Injury Injury thread 2014/15

[Chris_6678]

Cavka was looking fit in the video on the website.

 

[Keys]

Still 10 weeks away, for a 12-week injury he suffered 6 weeks ago.

Something wrong with the maths there.

pantskyle is doing the injury list it seems

 

[ioppolo]

Given a lot of us saw Tunners as delist material pre season, does he get a free pass for a season ending injury?

 

[AsterixTheGaul]

Given a lot of us saw Tunners as delist material pre season, does he get a free pass for a season ending injury?

All depends on how they rate the draft. Mixed reviews. Some saying it is weak but I think it is weak if you are tall shopping. I believe the midfield depth is sounding reasonable. Will know more after the U18 carnival.

Bottom line is another year of midfield drafting like 2014 - then we start to look like a real threat.

Where I stand now - Tunners would be off my list (may regret this but hey...would love to be proven wrong)

 

[Johnno22]

All depends on how they rate the draft. Mixed reviews. Some saying it is weak but I think it is weak if you are tall shopping. I believe the midfield depth is sounding reasonable. Will know more after the U18 carnival.

Bottom line is another year of midfield drafting like 2014 - then we start to look like a real threat.

Where I stand now - Tunners would be off my list (may regret this but hey...would love to be proven wrong)

Delist. Rerookie if nothing better available.

 

[dajesmac]

Tunbridge has already been a rookie. He habitually gets injured every time he has been given a chance. I don't think we will ever be able to extract his talent, delist.

Delist Main too but re rookie him. He should have been a rookie to begin with.

 

[Dugg]

Delist. Rerookie if nothing better available.

If he can be back before the end of the season and depending on where our season is headed, maybe give him a couple of weeks to prove his worth before making a decision. If he can't get up, delist.

 

[AsterixTheGaul]

If he can be back before the end of the season and depending on where our season is headed, maybe give him a couple of weeks to prove his worth before making a decision. If he can't get up, delist.

I cannot see him getting a game this year. McInnes will be unlucky with Darling coming back and Lamb will be back in less time.

Besides, 2 weeks is nothing - just ask Mick. And as he said yesterday, what benefit will 2 weeks give us when we have seen him for 4 years?

 

[Dugg]

I cannot see him getting a game this year. McInnes will be unlucky with Darling coming back and Lamb will be back in less time.

Besides, 2 weeks is nothing - just ask Mick. And as he said yesterday, what benefit will 2 weeks give us when we have seen him for 3 years?

I can't see him getting a game either. But depending on where our season is heading, he may be worth giving a last crack.

In his defence, he looked pretty good in the game earlier this year.

 

[WCErevival]

I'd say delist. He's been with us for what 4 years? Played one half decent game. We have plenty of forwards.

 

[ioppolo]

I'd say delist. He's been with us for what 4 years? Played one half decent game. We have plenty of forwards.

That long? That went quick.

 

[Piss Poor]

Yeah Turners time is up you'd think. McInnes has stepped up and can provide that back up key position player, Turners is dead weight.

 

[bodazoka]

In his defence, he looked pretty good in the game earlier this year.

He did but not great, he was noticeable and did some nice things but he certainly didn't have a "breakout" game. If you want 2-3 selections in the draft and maybe a FA we need to de-list 2-3 of the below.

Colledge
Cavka
Karpany
Main
Tunbridge

If these guys are lucky Ellis might retire this year to free up another spot with Waters meaning 1 x de-list for 3 x spots.

 

[WCErevival]

He did but not great, he was noticeable and did some nice things but he certainly didn't have a "breakout" game. If you want 2-3 selections in the draft and maybe a FA we need to de-list 2-3 of the below.

Colledge
Cavka
Karpany
Main
Tunbridge

If these guys are lucky Ellis might retire this year to free up another spot with Waters meaning 1 x de-list for 3 x spots.

Cavka hasn't even been with us for half a season

 

[Prem87]

No way we delist Cavka already.

Main has to go. Colledge is safe with one more year left on his contract. Karpany needs a little time, but would be happy to get rid of him and Tunbridge has been here too long and hasn't show enough.

 

[bodazoka]

No way we delist Cavka already.

Main has to go. Colledge is safe with one more year left on his contract. Karpany needs a little time, but would be happy to get rid of him and Tunbridge has been here too long and hasn't show enough.

My bad didn't realise he was a new guy! If Colledge is contracted its Carpany, Main or Tunbridge and at this stage at least 2 of these guys.

 

[Broken_Chairs]

He did but not great, he was noticeable and did some nice things but he certainly didn't have a "breakout" game. If you want 2-3 selections in the draft and maybe a FA we need to de-list 2-3 of the below.

Colledge
Cavka
Karpany
Main
Tunbridge

If these guys are lucky Ellis might retire this year to free up another spot with Waters meaning 1 x de-list for 3 x spots.

pretty sure mcginnity was on a 1yr contract, surely he's gone at year end

no way is cavka going

karps and main i can see going.

tunners... wouldn't be surprised if he's gone.

 

[WCErevival]

Dont forget Waters retirement gives us another list spot.

 

[jakethebear]

My bad didn't realise he was a new guy! If Colledge is contracted its Cavka, Main or Tunbridge and at this stage at least 2 of these guys.

Not quite sure what you mean by this. Cavka will definitely not be gone. New draftees have a two year contract.

 

[Lyyynnnchy]

He did but not great, he was noticeable and did some nice things but he certainly didn't have a "breakout" game. If you want 2-3 selections in the draft and maybe a FA we need to de-list 2-3 of the below.

Colledge
Cavka
Karpany
Main
Tunbridge

If these guys are lucky Ellis might retire this year to free up another spot with Waters meaning 1 x de-list for 3 x spots.

Colledge is under contract
Cavka is under contract having been with the club for no more than 6 months

So you can scratch those 2 off of your list

I'm happy for Main, Tunbridge and Karpany to all go

 

[dajesmac]

You can still delist a contracted player.

 

[the harry]

Colledge is under contract
Cavka is under contract having been with the club for no more than 6 months

So you can scratch those 2 off of your list

I'm happy for Main, Tunbridge and Karpany to all go

Waters is gone already, Ellis is a serious worry (9 weeks for a minor hamstring?), Butler would have been on the list to go 3 months ago but he needs to keep the form up for the rest of the season, McGinnity is very close to going surely too.

Won't be hard to get 4/5 changes from our senior list this season.

 

[Lyyynnnchy]

Waters is gone already, Ellis is a serious worry (9 weeks for a minor hamstring?), Butler would have been on the list to go 3 months ago but he needs to keep the form up for the rest of the season, McGinnity is very close to going surely too.

Won't be hard to get 4/5 changes from our senior list this season.

I wasn't saying it would be hard, just that Colledge and Cavka won't be on the delist list

I'd go 5 of the 6 below

Waters
Mcginnity
Ellis
Main
Karpany
Tunbridge

 

[DanWCE]

Waters is gone already, Ellis is a serious worry (9 weeks for a minor hamstring?), Butler would have been on the list to go 3 months ago but he needs to keep the form up for the rest of the season, McGinnity is very close to going surely too.

Won't be hard to get 4/5 changes from our senior list this season.

Ellis latest injury is a calf so would think he pinged that in his rehab program, which still does not bode well for him

 

[dajesmac]

Waters is gone already, Ellis is a serious worry (9 weeks for a minor hamstring?), Butler would have been on the list to go 3 months ago but he needs to keep the form up for the rest of the season, McGinnity is very close to going surely too.

Won't be hard to get 4/5 changes from our senior list this season.

To be fair to Ellis the hamstring injury turned into a calf like halfway through.his calves have nearly ruined his career once already.