Mid Year Survey

[In And Under Tiger]

Got this off one of the other boards. Thought it would be good to do.

Our best win:
Our worst loss:
The single most exciting moment of the season so far:
The single worst moment of the season so far:
We can't do without:
Could do more:
Mr Consistent:
Can’t cement a spot:
The player who I'm always ready to forgive for a mistake:
The player who I'm always ready to knock for a mistake:
Who do we want: ?
The opposition player I'd pay money to see:
The opposition player I’d pay money to see decked:

The Game In General
Worst rule / or interpreted rule:
Best commentator:
Worst commentator:
Worst Umpiring performance:

Crystal Ball
Before the season, I thought we'd finish:
As of now, I reckon we'll end up: .
Club Champion:
Grandfinalists:
Premiers:
Bronwlow Medalist:
Coleman:

Mine:

Our best win: Hmmm, Richmond
Our worst loss: Collingwood
The single most exciting moment of the season so far: Jimmy Stynes grab behind the goals.
The single worst moment of the season so far:
We can't do without: Sylvia
Could do more: Bruce
Mr Consistent: Davey
Can’t cement a spot: Petterd
The player who I'm always ready to forgive for a mistake: Sylvia
The player who I'm always ready to knock for a mistake: Robbo
Who do we want: ? Scully
The opposition player I'd pay money to see: Cyril Rioli
The opposition player I’d pay money to see decked: John Anthony

The Game In General
Worst rule / or interpreted rule: In the back when someone drops to their knees in a tackle.
Best commentator: Brian Taylor
Worst commentator: Quartermain loves the dick
Worst Umpiring performance: ???

Crystal Ball
Before the season, I thought we'd finish: Second Last
As of now, I reckon we'll end up: Last
Club Champion: Aaron Davey
Grandfinalists: Hawthorn
Premiers: Geelong
Bronwlow Medalist: Montagna
Coleman: Buddy

 

[saj_21]

Our best win: Richmond, however i rekon we've played better and lost games.
Our worst loss: Collingwood round 11
The single most exciting moment of the season so far: A passage of play in the 2nd aurater against the dogs, deep in our backline and under pressure there were numerours handballs between our youngsters who all remained compsed. We worked the ball up the ground and scored goal it was a glimpse of what we can do.
The single worst moment of the season so far: time on in the first 1/4 quarter against collingwood (rd11) long kick into their forward line and watching brad dick swoop on a loose ball and watch him kick the pies 7th unanswered goal for the quarter.
We can't do without: Davey...one of the best kicks in the AFL
Could do more: Newton, we've been screaming out for another KPF and he hasn't answered our calls, his good games correlate to his defensive pressure.
Mr Consistent: Davey
Can’t cement a spot: Dunn in and out of the side needs to hold down a position.
The player who I'm always ready to forgive for a mistake: Mclean
The player who I'm always ready to knock for a mistake: Bartram
Who do we want: Scully
The opposition player I'd pay money to see: G. Ablett
The opposition player I’d pay money to see decked: John "the forehead" Anothony.

The Game In General
Worst rule / or interpreted rule: Hands in the back way to inconsistent
Best commentator: Gerard Healy
Worst commentator: Dwayne Russell
Worst Umpiring performance: Been good this year but i hate Scott Mclaren

Crystal Ball
Before the season, I thought we'd finish: 14th
As of now, I reckon we'll end up: 16th
Club Champion: Davey (Sylvia is closing)
Grandfinalists: Geelong and St. Kilda
Premiers: Geelong
Bronwlow Medalist: Stevie J

 

[Davide_117]

Our best win: Richmond
Our worst loss: Collingwood
The single most exciting moment of the season so far: Sylvia kicking 3 in a row against the hawks.
The single worst moment of the season so far: Listening to Finey's final siren after pies game
We can't do without: Sylvia..out of him and davey for B&F
Could do more: Cam Bruce makes very bad decisions for one of our most experienced players.
Mr Consistent: Davey..look at first 2 months for Davey to get votes in brownlow
Can’t cement a spot: Cheney..even when he plays well he gets dropped.
The player who I'm always ready to forgive for a mistake: Sylvia
The player who I'm always ready to knock for a mistake: Bruce
Who do we want: Picks 1 & 2
The opposition player I'd pay money to see: G. Ablett
The opposition player I’d pay money to see decked: Travis Cloke, I remember sitting in cheersquad in round2 when he layed into Cheney for turn over in the kick in.

The Game In General
Worst rule / or interpreted rule: Hands in the back...too much interpretation.
Best commentator: Brian Taylor
Worst commentator: Robert Walls
Worst Umpiring performance: When dogs got a free against us which sealed their win when no melbourne player touched the dogs player. Then got given 50 as 2 melbourne players were running down wing into open goal. KILLED US IN THAT GAME>

Crystal Ball
Before the season, I thought we'd finish: 15th
As of now, I reckon we'll end up: 16th
Club Champion: Davey..just over Sylvia
Grandfinalists: Geelong and St. Kilda
Premiers: Geelong
Bronwlow Medalist: Dal Santo
Most Improved Player on our list: Frawley.
Players want back in team who are injured: Wonna and Garland
Player to play next week: Jurrah

 

[Dez!]

Our best win: Richmond
Our worst loss: Collingwood Queen's Birthday
The single most exciting moment of the season so far: I agree with the passage of play against the Dogs, was absolutely awesome just a pity we f***ed up the shot at goal if I remember correctly but still was bloody exciting.
The single worst moment of the season so far: Getting bent over by Collingwood.
We can't do without: Davey
Could do more: PJ, when did you become an idiot?
Mr Consistent: Davey
Can’t cement a spot: Dunn, Petterd and Bartram.
The player who I'm always ready to forgive for a mistake: Brock McLean because the man always makes up for it not long after.
The player who I'm always ready to knock for a mistake: Paul Johnson
Who do we want: Tom Scully
The opposition player I'd pay money to see: Gary Ablett
The opposition player I’d pay money to see decked: Mitch Robinson, Chris Judd and Sam Mitchell.

The Game In General
Worst rule / or interpreted rule: Hands in the back or the holding the ball rule.
Best commentator: BT or Brayshaw
Worst commentator: Dwayne Russell
Worst Umpiring performance:Scott Mclaren

Crystal Ball
Before the season, I thought we'd finish: 14th
As of now, I reckon we'll end up: 16th
Club Champion: Colin Sylvia if he keeps up the form he's got going.
Grandfinalists: Saints vs Geelong
Premiers: St Kilda
Bronwlow Medalist: Leigh Montagna

 

[whelan=legend]

Our best win: Richmond.. Who else?
Our worst loss: QB vs Collingwood
The single most exciting moment of the season so far: Jack Watts running onto the 'G
The single worst moment of the season so far: First quarter against collingwood
We can't do without: SYLVIA
Could do more: Weights
Mr Consistent: Davey
Can’t cement a spot: Ricky
The player who I'm always ready to forgive for a mistake: Sylvia, any young player
The player who I'm always ready to knock for a mistake: Bruce, McDonald
Who do we want: Scully & Butcher
The opposition player I'd pay money to see: SJ
The opposition player I’d pay money to see decked: Scott Thompson / Chris Johnson

The Game In General
Worst rule / or interpreted rule: Push in the back... players always drop their knees and force the person tackling into their back
Best commentator: Buckley
Worst commentator: Dwayyyneeeee
Worst Umpiring performance: vs St Kilda

Crystal Ball
Before the season, I thought we'd finish: Last
As of now, I reckon we'll end up: Last
Club Champion: Sylvia
Grandfinalists: Geelong and Saints
Premiers: Geelong
Bronwlow Medalist: Stevie Johnson
Coleman: Buddy

 

[mfc150]

Our best win: picks 1 and 2
Our worst loss: Collingwood
The single most exciting moment of the season so far:
The single worst moment of the season so far: 1st quarter siren QB
We can't do without: Aaron Davey
Could do more: Brock
Mr Consistent: GRIMESY !
Can’t cement a spot: Ricky P
The player who I'm always ready to forgive for a mistake: Rivers
The player who I'm always ready to knock for a mistake: Bartram
Who do we want: ? Midfielders.....Scully
The opposition player I'd pay money to see: GAJ
The opposition player I’d pay money to see decked: Fevola

The Game In General
Worst rule / or interpreted rule: Hands in back
Best commentator: Commeti
Worst commentator: Shwarz
Worst Umpiring performance: Hawks game

Crystal Ball
Before the season, I thought we'd finish: 16th
As of now, I reckon we'll end up: 16h
Club Champion: Davey
Grandfinalists: Geelong v Collingwood
Premiers: Geelong
Bronwlow Medalist: GAJ
Coleman: Franklin

 

[RandB]

Our best win: Richmond
Our worst loss: Pies round 11
The single most exciting moment of the season so far: Rivers walking off the ground on his own two feet.
The single worst moment of the season so far: Garland and Wona getting injured in pre-season and our first quarter against the filth round 11.
We can't do without: Money, so donate to this years DebtDemolition!!!
Could do more: Probably harsh but Mahoney could work on some semblance of a forward structure.
Mr Consistent: Not necessarily elite but I have to admit Moloney has been reasonably consistent.
Can’t cement a spot: Petterd
The player who I'm always ready to forgive for a mistake: Jamar
The player who I'm always ready to knock for a mistake: PJ
Who do we want: ? Scully and Pick 2 whoever that may be (I guess)
The opposition player I'd pay money to see: Ablett
The opposition player I’d pay money to see decked: Barry Hall because it would take one ****en great hit!

The Game In General Fast, for ever changing based on the weekly umpires meeting
Worst rule / or interpreted rule: Prior opportunity, too often a player is pinged with no hope of getting rid of the ball.
Best commentator: Matty Campbell
Worst commentator: Dwayne Russell/Nathan Buckley
Worst Umpiring performance: 1997 Melbourne v Dogs we killed them all day and the umps ****ing killed us and we lost by 2 points. The commentators at the end of the game were so gobsmacked they didn't know what to say.

Crystal Ball Saints to pay for their lack of player game rotations throughout the season.
Before the season, I thought we'd finish: Around 12th or 13th
As of now, I reckon we'll end up: Last
Club Champion: Davey
Grandfinalists: Saints and Cats
Premiers: After last year only god knows.
Bronwlow Medalist: Adam Goodes (having a great year and nobody to take votes off him)
Coleman: Buddy I guess

 

[kv_baby]

Our best win: Geelong (round 16)
Our worst loss: Pies Round 11
The single most exciting moment of the season so far: Frawleys goal against the saints
The single worst moment of the season so far: Everything Newton has done (or hasn't done)
We can't do without: AARON DAVEY, AARON FUC-KEN DAVEY
Could do more: Robbo
Mr Consistent: Davey/Sylvia
Can’t cement a spot: Pj
The player who I'm always ready to forgive for a mistake: Jones
The player who I'm always ready to knock for a mistake: PJ
Who do we want: ? No one
The opposition player I'd pay money to see: Junior
The opposition player I’d pay money to see decked: Buddy

The Game In General Not bad, terrible umpiring
Worst rule / or interpreted rule: theres Rules this season?
Best commentator: Walls
Worst commentator: Dwayne Russell
Worst Umpiring performance: Every game this season

Crystal Ball We will make finals
Before the season, I thought we'd finish: 10th
Club Champion: Davey
Grandfinalists: Cats v Dogs
Premiers: Dogs
Bronwlow Medalist: Pendlebury
Coleman: Stevie J

 

[RPetterd15]

Our best win: Richmond
Our worst loss: Collingwood (Queen's Birthday)
The single most exciting moment of the season so far: Syliva's game against Hawthorn and his long bomb goals that I never new he could kick.
The single worst moment of the season so far: PJ turning the ball over twice when trying to give it off to Davey, which resulted in 2 goals to pies in Queen's Birthday
We can't do without: Aaron Davey
Could do more: Robbo
Mr Consistent: Jack Grimes(Surprising)
Can’t cement a spot: Poor Ricky 'Bobby' Petterd
The player who I'm always ready to forgive for a mistake: Grimesy, Ricky P
The player who I'm always ready to knock for a mistake: Newton/PJ
Who do we want: Scully
The opposition player I'd pay money to see: Paddy Ryder
The opposition player I’d pay money to see decked: Mitch Robinson

The Game In General
Worst rule / or interpreted rule: Rush Behind Rule
Best commentator: Brian Taylor
Worst commentator: Dwayne Russell
Worst Umpiring performance: Most

Crystal Ball
Before the season, I thought we'd finish: 15th
As of now, I reckon we'll end up: 16th
Club Champion: Aaron Davey or Colin Sylvia
Grandfinalists: Geelong vs St Kilda
Premiers: Geelong
Bronwlow Medalist: Brendon Goddard
Coleman: Stevie J

 

[cannons]

Our best win: Too many to choose from
Our worst loss: The most recent loss to Collingwood
The single most exciting moment of the season so far: Colin Sylvia's performance v. Hawthorn
The single worst moment of the season so far: Hearing about Garland's injury
We can't do without: Sylvia
Could do more: Bate
Mr Consistent: Davey
Can’t cement a spot: Petterd, Dunn, Bartram and Cheney
The player who I'm always ready to forgive for a mistake: Sylvia, this has been the case ever since he was drafter
The player who I'm always ready to knock for a mistake: Robertson
Who do we want: ? Scully, Pavlich would be nice too
The opposition player I'd pay money to see: Richo, Leon Davis
The opposition player I’d pay money to see decked: Split decision between Thomas, Cloke and Anthony

The Game In General
Worst rule / or interpreted rule: Holding the ball, this has degenerated into a farce recently
Best commentator: Bruce for that 'Delicious' comment, in actuality it's probably BT
Worst commentator: I can't name one, I don't have too many issues with the commentary
Worst Umpiring performance: I can't single an umpire out, just particular instances

Crystal Ball
Before the season, I thought we'd finish: 16th
As of now, I reckon we'll end up: 16th
Club Champion: Sylvia
Grandfinalists: Irrelevant
Premiers: Also irrelevant
Bronwlow Medalist: Sylvia
Coleman: Liam Jurrah

 

[BleasePlease]

Our best win: richmond
Our worst loss: collingwood rd 11
The single most exciting moment of the season so far: our new gameplan, and our attack on the pill. signs are good for the future.. jack grimes, addam maric, cale morton, jack watts, jamie bennell etc, etc...
The single worst moment of the season so far: collingwood game was horrific
We can't do without: matty warnock
Could do more: jimmy mc - the skipper
Mr Consistent: newton (consistently bad at afl level)
Can’t cement a spot: petterd, martin
The player who I'm always ready to forgive for a mistake: cale morton
The player who I'm always ready to knock for a mistake: paul johnson
Who do we want: ? scully
The opposition player I'd pay money to see: NicNat
The opposition player I’d pay money to see decked: cam mooney = twat

The Game In General
Worst rule / or interpreted rule: hands in back
Best commentator: big brian
Worst commentator: dwayne russel
Worst Umpiring performance: cant recall

Crystal Ball
Before the season, I thought we'd finish: 16th
As of now, I reckon we'll end up: . 16th
Club Champion: col sylvia
Grandfinalists: saint vs cats
Premiers: saints
Bronwlow Medalist: adam goodes
Coleman: brendan fevola

 

[TelkoTheGreat]

Our best win: you know the one
Our worst loss: QB Massacre
The single most exciting moment of the season so far: Sylvias 2nd Q goals vs Rich, RD 4
The single worst moment of the season so far: QB
We can't do without: Frawley
Could do more: Bruce/Bate
Mr Consistent: Jack Grimes
Can’t cement a spot: Dunn
The player who I'm always ready to forgive for a mistake: Jetta
The player who I'm always ready to knock for a mistake: Bruce
Who do we want: ? Sculls
The opposition player I'd pay money to see: Sam Wright
The opposition player I’d pay money to see decked: Judd


The Game In General
Worst rule / or interpreted rule: holding the ball as of late.
Best commentator: none really
Worst commentator: dwayne the payne russell
Worst Umpiring performance: too many to call

Crystal Ball
Before the season, I thought we'd finish: John Butcher
As of now, I reckon we'll end up: Tom Scully & John Butcher
Club Champion: Colin Sylvia
Grandfinalists: cats n saints
Premiers: saints
Bronwlow Medalist: Ablett
Coleman: Fevola

 

[Dez!]

Telko?

You thought we'd finish John Butcher? I see.

 

[chopper41]

Our best win: Well, yeah.......but pro tankers might give an interesting answer.
Our worst loss: Collingwood
The single most exciting moment of the season so far: Jack Watts free kick. One of the most unique moments i've experienced at the footy.
The single worst moment of the season so far: Most of it.
We can't do without: Davey
Could do more: Bruce
Mr Consistent: Davey
Can’t cement a spot: Jetta
The player who I'm always ready to forgive for a mistake: Davey
The player who I'm always ready to knock for a mistake: Newton
Who do we want: ? Scully and Butcher
The opposition player I'd pay money to see: Ablett
The opposition player I’d pay money to see decked: Lance Franklin

The Game In General
Worst rule / or interpreted rule: Hands in the back
Best commentator: Brian Taylor
Worst commentator: Bruce MacAvaney
Worst Umpiring performance: -

Crystal Ball
Before the season, I thought we'd finish: Last
As of now, I reckon we'll end up: Last
Club Champion: Davey
Grandfinalists: St.Kilda
Premiers: Geelong
Bronwlow Medalist: Gary Ablett jnr (has to happen eventually)
Coleman: Fevola

 

[Wonaeamirri33]

Our best win: Obvious
Our worst loss: Also obvious
The single most exciting moment of the season so far: Second quarter against Richmond
The single worst moment of the season so far: First quarter against Collingwood
We can't do without: Aaron Davey, Sylvia, Jamar, Frawley, Jones, Brock, Moloney
Could do more: Bruce, Bate, JMac, Robbo, Bell, Miller, Newton, Petterd, Warnock
Mr Consistent: Davey
Can’t cement a spot: Dunn
The player who I'm always ready to forgive for a mistake: Wonaeamirri
The player who I'm always ready to knock for a mistake: Newton
Who do we want: Butcher & Scully
The opposition player I'd pay money to see: Ablett
The opposition player I’d pay money to see decked: Barry Hall- followed closely by Franklin...

The Game In General
Worst rule / or interpreted rule: Holding the ball
Best commentator: Cometti
Worst commentator: Walls
Worst Umpiring performance: Definitely been a few...

Crystal Ball
Before the season, I thought we'd finish: 12th
As of now, I reckon we'll end up: 16th
Club Champion: Sylvia/Davey
Grandfinalists: Bulldogs
Premiers: Geelong
Brownlow Medalist: Gary Ablett jnr
Coleman: Stevie J

 

[TelkoTheGreat]

Telko?

You thought we'd finish John Butcher? I see.

In other words I thought maybe 15th at least and get one of them but now I think we will land both..

 

[TelkoTheGreat]

The single most exciting moment of the season so far: Second quarter against Richmond

Best quarter ever.

 

[Brock 'n' Roll]

Our best win: Richmond
Our worst loss: Collingwood
The single most exciting moment of the season so far: 2nd Quarter v Richmond
The single worst moment of the season so far: Robbo in the Hawks match!
We can't do without: Davey
Could do more: Brocky
Mr Consistent: Davey
Can’t cement a spot: Ricky/Lynden
The player who I'm always ready to forgive for a mistake: PJ
The player who I'm always ready to knock for a mistake: Jamar
Who do we want: ? Pick 1 & 2
The opposition player I'd pay money to see: Stevie J/D Moplop
The opposition player I’d pay money to see decked: Travis Cloke/Fev

The Game In General
Worst rule / or interpreted rule: hands in the back
Best commentator: Rex Hunt (Still)
Worst commentator: Dwayne Russell
Worst Umpiring performance: Cant name just ONE!

Crystal Ball
Before the season, I thought we'd finish: Last
As of now, I reckon we'll end up: Last
Club Champion: Aaron Davey
Grandfinalists: Bulldogs
Premiers: Geelong
Bronwlow Medalist: Adam Goodes
Coleman: Fev

 

[Capt_Concussion]

Our best win: Richmond
Our worst loss: Collingwood
The single most exciting moment of the season so far: Cheney's debut, calm, composed...got dropped
The single worst moment of the season so far: Robbo's effort in the goal square, we all know what I mean.
We can't do without: A lead up forward (not saying we can't do without Miller)
Could do more: Bate
Mr Consistent: Davey
Can’t cement a spot: Dunn
The player who I'm always ready to forgive for a mistake: Davey
The player who I'm always ready to knock for a mistake: Robbo
Who do we want: ? Some freak who can play KPF, Ruck and somehow be an awesome speedy, skillful midfielder, all in one.
The opposition player I'd pay money to see: Hayes
The opposition player I’d pay money to see decked: Milne

The Game In General
Worst rule / or interpreted rule: Hands in the back, the whole concept of the rule is rediculous, we already have push in the back.
Best commentator: Quarters
Worst commentator: Walls
Worst Umpiring performance: ?

Crystal Ball
Before the season, I thought we'd finish: Last
As of now, I reckon we'll end up: Last
Club Champion: Davey
Grandfinalists: Geelong, St Kilda
Premiers: Geelong
Bronwlow Medalist: Montagna
Coleman: Buddy

 

[bloodpumpsRnB]

Our best win:
Our worst loss: Collingwood
The single most exciting moment of the season so far: The Walk to the G'
The single worst moment of the season so far: The first 10 minutes of QB
We can't do without: Aaron Davey
Could do more: Matthew Bate
Mr Consistent: Hopefully Sylvia
Can’t cement a spot: Lynden Dunn
The player who I'm always ready to forgive for a mistake: Jack Watts
The player who I'm always ready to knock for a mistake: Nathan Jones
Who do we want: Judd
The opposition player I'd pay money to see: Judd
The opposition player I’d pay money to see decked: Fevola

The Game In General
Worst rule / or interpreted rule: Hands in the back/side
Best commentator: Brian Taylor
Worst commentator: Andrew Maher
Worst Umpiring performance: Last week. And the week before. And the week before.

Crystal Ball
Before the season, I thought we'd finish: 16th
As of now, I reckon we'll end up: 16th
Club Champion: Colin Sylvia.
Grandfinalists: I'll be unique and go Geelong and St Kilda.
Premiers: Geelong
Bronwlow Medalist: Adam Goodes
Coleman: Fevola