News McGuane To Brisbane

[Mr Stokes]

I would be very surprised if we were offered anything at all for this spud.
His one great attribute is paddling the ball over the boundary line whether under pressure or not.
I'm sure there are a lot of other replacements we can try if that is the skill we need to replace. I would take anything for him.
Move along my good man!

 

[McGun]

Cam Mooney said on Trade Week Radio that he thinks McGuane to Lions will be a done deal by the end of the week he wants to go back home with his family, his brother and his wife just had there first child.

 

[Tiger888]

Mcguane definitely going to Brisbane - Cam Mooney is good mates with his brother said on draft radio

 

[Tiger888]

McGuane for Maric and and pick 37 down to 34 is a great get for Tigers

 

[Damo80]

McGuane for Maric and and pick 37 down to 34 is a great get for Tigers

Yep, I'd be most happy with that. Where's the 2nd rounder for McGuane come from? I reckon it's overs. Lions have traded for some spuds in recent years, but haven't generally paid overs. I reckon 3rd rounder more likely.

 

[Tiger888]

34 I think is Brisbanes 5th pick in the Draft

 

[Hollow Knight]

34 I think is Brisbanes 5th pick in the Draft

Fourth at the moment.

 

[tigs2010]

Fourth at the moment.

Will be 5th.

And for god's sake Tiger people we aren't going to get pick 34 guys so don't get your hopes up lol. If we get pick 52 we should be happy as that's a fair price.

 

[nugget_12]

Will be 5th.

And for god's sake Tiger people we aren't going to get pick 34 guys so don't get your hopes up lol. If we get pick 52 we should be happy as that's a fair price.

you need to realize that if pick 34 is the clubs 4th or 5th pick depending on what they get for clarke that they might not even use it! west coast 3yrs ago had their last pick at like 20 after having 5 picks in the top 20!

pick 34 is not out of the question by a long shot!
it just depends how deep they decide to draft, they have a priority pick at end of 1st round dont they plus they also cashed in a compo pick if i remember correctly! all picks before #34

 

[Barnzy]

I would much rather hold on to McGuane than accept a crappy draft pick from Brisbane.

I dont think he is in our Best 22. But big bodied defenders dont grow on trees. Imagine if what happened this year occurred again next year.

Since when has chicken legs McGuane been a "big bodied defender"?

Rance, Astbury and Post already monster him. He's about the same size as Grimes but Grimes is much bigger in the legs/thighs. Just sayin'.

 

[Ned_Flanders]

lets not get greedy - getting McGuane off our list is worth more than the difference between a kid at 34 and 74 IMO

 

[Punt_Road_Roar]

This is just turning into a massive **** tease started by the Herald Sun.

Brisbane have played it magnificently by not even talking to Richmond..... we will be accepting a half eaten jam sandwich by friday.


In all seriousness do you think Fremantle's reluctance getting the Clark deal done is stuffing up our chances to off load this dud???

 

[tigs2010]

you need to realize that if pick 34 is the clubs 4th or 5th pick depending on what they get for clarke that they might not even use it! west coast 3yrs ago had their last pick at like 20 after having 5 picks in the top 20!

pick 34 is not out of the question by a long shot!
it just depends how deep they decide to draft, they have a priority pick at end of 1st round dont they plus they also cashed in a compo pick if i remember correctly! all picks before #34

If they dont use 34 it would be the biggest waste of a compo pick ever. They will use 34 for certain. Not like they dont have players to upgrade on.

 

[McGun]

If they dont use 34 it would be the biggest waste of a compo pick ever. They will use 34 for certain. Not like they dont have players to upgrade on.

Its not a waste if they plan on trading it and at the start of the year (when they decided to use it) they didnt know they would have so many picks ahead of it.

 

[Damo80]

This is just turning into a massive **** tease started by the Herald Sun.

Brisbane have played it magnificently by not even talking to Richmond..... we will be accepting a half eaten jam sandwich by friday.


In all seriousness do you think Fremantle's reluctance getting the Clark deal done is stuffing up our chances to off load this dud???

Ok, how about Clark to Freo, Z Clarke to us, McGuane and pick 15 to Lions. Plus later pick/player shuffling to get things square?

Lyon has said Griffin is required, and with Sandi and Clark, you have to wonder how they can play them all!

 

[tigs2010]

Its not a waste if they plan on trading it and at the start of the year (when they decided to use it) they didnt know they would have so many picks ahead of it.

Must have over-rated themselves then.

 

[THE_GUN]

Just out of left field here but wouldnt it be funny if the following did occur

Brisbane Trade Mitch Clark +52 fremantles pick 16 & 38

That would give brisbane 6 picks inside top 40 ,

We then give brisbane picks 15 + Mguanne for picks 16+38

Effectively they get pick 15 + Mguanne for Clarke

 

[THE_GUN]

Ok, how about Clark to Freo, Z Clarke to us, McGuane and pick 15 to Lions. Plus later pick/player shuffling to get things square?

Lyon has said Griffin is required, and with Sandi and Clark, you have to wonder how they can play them all!

I would Love this Result , Means we dont need to get Maric.

Whilst we are dreaming, can we do Connors - Nicholls as well.

 

[McGun]

What about our 3rd round pick (#55?) and McGuane for #34.

 

[McGun]

McGuane "Not on Lions radar" - Lions List Manager, Trade Talk Radio.

 

[cotter101]

Our list manager has just said on TWR that McGuane is not on our radar...... YES!!!

 

[Punt_Road_Roar]

Our list manager has just said on TWR that McGuane is not on our radar...... YES!!!

Can we sue the Herald Sun for emotional distress?????

 

[folester41]

doesnt mean much for us, we get rid of mcguane for a low pick, or we keep mcguane and then eventually delist him.

 

[jihg]

Will be 5th.

And for god's sake Tiger people we aren't going to get pick 34 guys so don't get your hopes up lol. If we get pick 52 we should be happy as that's a fair price.

We are using the Adelaide model of over the top silly demands and expectations.

 

[JAKLAUGHING]

This is just turning into a massive **** tease started by the Herald Sun.

Brisbane have played it magnificently by not even talking to Richmond..... we will be accepting a half eaten jam sandwich by friday.


HAHAHAHA... ....