

From outside the team, has to be a fit and firing Kouta due to his versatility but Andrew McKay wouldn't be a bad compromise.

 

[E Shed]

Sexton or McKay would go alright in your backline about now.

 

[thylacine60]

Proof positive reading and comprehending are often words apart.

 

[True Bluebagger]

As we desperately a key defender to help mentor and teach the younger backman, it would hard to go past a 25 yr. old, Bruce Doull.

SOS would do if Doully couldn't get away from his newsagency!!!

 

[The Coach]

Proof positive reading and comprehending are often words apart.

Are you happy now you whinging old bastard

 

[CTwenty]

Are you happy now you whinging old bastard

Can't speak for Thy but I am!!!

 

[thylacine60]

Jesus - go easy, OddMan. Was just pointing out your request for suggestions outside the TOTC being met with so many suggestions from inside it. Sheesh...

 

[Blue Dawn]

My head hurts!

 

[Azul]

Jesus - go easy, OddMan. Was just pointing out your request for suggestions outside the TOTC being met with so many suggestions from inside it. Sheesh...

Yes well back on topic, we're crying out for a key forward to compliment Fev so Earl Spalding for mine.

 

[The Coach]

Jesus - go easy, OddMan. Was just pointing out your request for suggestions outside the TOTC being met with so many suggestions from inside it. Sheesh...

Now youre not happy with special treatment FFS

this should balance the ledger

(or be more to your liking )

 

[The Coach]

Yes well back on topic, we're crying out for a key forward to compliment Fev so Earl Spalding for mine.

'

I did give him consideration Azul - would add a nice dose of 'vigour' too

 

[thylacine60]

Would definitely go there except for the dubious drink issue.

 

[gbatman]

don't make me choose!

 

[TOPBLUE_25]

Kouta then maybe Ratten