If they bid on Viney can anyone seriously see us passing on Grundy/Whitfield? Particularly given I think GWS will finish last and take Grundy at 1, leaving Whitfield to "slip".
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.

LIVE: Geelong v Gold Coast - Rd 14 - 7:40PM Fri
Squiggle tips Cats at 78% chance -- What's your tip? -- Injury Lists » -- All Rd 14 Games
100% yes, I'm convinced you'll take Viney no matter what. I can't foresee a situation where you'd let him go, even if it meant missing out on Grundy or Whitfield.If they bid on Viney can anyone seriously see us passing on Grundy/Whitfield? Particularly given I think GWS will finish last and take Grundy at 1, leaving Whitfield to "slip".
I'm really not interested in the fact they said it... I'm only interested in whether they meant it, and at this point in time I'd really doubt if even the Demons know what they'll do if someone bids early. But Melbourne fans throw it up, as though it's an iron clad guarantee (a "fact", if you like) that they won't take Viney with pick 3 because it's a fact that the club has said something to that effect. I just don't buy that it's as simple as that, and think Demon's fans are trying to talk themselves into this "I'd be happy to miss out on Viney" crap. For the sake of one or two draft places (assuming he's rated 5th best player in this year's batch) I'd be spewing if it was my club.It's irrelevant what I believe or don't believe. I'm merely giving you the facts. You can please yourself what you do with them.

Log in to remove this Banner Ad
I'm really not interested in the fact they said it... I'm only interested in whether they meant it, and at this point in time I'd really doubt if even the Demons know what they'll do if someone bids early. But Melbourne fans throw it up, as though it's an iron clad guarantee (a "fact", if you like) that they won't take Viney with pick 3 because it's a fact that the club has said something to that effect. I just don't buy that it's as simple as that, and think Demon's fans are trying to talk themselves into this "I'd be happy to miss out on Viney" crap. For the sake of one or two draft places (assuming he's rated 5th best player in this year's batch) I'd be spewing if it was my club.
But at the risk of derailing KM's thread, I'd say we agree to disagree![]()
Really like your new second round selection for the Bombers KM.
Essendon are in need of more KPP's so i would not be immune to see us take a KPP (forward or back) in the second round as well (even after selecting Joey with our first pick)..
We have plenty of young midfielders (developing) on our list already, off the top of my hear, we have Michael Ross, Elliot Kavanagh, Jackson Merret, Trav Colyer as well as younger guys in the ones like Melksham and hopefully Heppel can push up into the midfield group.
We may look to select an inside midfielder to develop for down the track as we do have a couple of high production inside midfielders (Jobe Watson & Ben Howlett) but then a handful of b/c grade inside mids (Nathan Lovett - Murray, Sam Lonergan, David Myers who seems to be more a stop gap inside mid).
I would also love to see us select a utility type who can play anywhere, much like Lovett - Murray has done for us over the past couple of years in particular.(however, you might be able to help, could you see Nick O'Brien as a utility type whom Essendon selected in the third round last year, or is he more of only a forward)..
Having seen where our list is at KM, our needs are really for
1. KPP x 2 (we do seem to like our swingmen who can play both forward and back, see Jake Carlisle, Michael Hurley, Cale Hooker was drafted as a forward - for this reason, I would LOVE to see us have a look at Tom Lee from Claremont)
2. Ruckmen (even though we do have Joe Daniher coming in, I would love to see us draft one we can develop).
3. Small forward
4. Utility
5. Inside midfielders
Will keep the KPP needs in mind for Essendon. In the 2nd round there probably won't be a great deal of value available but perhaps later on someone slips through.
After Grundy there just aren't the ruck options. McBean could be a ruck option at his height if available but won't ever be a power ruckman.
Otherwise it's pretty much wait it out till the rookie draft.
Small forwards can always be added late draft/ rookie. Plenty of options. Anthony Tipungwuti, Anthony Bonnaddio, Marvin Warrell and Jarrod Stokes would be some others I'd look at.
As utilities Jackson Thurlow might be an option mid draft. Matthew Haynes as a quicker tall outside utility can play back and some forward. Cameron Banfield, Nic Amato and Mason Wood might be some later draft options who could also be worth looking at also with versatility.
As inside mids Nathan Hrovat, Jesse Lonergan and Nathan Stark could be worth looking at 2nd round and beyond.
I'm guessing with Tom Lee you heard about the 12 mark, 7 goal game too? His numbers are looking good this year and continues to improve so you might be onto something.
Tom Lee is so last year. Better late than never to jump on though.![]()
Anyone your keen on from the state leagues in SA Christoff?
Seen people are talking up Duffy a bit (even though he is from WA), but anyone from SA that are really demanding selection?
Duffy was one of my guys last year. Talent wise, he should have gone in the second round. Crazy that nobody rookied him.
Most of the guys from SA are your solid half back types - Spurr, Pfeiffer, Duigan. No doubt some of those solid older types will finally get a chance, but SANFL takes a back seat to U18 football for me. Sp most of the ones I like are guys who were overlooked last year (Hender, Raikiwasa, Gallard, Langford), along with a couple of new recruits from interstate. But I've probably mentioned them all already.
I know you (along with Chris and now Tigs) have gone through this a number of times, but are there really NO other ruckmen worth mentioning? Even ones that you could stick on the rookie list because that is where they need to grow the most these days.
Word out there is that Dean Putt (yes the former Richmond player who Essendon were going to draft before the Tigs poached him two picks prior to us selection Cale Hooker) are very interested in him and thus the reason for him playing at Aberfeldie in the Essendon District Football League along as a top up player with the Bendigo Gold with out VFL team who has put in some really strong games, was BOg in our earlier win against Casey in a very depleted Bendigo side. There is another young guy by the name of Michael Sikora who has dominated the hitouts at times this year for Sandringham, pity he is only averaging something like 8 possessions per game, he is young in terms of ruckmen also. I think we will look to add a ruckmen, a kid, 19/20 y.o (how has Bolger gone this year by the way?) to develop, Id prefer us to go this way rather than log jamb our ruckmen all being in that same age group (TBC 22, Ryder is 24, Hille is 30).
i would love for us to add a genuine small forward, not a make shift one in the Kyle Reimers mould (a midfielder we are playing as a small forward) but a genuine crumber, like jeffy Garlett.
The utility type I am talking about is that Nathan Lovett - Murray mould who can play anywhere, tall or small, forward or back, can you give me some more info on Banfield & amato? havent seen there names thrown around yet, so curious.
As for the inside mids you mentioned, the other one i would love to see is one I have spoken to you about is Jason Pongracic who kicked 4 goals playing forward yesterday for Dandenong. Mate umpired them and said he was awesome. kicked a stunning goal on the run from 30 after busting a couple of tackles just to highlight his strength in the contest. i could definitely see Essendon picking Lonergan purely on the back of his uncle being at Essendon (people suggesting romanticism does not exist anymore are either blind or stupid, it still is), as for Hrovat, surely he will go inside the top 20? his production outside of the champs has been up there with the best.
As for Tom Lee's stellar game against Swan Districts, yeah heard about it, have got someone sending me a copy of the game that's how interested i am to see how bloody good he was.. Article came out during the week about Frankston's in demand key forward Khan Haretuku suggesting up to half a dozen clubs are looking at him, and that it also tells of Ross Lyon telling Khan he was "not good enough and won't make it" because he "does not have enough talent". So there is another player to keep in mind when doing the later stages of your draft KM.
But i would definitely keep Tom Lee as an option for a national draft pick, his numbers in the past month has been extraordinary.
knightmare you seemed to have forgoten Laine Wilkins do you not rate him if not. Why not inside football has rated him as going in the first round
Sikora is 206cm, 102kg, 26.1.1989, played for the Melbourne Tigers under 18 basketball team, so this 23 y.o has come on in leaps and bounds in his short time in the AFL scene, as supported by his selection in the VFL Academy.
Stats are here
There is a short 6.5 minute clip on youtube with some highlights from last year.Always room for size.
Hitout numbers promising and in talls it's that quick improvement I look for so that sounds positive. Are many of those taps to advantage? If so then we might have something.
How is his pace, agility + leap?
Tackling numbers interesting and looks to have more potential to improve in that regard.
Going by the stats he will need to do more around the ground and add some more tricks - maybe learn to go forward and take some more marks and hit the scoreboard or just add something else to his game.
Haven't seen him play as far as I know but will make an effort to look out for him over this last little bit.
There is a short 6.5 minute clip on youtube with some highlights from last year.
I saw him earlier in the year and he was alright against Bendigo. To be fair, we did not have a ruckmen (we had Essendon's fitness coach in as our ruckmen), dominated the hitouts, 45 to be exact, if i remember correctly, tried to tap to advantage, looked fairly agile and mobile for a big man. Id have to go back and look at the tapes to rejig the old memory bank..
I know you (along with Chris and now Tigs) have gone through this a number of times, but are there really NO other ruckmen worth mentioning? Even ones that you could stick on the rookie list because that is where they need to grow the most these days.
Word out there is that Dean Putt (yes the former Richmond player who Essendon were going to draft before the Tigs poached him two picks prior to us selection Cale Hooker) are very interested in him and thus the reason for him playing at Aberfeldie in the Essendon District Football League along as a top up player with the Bendigo Gold with out VFL team who has put in some really strong games, was BOg in our earlier win against Casey in a very depleted Bendigo side. There is another young guy by the name of Michael Sikora who has dominated the hitouts at times this year for Sandringham, pity he is only averaging something like 8 possessions per game, he is young in terms of ruckmen also. I think we will look to add a ruckmen, a kid, 19/20 y.o (how has Bolger gone this year by the way?) to develop, Id prefer us to go this way rather than log jamb our ruckmen all being in that same age group (TBC 22, Ryder is 24, Hille is 30).
i would love for us to add a genuine small forward, not a make shift one in the Kyle Reimers mould (a midfielder we are playing as a small forward) but a genuine crumber, like jeffy Garlett.
The utility type I am talking about is that Nathan Lovett - Murray mould who can play anywhere, tall or small, forward or back, can you give me some more info on Banfield & amato? havent seen there names thrown around yet, so curious.
As for the inside mids you mentioned, the other one i would love to see is one I have spoken to you about is Jason Pongracic who kicked 4 goals playing forward yesterday for Dandenong. Mate umpired them and said he was awesome. kicked a stunning goal on the run from 30 after busting a couple of tackles just to highlight his strength in the contest. i could definitely see Essendon picking Lonergan purely on the back of his uncle being at Essendon (people suggesting romanticism does not exist anymore are either blind or stupid, it still is), as for Hrovat, surely he will go inside the top 20? his production outside of the champs has been up there with the best.
As for Tom Lee's stellar game against Swan Districts, yeah heard about it, have got someone sending me a copy of the game that's how interested i am to see how bloody good he was.. Article came out during the week about Frankston's in demand key forward Khan Haretuku suggesting up to half a dozen clubs are looking at him, and that it also tells of Ross Lyon telling Khan he was "not good enough and won't make it" because he "does not have enough talent". So there is another player to keep in mind when doing the later stages of your draft KM.
But i would definitely keep Tom Lee as an option for a national draft pick, his numbers in the past month has been extraordinary.
Bolger seems to have really stagnated. Can't really see him going this year unless he has a massive finish to the year.
Haretuku will go. Haven't seen Sikora play but he certainly sounds intriguing. Those big basketball blokes seem to go pretty well, have excellent co-ordination and develop quickly. Maybe we will have a crack after we missed Joe Ingles a few years ago.I'd say Pierce and Prowse are the other 2 youngsters that could go late. I know teams are looking at Prowse. Pierce reminds me of Angus Graham and it makes me cringe.Bolger seems to have really stagnated. Can't really see him going this year unless he has a massive finish to the year.
Not sure if its romanticism in football or its more the fact you can get a very good feel for a players character as well as their ability to settle in as an interstater. Wouldn't surprise to see Brendan Verrier on our list if available late because a) he fills a need and b) his brother is a bit homesick.
Would love Tom Lee for us as an athletic CHF that's ready to go. He'd be better than McGuane/Miller. ShhhhHaretuku will go. Haven't seen Sikora play but he certainly sounds intriguing. Those big basketball blokes seem to go pretty well, have excellent co-ordination and develop quickly. Maybe we will have a crack after we missed Joe Ingles a few years ago.
I'm really not interested in the fact they said it... I'm only interested in whether they meant it, and at this point in time I'd really doubt if even the Demons know what they'll do if someone bids early. But Melbourne fans throw it up, as though it's an iron clad guarantee (a "fact", if you like) that they won't take Viney with pick 3 because it's a fact that the club has said something to that effect. I just don't buy that it's as simple as that, and think Demon's fans are trying to talk themselves into this "I'd be happy to miss out on Viney" crap. For the sake of one or two draft places (assuming he's rated 5th best player in this year's batch) I'd be spewing if it was my club.
But at the risk of derailing KM's thread, I'd say we agree to disagree![]()
Absolutely. I saw him play for Clarmeont vz Port Melbourne yesterday.....what a talent! Any reasons as to why he hasn't been drafted as yet?