Mcleod V Wanganeen

[Lightning_Rod]

Just been listening to the local crow show, and they had a good question, who is the better player/or who wouldyou prefer. with my bias of course i would take gavin a million times over, but i would love to see wat the pubplic think.

 

[shaz63]

Not being biased..........but I would chose Wanga's over McLeod anytime.

 

[ICanDressMyself]

One's retired and one's not. I know who I'd take.

And it's not w ankerknees.

 

[Troy Wingate]

Gavin is 10 times the player McLeod is.

 

[SWANNIES RULE]

Mcleod is overrated. Wanganeen was hands down a better player.

 

[Groove]

wangas easy

 

[King Elvis]

Both Guns - enough said.

I remember a story I heard from Sheedy about Wanga's Brownlow year - how Sheedy didn't know what to do with him so stuck him in a back pocket, Wanganeed told him he had no idea how to play that position, and won the Brownlow there.

is that right?

 

[Sims01]

Wangas for me.

 

[crazy_big_al]

wangas easy

 

[Scruba]

wanga

 

[KUNG FU]

The current result genuinely surprises me.

 

[WhyAlwaysMe]

Both Port Adelaide boys but have to go Wanganeen.

 

[Gets!]

McLeod by the length of Bass Strait.

To say that Wanganeen was in the same category of Macca is a disgrace.

 

[darrend05]

McLeod by the length of Bass Strait.

To say that Wanganeen was in the same category of Macca is a disgrace.

dont know much about football do you.......

 

[ICanDressMyself]

McLeod is a lot better.

Doesn't have to dive for his freekicks either..

 

[Total Power]

One's retired and one's not. I know who I'd take.

And it's not w ankerknees.

didnt you tell me a while ago you respect every player who has played 250+ games?? thats happened when i dissed Roo and you dissed Tredders. Or maybe this is how you show respect.Hypocrite

 

[Dj Chriss]

Mcleod hes a superstar and the things he does with the football is brilliant

 

[The Joker]

Other than the two of them being Aboriginals what else do they have in common as Football Players

Midfielder i would take McLeod
Back pocket i would take Wanganeen

 

[Coin_Toss]

Waganeen, in my opinion, but it's very close.

Good poll.

 

[blaisee]

I would much rather watch mcleod play.

Wanganeens style was a disgrace, he played for free kicks every time he got near the ball.

MAcleod has 2 norm smiths

I would much prefer mceod at his peak over wanganeen

 

[DapperDon]

MAcleod has 2 norm smiths

I would much prefer mceod at his peak over wanganeen

and Wanganeen has a Brownlow, what's your point?
have a look back in his early days for Essendon and see what a freak Wangas was.

Both superstars, but I'd have to take Wanganeen overall.

It's been 10years since he left Essendon and it still hurts.

 

[ICanDressMyself]

didnt you tell me a while ago you respect every player who has played 250+ games?? thats happened when i dissed Roo and you dissed Tredders. Or maybe this is how you show respect.Hypocrite

Where in that sentence did I say I didn't respect Gavin?

He just has weak knees and falls over a lot. Good footballer but ruined his game with diving.

 

[Total Power]

Where in that sentence did I say I didn't respect Gavin?

He just has weak knees and falls over a lot. Good footballer but ruined his game with diving.

W ankerknees is not an insult??

 

[ICanDressMyself]

W ankerknees is not an insult??

Yeah it is, but since when does that mean I don't respect him?

Are you saying you've never insulted Roo or Hart or Smart or Bicks? Bulltish!

As I said, great player, but unfortunately his game got brought down by his constant acting.

 

[Total Power]

Yeah it is, but since when does that mean I don't respect him?

Are you saying you've never insulted Roo or Hart or Smart or Bicks? Bulltish!

As I said, great player, but unfortunately his game got brought down by his constant acting.

So you could have called him a diver or whatever. W@nker is still a pretty poor insult for such a legend like Wangas.I did insult Roo, but its YOUR PHILOSOPHY, not to insult a legend...isnt it??