Matthew Scarlett or Chad Cornes?

[sam_the_king]

neither are the best defender in the league.

 

[Drummond]

Possibly the worst poll ever.

 

[grantyc77]

Scarlett, Cornes is used more as the loose man, one on one contests it would be Scarlett by the flemington straight.

 

[pafc4life]

lol people are hell funny. i agree scarlett is mot definetely an old fashioned full back, but unfortunately the guy isnt in the same league as Rutten, Glass, Michael etc.

Chad Cornes, however, is a champion that can thrive in any position on the ground. what a ridicolous poll

 

[tin can sam]

lol people are hell funny. i agree scarlett is mot definetely an old fashioned full back, but unfortunately the guy isnt in the same league as Rutten, Glass, Michael etc.

couldn't agree more, Scarlett is a league above all those players mentioned.

 

[Big Nasty]

lol people are hell funny. i agree scarlett is mot definetely an old fashioned full back, but unfortunately the guy isnt in the same league as Rutten, Glass, Michael etc.

Chad Cornes, however, is a champion that can thrive in any position on the ground. what a ridicolous poll

Man that is a seriously bad comment. If thats your opinion on Scarlett, you really know nothing about AFL.