Player Watch Nathan Freeman

[76woodenspooners]

How about we keep Freeman and forget about Aish?
According to these figures Aish has the worst kicking efficiency in the competition in his position.
I got this table from the AFL web site.
Everyone is saying that Aish is silk.
This does not suggest that.
What am I missing????



View attachment 175340

LOL at Cameron Wood

 

[abs_of_STEELE]

Really disappointing to see this happen. Although I understand it more if he thinks this will probably be his last AFL contract, so better cash in now.

 

[TradeDraft]

Seriously, we have to play hardball here, St Kilda are the ones offering him stupid money.

If they want him they need to find us a first round pick or we let him go for nothing (probably to Carlton where he will definitely break down again).

We won't get Pick 5. His Value has not gone up. Rather take a 2nd Rounder then Nothing.

I say good chance the Saints could be the 3rd team in the Treloar Trade

 

[PieBeast]

Oh and welcome to Collingwood James Aish.

 

[burningdwarf]

Good to see you guys are taking the news well. You definitely didn't offer Wellingham and pick 30 for Ball either. I think with Seedsman gone, Shenton will be a real quality pick up for you guys!!

 

[Soaring Magpie]

If he wants to chase the money, good luck to him.
I'll be laughing at the saints when he pulls up short in round 1 clutching at his hamstring

 

[Ketchup]

St Kilda *******s already posting shit about 3rd rounder or we'll get him in psd on the trade and draft board...

Strange. I don't remember being banned from that thread. Turns out I am but.

Probably a good thing considering how moronic St Kilda fans are

 

[Lefthanded]

Seriously, we have to play hardball here, St Kilda are the ones offering him stupid money.

If they want him they need to find us a first round pick or we let him go for nothing (probably to Carlton where he will definitely break down again).

Worst case, if we can use the late picks as points for sweeteners for Treloar+ in trade with GWS or Aish with Lions than before FA compo Saints round 2 + round 3 total 1227 points which equates to just better than pick 13. I know GWS have 2 academy boys this year. Not sure about Lions.

 

[Ketchup]

Good to see you guys are taking the news well. You definitely didn't offer Wellingham and pick 30 for Ball either. I think with Seedsman gone, Shenton will be a real quality pick up for you guys!!

I can't even troll this guy. His name trolls his own club. I like him. All he needed to do was add non consensual sex in it and he'd be the ultimate.

 

[danielnajdek]

Good to see you guys are taking the news well. You definitely didn't offer Wellingham and pick 30 for Ball either. I think with Seedsman gone, Shenton will be a real quality pick up for you guys!!

Did you think we'd be jumping for joy?

 

[Apex36]

Oh and welcome to Collingwood James Aish.

I hope you're right. I have an awful feeling that he's holding off on asking for a trade because he's Hawthorn bound.

 

[Unknown Identity]

Poke fun at other boards meltdowns over players either leaving or not picking them, Freeman requests trade and everyone loses their mind.

Chill the **** out!

 

[Cousin of Daicos]

Oh and welcome to Collingwood James Aish.

Wait what?

 

[Baird]

They traded first round picks for Hickey and Tom Lee too fwiw.

 

[MagpieJoel]

Freeman has requested a trade to St Kilda

Flog of the highest order.

 

[hellfire]

We offered pick 30 and Wellingham for him. Hardly unreasonable. Not our fault Ross Lyon is a dickhead. That trade could well have won them the grand final in 2010 if they'd accepted it.

Instead....

"Wellingham ROVVVESSS IT.........."

 

[PicaBoo]

So it finally happened. So what. Haven't seen much of him, can't be fussed. He would have been in the VFL predominantly anyway until he gets fitness. We win some, we lose some. As long as overall quality coming in exceeds quality going out. GL to him.

 

[BoxMatrix]

Poke fun at other boards meltdowns over players either leaving or not picking them, Freeman requests trade and everyone loses their mind.

Chill the **** out!

This is not a meltdown. Remember last year when Beams requested a trade? That was a meltdown.

 

[Mick39]

I don't have an issue of him wanting out. He has a poor character and I highlighted this to many but was criticised.

My main beef is why we recruit so many players with questionable character traits.

 

[Stoods]

Lost so much respect for Freeman, i really have..

Looks like a need a new avatar lol

 

[TradeDraft]

Oh and welcome to Collingwood James Aish.

Source on Aish?

 

[Mr Bombastic]

Can anyone else see the irony of us stressing all year that scharenberg was leaving for it to end up being freeman?

 

[Linda Lovelace]

I think Carlton and Essendon having picks before Saints will stop them from going through with a PSD threat.

Bombers need pace and would possibly take a punt on a top 10 pick considering they have been stripped of draft picks in recent years, and unless Carlton need their pick, why the heck wouldn't they take a punt?

 

[Apex36]

So it finally happened. So what. Haven't seen much of him, can't be fussed. He would have been in the VFL predominantly anyway until he gets fitness. We win some, we lose some. As long as overall quality coming in exceeds quality going out. GL to him.

Fitness? He was easily one of the fittest blokes on our list. Fitness was never going to be an issue with him.

 

[PieBeast]

I hope you're right. I have an awful feeling that he's holding off on asking for a trade because he's Hawthorn bound.

Oh he's holding off cause we've asked him too due to the minor shit storm Treloar's announcement created.

Wait what?

Freeman was adamant Aish is Pies bound and sighted this as one of the reasons why he could be leaving.