Ins and Outs

[Ausyid]

I know it's early but here are my ins and outs for Freo.

Out: Yze, Bate, P. Johnson, Moloney

In: Dunn (if fit), Pickett, Buckley, Petterd

Moloney out because when he has the ball he is ok but he has zero accountability when we aren't in possession and his direct opponent does whatever the hell he wants while Beamer strolls around.

Yze is past it and probabbly shouldn't play again for us unless he seriously gets his act together.

Bate does not go hard enough at the ball and doesn't use the ball well either.

P. Johnson is a class below AFL level. Hopefully he can prove me wrong.

Dunn should walk back into the team when he is fit because of our forward line injuries.

We lack the hardness that Pickett brought to the side last year. I don't care if he's fat he is better than Bate, Moloney etc.

Buckley and Petterd deserve a go and can't be any worse then the headless chickens who were on the field today.

Thoughts?

 

[stickman11]

I know it's early but here are my ins and outs for Freo.

Out: Yze, Bate, P. Johnson, Moloney

In: Dunn (if fit), Pickett, Buckley, Petterd

Moloney out because when he has the ball he is ok but he has zero accountability when we aren't in possession and his direct opponent does whatever the hell he wants while Beamer strolls around.

Yze is past it and probabbly shouldn't play again for us unless he seriously gets his act together.

Bate does not go hard enough at the ball and doesn't use the ball well either.

P. Johnson is a class below AFL level. Hopefully he can prove me wrong.

Dunn should walk back into the team when he is fit because of our forward line injuries.

We lack the hardness that Pickett brought to the side last year. I don't care if he's fat he is better than Bate, Moloney etc.

Buckley and Petterd deserve a go and can't be any worse then the headless chickens who were on the field today.

Thoughts?

Yze gaveus more drive than some of the duds in the team and moloney wasn't bad.

I'd rather see Carrol who is useless, Godfrey, Ward, Johnson and Holland all given the flick.

 

[Number32]

IN: (if these players are fit) Dunn, pickett, sylvia, pettard, bizzell

OUT: Holland, Bate, either (p.johnson or jamar, cant have 3 ruckmen), godfrey, yze

 

[Number32]

also put carroll in the out category as well and bring in garland or buckley

 

[stickman11]

also put carroll in the out category as well and bring in garland or buckley

Yze won't get dropped. He was quite good this week.

 

[bringbackschwarter5]

Amazing to see how quick people turn on Carroll

 

[Demonic Ascent]

IN: Longmire

OUT: Daniher

 

[ExTasDeeMan]

Yze won't get dropped. He was quite good this week.

Which game were you watching? Probably the same one that Yze was watching. Didn't have any guts or skills today.

 

[stickman11]

Which game were you watching? Probably the same one that Yze was watching. Didn't have any guts or skills today.

You sound like a record player... trot out the same line week in week out. Year in year out. At least he got the ball moving forward which is a lot more than some out there today, like cough davey. Yze got 21 disposals, that is more han davey has got in three weeks.

 

[stickman11]

Amazing to see how quick people turn on Carroll

Turn. I don't believe I had any confidence in the blokes ability in the first place. Simply horrible, never knows what to do with the ball when he has it.

 

[trav_16]

Yze won't get dropped. He was quite good this week.

I agree with you about Yze and Carrol, but my problem is Miller, I cant stand him every time i watch him it Amazes me how he gets a game week in week out

 

[demonfan9]

Drop Moloney?

You're kidding.

One of our most important and passionate players.

 

[Ausyid]

Drop Moloney?

You're kidding.

One of our most important and passionate players.

Watch his opponent lead for the ball and with Moloney strolling behind him. No accountability whatsoever. Who cares if he can kick a long ball he needs to man up also.

 

[Number32]

Yze won't get dropped. He was quite good this week.

He wasnt quite good, he does not know what the word hard means and makes mistakes time after time, it looks like he just cant be bothered sometimes to even kick the ball correctly

 

[ExTasDeeMan]

You sound like a record player... trot out the same line week in week out. Year in year out. At least he got the ball moving forward which is a lot more than some out there today, like cough davey. Yze got 21 disposals, that is more han davey has got in three weeks.

21 extremely cheap possessions (which were crud kicks and handballs). You seem to be classing Yze in a class when if he gets X number of possessions, that he has played a good game. Really. He is THE senior player of the MFC at the moment and he is playing like a 1st year draft pick. Just not good enough and he knows it.

He plays unaccountable football generally, but at least he kicked a few goals or kicked hard from the backline. Now, he does nothing.

Trotting the same line - week in and week out (year in year out), i think not. I used to enjoy his play, but we should have traded him for some beans when we had the chance.

 

[demonfan9]

Watch his opponent lead for the ball and with Moloney strolling behind him. No accountability whatsoever. Who cares if he can kick a long ball he needs to man up also.

He goes in hard, kicks goals, hits targets and bleeds for the team.

At the moment we don't have many of these types of players.

 

[stickman11]

21 extremely cheap possessions (which were crud kicks and handballs). You seem to be classing Yze in a class when if he gets X number of possessions, that he has played a good game. Really. .

Mmmme. You must kill them on the field from your keayboard.

Funny how everyone is an expert. It is a sad reflection on the average Melbourne supporter. No idea.

 

[master bate]

Moloney will be out cause his groins gone again i think, but geez mate he is one of the only blokes who gives it his all, he might not be the most talented but he really has a crack and is accountable, i was watching him when we were 10 goals down in 2005 Elim Final v Geelong and he was chasing half the Geelong team whilst Trav and Yze stood there, i felt pleased when he turned round and had a good crack at them.

 

[ExTasDeeMan]

Mmmme. You must kill them on the field from your keayboard.

Funny how everyone is an expert. It is a sad reflection on the average Melbourne supporter. No idea.

Stop being a fu cking apologist. Do you watch games on the TV or do you watch them at the ground?

The average melbourne supporter should be angry and expect more of the team. If they don't think angry thoughts when any Melbourne player shirks a contest or kicks (and handballs) sideways, then they aren't really supporters.

 

[Marns]

Mmmme. You must kill them on the field from your keayboard.

Funny how everyone is an expert. It is a sad reflection on the average Melbourne supporter. No idea.

I don't think anyone claims to be an expert. Most of us can claim to be fed up though, which is more than justified.