Leon davis Vs Heath scotland

[BLUES9898]

Just wanted to get evryones idea on who has been the better player this year
tbh its way too hard to spilt both deserve all Australian

 

[jonoman89]

Both have different roles. Scotland has floated through the middle more whereas Davis has locked down on his opponent. Davis for mine....just.

But Scotland has been fantastic as well. Both deserve AA.

 

[SexyBlueGirl]

Leon just, but both AA as jono said.

 

[Terex8]

I'll go with the dual All Australian, who has a premiership medallion.

 

[jonoman89]

I'll go with the Collingwood player

That looks like a better reflection of your mindset i reckon.

Dual AA is he? Well in that case i go with Scotland as he is an All Australian player as well, played in 2 grand finals and finished 2nd in a BnF on 2 separate occasions.

Past records have stuff all to do with this poll mate.

 

[Fasta_123]

Davis, his past record is far superior

 

[BLUES9898]

Forgot to Make it clear but it's this year Only

 

[Vinnie Vegas]

Leon Davis is better defensively, quicker, and more capable of escaping traffic to get the ball going forward. Scotland relies more on being able to get loose - Despite what might appear to be similar roles, the two actually play very differently, with Leon's primary role not being the loose man, while Scotland's is, making his role almost more like Nick Maxwell's.

I also think Davis is a slightly better kick, but that's squibbling over a minor difference.

 

[JUBJUB]

I'll go with the dual All Australian, who has a premiership medallion.

Oh that bloke that has never and will never play in a winning GF.
Got dropped because he was shithouse under pressure.

 

[The Finger]

Oh that bloke that has never and will never play in a winning GF.
Got dropped because he was shithouse under pressure.

This. Theyve now given him a role to inflate his stats. Buckley no doubt will have Leon in his sights its no secret Buckley has no time for him.

 

[hellfire]

This. Theyve now given him a role to inflate his stats. Buckley no doubt will have Leon in his sights its no secret Buckley has no time for him.

Inflate his stats?

What role is that? Smash your opponent, and carve them up with your run, clean hands, and precision off half back?

Please, continue to inflate those stats, Leon.

 

[The Finger]

Has played on, and beaten an opponent virtually every week... Only a few sides have been dumb enough to allow someone with the footskills of Leon Davis to play loose, though that includes your mob (and I don't mean Melbourne).

Need to ge the distributers opinion on this. He claims players with good footskills are left free.

 

[ipswichpies]

On this years form hard to separate both have been good for their clubs,it did not take long for the finger to surface spewing his bile.

 

[jonesy86]

Mark Nicoski played well for WCE last night... that's the bloke that Leon played on last week, not only kept him out of the game but got a stack of the ball himself.

 

[the distributer]

Davis for mine, just beats opponants week in week out and his disposal is better than Scotlands, Davis more attacking, better defender and can play as a mid if needed as well, scotland has been very good this but Davis comfortably and i think most unbias posters would agree, and i said 'unbias posters' Finger.

 

[Slattery_20]

Davis.

Kinda funny they're both having their career best years at this sort of age, though.

 

[bradles7]

two completely diffrent player scotland-back davis-forward

 

[hazza1824]

Scotland more reliable