Opinion Most overrated player on our list?

[theflea]

No player is perfect though, which is my main point. Picking out a player because they make mistakes doesn't mean they're overrated.

I also think you need to consider fanboyism that certain players hold, for example no one seriously thinks McBean is the best player in the world and we all know how scrawny he is, but we like to talk him up because it's fun.

I'm just saying think about the meaning of overrated, tis all.

Completely agree. Overrating = better than they actually are, but this doesn't mean their shite either.

 

[rammbo]

Ok after reading the knights thread ill have to add him in a three way tie with astbury and houlie.

 

[jko'neal]

This is like shooting Bambi But Foley IMO, get the feeling people are expecting the Foley before the injuries, not gonna happen and IMO he's going to struggle to get into the side over the next two years.

And Griffiths, hope he proves me wrong but I hoping Santa drops off a pair of "Balls" in his Christmas stocking.

 

[Nostradumbass]

Kanye Pettifer.

 

[nobulltiger]

All I want for Footy Christmas is for Cotchin to have a disposal efficiency above 75%