Matthew Lappin or Aussie Jones?

[LondonCalling]

Mmmhmmm

 

[X_box_X]

Very, very even. Aussie Jones has exceptional foot skills and generates a lot of run from the half back line. Lappin also generates run from the back line but also has the ability to kick a bag of goals. Lappin is also a tad more consistent.

Matty is Lappin it up for mine.

 

[weagles_fan]

Wirrpunda > Both of them.

 

[Funkalicous]

Jones has been better this season. However in Lappin's defence, I think he's been carrying an injury all season.

 

[stokesy]

Both are very handy players to have in the side.

However, I think Lappin has more levels in his game. As people have said above, he can dob a few goals, run from the backline and he can also play on the ball/wing/midfield areas.

I think Lappin also does the couregous things, like marks in the packs etc.

Lappin for me. But I would like Jones in the Carlton side as well!

 

[Outoftheblue]

Last year, definitely Lappin. This year, Jones.

 

[JeffDunne]

Last year, definitely Lappin. This year, Jones.

Both were outstanding last year and have been up and down this year.

Aussie hurts opposition teams more and would factor in their plans more than Lappin.

 

[Outoftheblue]

Aussie hurts opposition teams more and would factor in their plans more than Lappin.

Ask Essendon supporters about Lappin. Shutting down Lappin is important to stopping what little rebound is generated out of Carlton's back line.
Both Lappin and Jones can hurt the opposition; Lappin is more of a goalkicking threat. Lappin uses the ball well; Jones uses it superbly. Lappin is better at gathering the ball under pressure; which he is more often given the relative merits of the St Kilda and Carlton forward lines.
Lappin has been OK this year, but he was fantastic last year. Jones has been good the times I've seen him.

 

[cs61]

Wirrpunda > Both of them.

is he in the poll?

 

[coxon]

Ask Essendon supporters about Lappin. Shutting down Lappin is important to stopping what little rebound is generated out of Carlton's back line.

absolutely... tears us a new one almost everytime we play the scum...

hate the team, but have great admiration for m.lappin...

 

[tomaraya]

lappin by a big margin.
can play just as well and effective as jones in the back half and is more than capable in the front half.
would be seen as one of the premier goal sneaks in the league if he played the majority of his football in front of goals.