MATTHEWS v CAREY V ABLETT

[ripitup27]

All brilliant. All great. Can't split them. Hence the 7 page arguments. We can never tell who is the greatest, its just too hard. I just wanna say I think arguments about premierships are mute because its disrespectful to the other 19, 20, 21 players, whatever, that played in those sides. Premierships are won by teams, not individuals. I mean, Abletts 9 goals in 1989 is just as good as any performance by Carey or Matthews in a Grand Final, even though they didn't win. Anyway, premierships are teams, not individuals, so should not be brought up in a individual player poll.

And all these players won games off their own boots, not just two, or one, so thats a ******** argument too.

All great players, can't split em.