James Aish

[Sam_Malone]

Sorry I just realised this was your board, thought it was the trading board... I usually don't bring my opinions to other teams boards if they're in disagreement.

Edit: I'm hoping it's the usual bs from Barrett because Aish impressed me in second half of season

Are you saying its not for "cap space"?

Would you go Harry Dear for Aish?

 

[MRB37]

Didn't want to come to Adelaide last year, don't think that would have changed now that he's spent the year in Melbourne.

 

[FAITH]

Man something is wrong with the lad.

 

[headache1]

Man something is wrong with the lad.

Assuming it's true, it really does seem odd that his name would even be floated considering he arrived just last year and started to play some good footy toward the end of the season. Maybe he's an utter campaigner of a person?

 

[GROTTO]

We need a strong squad to win finals footy, if Aish came at a cheap price, the Club should look at getting him.

Our time is now.

 

[Cleric]

Nah he had a chance to come home and didnt.
Stay in Melbourne and rot in the VFL for all.I care.

 

[MRB37]

With the media in SA I really don't blame him for not wanting to come here. He'd have massive expectations on him, constantly being compared to other Aish's, he can just be another face in the crowd in Melbourne.

 

[adelaidecrows]

Nah he had a chance to come home and didnt.
Stay in Melbourne and rot in the VFL for all.I care.

He will be cheaper now, collingwood have got buckleys chance of getting anything like they gave away to brisbane. But if they offer him to us for our future 2nd round pick that has to be worth considering. Aish, Rockliff and Gibbs would be one hell of a midfield.

 

[1970crow]

Sorry I just realised this was your board, thought it was the trading board... I usually don't bring my opinions to other teams boards if they're in disagreement.

Edit: I'm hoping it's the usual bs from Barrett because Aish impressed me in second half of season

I thought he looked good in an effortless kind of way in the couple of games I saw.

 

[Redleg Crow]

His game against us reminded me of why I rated him when he played for Norwood.

It's a buyers market this year, so would grab him cheap.

 

[Crowbots are dead]

Where is the actual link or sauce about this? Sounds like rubbish

 

[Sanders]

100% no

 

[daniel_4tw]

I remember when he was drafted. Kid was suppose to be a gun from the get go and this board was gutted we missed out on him.

What happened?

 

[Cleric]

I remember when he was drafted. Kid was suppose to be a gun from the get go and this board was gutted we missed out on him.

What happened?

He ego outweighed his abilities.

 

[mattymac]

Cheaper? He's now on a 3 year contract and played well for us this year.. no way you'll be getting him cheaper

3rd rounder. If you're shopping him already there are issues.

 

[conVINCEd]

Nah he had a chance to come home and didnt.
Stay in Melbourne and rot in the VFL for all.I care.

Jeepers. I'm guessing you're in the 'no to Gibbs' squad as well?

 

[Tex200]

Can't believe this is even a discussion. Hope we go nowhere near him

 

[Tex200]

Jeepers. I'm guessing you're in the 'no to Gibbs' squad as well?

Why would Aish and Gibbs be in the same sentence ?

 

[Apsaalooke]

With the media in SA I really don't blame him for not wanting to come here. He'd have massive expectations on him, constantly being compared to other Aish's, he can just be another face in the crowd in Melbourne.

Come on that was a generation ago and there was only Michael Aish - his father Andrew was just another Trevor Chappell. If he can't cope with being compared to a past uncle then he hasn't got it for AFL. I didn't see the Robrans or Eberts have a mental problem with this and their fathers were in a different league to James' uncle.

 

[WetCrow1991]

Table scraps you wouldn't even give to the dog. A certified dud.

 

[Rotayjay]

Come on that was a generation ago and there was only Michael Aish - his father Andrew was just another Trevor Chappell. If he can't cope with being compared to a past uncle then he hasn't got it for AFL. I didn't see the Robrans or Eberts have a mental problem with this and their fathers were in a different league to James' uncle.

I agree. James Aish sounds like an absolute soft****.

 

[Infra Ted]

I would still be happy to have him at Adelaide, at the right price. Has potential and has shown some good signs. I believe he wanted to go to Collingwood originally because Scharenberg (his best mate) was there. Not going good for Scharenberg. Also was rumored that he went for the girls and party lifestyle. Maybe not all he thought it would be? Or maybe it was for the success that the media was telling us Collingwood were gonna have (lock them in for finals, most likely top-4)....guess they were just unlucky this year....

Completely forgot about Scharenberg. Is he still at the pies?

 

[Tex200]

Hine has shut it down

 

[RePete]

Completely forgot about Scharenberg. Is he still at the pies?

Yeah. Spent the whole year recovering from his 2nd knee reconstruction. Who knows if he will be anything after that.

 

[TradeDraft]

Hine has shut it down

Showing Damo is an Idiot and Aish was never thought of as Tradable in face is Untouchable