didaksrightfoot
Premiership Player
- Sep 12, 2013
- 4,902
- 5,555
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
- Other Teams
- SA Spurs, Juventus
Ned Guy and his team deserve massive kudos for their work in retaining our best players on significantly less coin than they could be making elsewhere.
He took over from the fiasco that was Gubby, whose highlights included trading Witts out for picks 44 and 62, Cloke out for 76, Marley out for 105, and paying big dollars for Wells and Mayne. Not the easiest position from which to take the reigns.
Since then, Ned has been in charge of a list management team who has:
- re-signed Jordan De Goey on less coin despite a $5 million "Godfather offer" from North Melbourne
- re-signed Darcy Moore on less coin despite very strong, Joe Daniher-level interest from Sydney. Many journos thought he was gone.
- re-signed Tom Langdon on less coin despite Sydney's interest. Again, most journos had him leaving.
- reportedly has Brayden Sier set to re-sign despite strong rumours of his departure
- re-signed Jamie Elliott despite a significantly bigger contract offer from Brisbane
During that period, we haven't lost anybody of note.
If he can snare Brodie's signature, it's pretty much the perfect record from his two years at the helm.
Maybe not all of it is Ned's doing - perhaps the culture we're building at Collingwood is conducive to players wanting to stay, even for significant unders.
Whatever it is that has our players looking to stick around, long may it continue!
Re-signed Treloar (4 more years, 5 in total)
Re-signed Adams (5 years)
Re-signed Maynard
Without knowing the dollar figures on each of these contracts, or what the alternative would've been on the trade market (or in Elliot's case - Comp picks, though that's a bit clearer) - it's hard for us to accurately judge each decision.
Our list still seems unbalanced - we have lots of overlap of guys with similar skill-sets, and still quite a few big gaps in our 22 (though Darcy coming on has filled one of those - whilst healthy). Would making some tough decisions on some of these guys (particularly if selling high) been able to address that? Not necessarily - but the question needs to be asked: We are not a premiership team right now. Is just keeping our list together enough to be considered a success?
Last edited: