Just a quick question

[OldStyle2007]

I don't think we are being one eyed about McPhee

I too had heard all the hype about this guy and have been watching a few bombers matches this season.

Quite honestly, he has been horrible for Essendon this season. He may be injured, but his onfield attitude is really poor. For a senior player he shows no leadership in his decision making or effort

OK, as a backmen you get beaten sometimes but McPhee looks like he doesn't care that much

Look at Harley last week against Burton. He got beaten a couple of times, but also won his fair share of contests, and ALWAYS tried 100%

IF I was a bombers supporter, I would be trying to offload McPhee for someone who gives a damn too

 

[darren forssman]

I'd say he would be up there with Kelly, Varcoe and Byrnes. He could replace any of these guys (more so Kelly than the others). They better watch out!

kelly = yes

varcoe and byrnes = no

i am not saying delist/trade him but if a team throws out a deal i am sure geelong will think about.