Most Underated and overated player in the AFL

[Richmond_12]

who do u think is the most underated player in the AFL?

 

[jules101]

Underrated: Tyson edwards
Overrated: Fevola or Richardson prob Fevola

 

[Legendary Soundpost]

Underrated: Tyson edwards
Overrated: Fevola or Richardson prob Fevola

Not bad call. In My opinion :

Underrated - T.Edwards & J.Corey
Overrated - Fevola, Fevola, Fevola & Fevola closely followed by D.Neitz

 

[Talented Player]

Underrated - Mark Johnson & Dylan McLearn - He steps up when the rest of the Lion ruckmans are injury.

Overrated - I'm with jules101 (Fevola & Richardson)

 

[melbournemartin]

underrated - Tyson Edwards, Nathan Carroll (in his last month of the year)

overrated - Riewoldt, C.Cornes, Ling

 

[macca69]

dunno about the AFL but for West Coast

Underated - Glass
Overated - Fletcher

 

[Gold Coast Crow]

Tyson Edwards is definately under rated. I thought saying Chad Cornes was a bit harsh.

As for over rated, I think Pickett, The Powder Puffs will be glad to see the back of him after this year.

 

[ablettjnr]

Not bad call. In My opinion :

Underrated - T.Edwards & J.Corey

I hear that.

 

[hulld]

adam yze definitely the most overated in the league. he is so soft.

Craig Bolton is easily the most underated in the AFL. He is never beaten. He towelled up Riewoldt and Chick in the finals

 

[raman]

Underrated: Tyson Edwards

Overrated: Scott Bloody Thompson

 

[FFC + BBFC = BBFFC]

sorry, worng thread

 

[BMW22]

Overated : TREDREA (he is poo,doesnt stand up wen he has 2)

Underated: Brent Moloney

 

[jeffs_girl]

Underrated Troy Cook

Overrated Brendan Fevola

 

[Rhys87]

Overated - Phillip Matera

 

[Fletch - Tas]

For hawks

Overrated - Crawford (last season only)
Underrated - Bateman

 

[bomberbluey]

Dunno about the AFL, but in this trade week:

Overrated- Jon Hay (he is no way even close to being worth one 1st rounder, let alone two)

Underrated- Daniel Motlop (He's a special type, a real matchwinner and defs worth more than Hay and is younger than Hay)

OK, i'll have a go at the AFL:

Overrated- Peter Bell (a good tryer, nothing more), Brett Deledio (He's gonna be a gun but Griffen was the standout for Rising Star IMO)
Underrated- Corey Jones, Steven Baker

 

[prynny_22]

dunno about the AFL but for West Coast

Underated - Glass
Overated - Fletcher

I was gonna say fletcher the underated

 

[damoc_85]

Underrated - Michael Braun

Overrated - Josh Fraser

 

[Flukey!]

Underated - Bolton ( Swans )
Overated - Deledio - one season does not maketh a career

 

[Mike_Spicoli]

Overated : Chad Cornes - Is good at racking up 30 possies on the half back line without an opponent but with a man he struggles. And Wells is at this stage.

Underated: Daniel Harris

 

[Fletch - Tas]

Judd would be my overall overrated actually. As good as he is, he is still not as good as everyone says.

 

[Nbrown7]

Underated - Bolton ( Swans )
Overated - Deledio - one season does not maketh a career

point? He's only played one year and been better than alot of already established afl players. Jeouleousy board

 

[saladin]

over-rated: after todays events, ted richards!

under-rated: amon buchannon

 

[Beamdogg]

Overated : TREDREA (he is poo,doesnt stand up wen he has 2)

Underated: Brent Moloney

I totally agreee with you there BMW22 Brent Moloney is one of the most talented players in the AFL and toughest

 

[super4]

Overated : TREDREA (he is poo,doesnt stand up wen he has 2)

Underated: Brent Moloney

So because he is a permiership captain he has to be overated. And because he has been best CHF for the past 3 years means he must be overated as well! Get over it!