Also undecided on Okeefe. Already got dids and gia so not sure between ROK and didak 
-
Mobile App Discontinued
Due to a number of factors, support for the current BigFooty mobile app has been discontinued. Your BigFooty login will no longer work on the Tapatalk or the BigFooty App - which is based on Tapatalk.
Apologies for any inconvenience. We will try to find a replacement.
(New) Player Comparison Thread
- Thread starter chrisknights
- Start date
- Tagged users None
🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.
I would go ROK dids constantly has on and off field problems(1 more major off field stuff up and he will be gone for a long time) and has only averaged over 80+ for a year twice were as ROK has only averaged under 80 for his first year of AFL plus i think o'keefe s in better form and will only get more time in the mid were as didak will start to score better but might be abit to get his match fittness and form back.Also undecided on Okeefe. Already got dids and gia so not sure between ROK and didak
I would also recommend ROK over Dids. Not coming off a serious injury being the deciding factor.
Only doing the one trade, and a popular one it will be:
Beams -> Muston
Then the following week will be:
Rich -> Stanton
Sidebottom -> Kornes/Thompson/Green
Would ideally like to bring in Bartel, but after doing the sums I cant afford him. Trades are too tight, cant find the extra cash unfortunately.
Would leave me with just Hartlett to upgrade with my worst players (by position) being Gilbee, Cross, Kruezer and Franklin.
Only doing the one trade, and a popular one it will be:
Beams -> Muston
Then the following week will be:
Rich -> Stanton
Sidebottom -> Kornes/Thompson/Green
Would ideally like to bring in Bartel, but after doing the sums I cant afford him. Trades are too tight, cant find the extra cash unfortunately.
Would leave me with just Hartlett to upgrade with my worst players (by position) being Gilbee, Cross, Kruezer and Franklin.
FromDaics2Dids
Team Captain
I have 9 trades left, $41k and 4 players to upgrade, two of which will be this week and next. Here is what im weighing up....
1) Locker/Enright + Bartell + $45k
VS
2) Mundy/Ellis + Bartel + $145k
VS
3) Mundy/Ellis + Dal Santo / Thompson + $200k
VS
4) Lockyer + Dalsanto / Thompson + $130k
What option you reckon?
1) Locker/Enright + Bartell + $45k
VS
2) Mundy/Ellis + Bartel + $145k
VS
3) Mundy/Ellis + Dal Santo / Thompson + $200k
VS
4) Lockyer + Dalsanto / Thompson + $130k
What option you reckon?
Log in to remove this Banner Ad
I like option 2- especially since you will be low on trades, would save you having to generate some more cash for another upgrade.
Cant decide which one to trade out of Zaharakis (BE 48) or Robinson (BE 42)
for Muston
My Midfield is Ablett, Bartell, Selwood, Cross, Cooney, Coughlan(Zaha, Robbo)
Which one is more likely to play more games in the next 6 rounds?
for Muston
My Midfield is Ablett, Bartell, Selwood, Cross, Cooney, Coughlan(Zaha, Robbo)
Which one is more likely to play more games in the next 6 rounds?
chrisknights
Senior List
- Thread starter
- #257
trade out robo, he isnt named
foley4brownlow
Team Captain
andrew mackie v corey enright. both looking good and both should average 90. the question is who to get though. mackie looks like he has higher scoring potential in terms of scoring 100s but enright is super consistent and you know you will get 75+ from him every week,but i rekan his max would be about 110. thoughts on who i should get?
Gia + 90k
Deledio + 70k
Leon Davis + 15k
I'm thinking Deledio but am not quite sure. R.Murphy may steal a few points from Gia. The extra cash may allow me to upgrade Grimes or Houlihan later in the season.
Deledio + 70k
Leon Davis + 15k
I'm thinking Deledio but am not quite sure. R.Murphy may steal a few points from Gia. The extra cash may allow me to upgrade Grimes or Houlihan later in the season.
Mundy or Fisher?
I like the look of Mundy, especially at that price, but can imagine kicking myself if Fisher returns to the scoring he's capable of as Hudghton takes the key back spot. Another pro for Mundy is uniqueness, as my team is looking very stock standard at the moment.
I like the look of Mundy, especially at that price, but can imagine kicking myself if Fisher returns to the scoring he's capable of as Hudghton takes the key back spot. Another pro for Mundy is uniqueness, as my team is looking very stock standard at the moment.
Even though it doesnt mean anything any more mackie is way more injury prone than enright, just some food for thought
- Sep 26, 2004
- 48,828
- 66,146
- AFL Club
- Carlton
- Moderator
- #262
I'd go for Fisher.
I've got Fisher and whilst he has been disappointing up to this stage, I can't help but feel excited at the fact that as you said, Hudghton is back. This should allow Fisher to return to his best DT scoring position, that being half back, meaning a probable increase in points.
You are right in saying that Mundy is more unique which may give you soms sort of advantage over teams but I just don't like him as a scorer as much as I do Fisher.
exactly hudghton will come back and play a defensive role, whilst fisher will be let loose a little more now. especially with gilbert out this week.
Steve Johnson vs Nick Riewoldt + 11.9k?
Johnson is no doubt the best forward going around, but a tad overpriced.
Riewoldt is also a tad overpriced, and has a big breakeven, but the 11.9k he is cheaper than johnson will allow me to buy bartel next week instead of Pendlebury or someone cheaper. I have gia and deledio so don't even think about suggesting them
Johnson is no doubt the best forward going around, but a tad overpriced.
Riewoldt is also a tad overpriced, and has a big breakeven, but the 11.9k he is cheaper than johnson will allow me to buy bartel next week instead of Pendlebury or someone cheaper. I have gia and deledio so don't even think about suggesting them
Steve Johnson vs Nick Riewoldt + 11.9k?
Johnson is no doubt the best forward going around, but a tad overpriced.
Riewoldt is also a tad overpriced, and has a big breakeven, but the 11.9k he is cheaper than johnson will allow me to buy bartel next week instead of Pendlebury or someone cheaper. I have gia and deledio so don't even think about suggesting them
can't go wrong, youd want both in your final team, so do you want the 12k cash or the 6-7 extra ppg.
One thing that is really making me lean towards riewoldt, is that from round 2-10:
Riewoldt has averaged 109.56
Johnson has averaged 109.44
And Riewoldt has been more consistent. Also, by next week i will have bartel, corey, selwood and chapman in my side, with ablett coming in a week or two later. If I also have johnson... is that geelong overkill?
no such thing.
Trying to decide for a back upgrade, I have 3 options basically equating a slight sacrifice in quality for a large saving as follows:
A. Lockyer 370k
B. Mackie 340k
C. Ellis 307k
I think all are solid options, Lockyer would likely be the best, however he has been patchy lately and Ellis is risky, but has scoring potential and is cheap. Mackie is a safe bet. Hmmm, expensive quality, safety, or cheap risky.
What would you go for?
A. Lockyer 370k
B. Mackie 340k
C. Ellis 307k
I think all are solid options, Lockyer would likely be the best, however he has been patchy lately and Ellis is risky, but has scoring potential and is cheap. Mackie is a safe bet. Hmmm, expensive quality, safety, or cheap risky.
What would you go for?
I picked up lids a little while ago over gia and have loved the move... he has been tagged so far this season but at worst still gives you high 80's and the games he breaks the tag then he gets 110+
Also with the new coach coming in lids will be one of the core players used imo so job security is not a problem..
🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.
Yeah I made the trade a bit earlier today and decided to go with him to. His consistency tipped me over the line!
- Oct 3, 2004
- 1,138
- 1
- AFL Club
- North Melbourne
- Other Teams
- Dream team
Thompson v Stanton v Dal Santo?
Looking to get one of these in for Robinson, as I'm low on trades, and will be upgrading Warren to Didak with no more downgrades.
I guess the other option is to upgrade Ziebell to Didak, but that leaves me with Warren and Hentschel on the bench, but I could afford any midfielder <440k.
Thoughts on above? These are my final upgrades!
Out of the 3 names mentioned, I'm probably leaning towards Stanton and Thompson over NDS, but finding it difficult to split all 3 TBH.
Looking to get one of these in for Robinson, as I'm low on trades, and will be upgrading Warren to Didak with no more downgrades.
I guess the other option is to upgrade Ziebell to Didak, but that leaves me with Warren and Hentschel on the bench, but I could afford any midfielder <440k.
Thoughts on above? These are my final upgrades!
Out of the 3 names mentioned, I'm probably leaning towards Stanton and Thompson over NDS, but finding it difficult to split all 3 TBH.
For my 6th mid:
Thompson v Stanton v Dal Santo V Kornes
More than likely going the latter, he has served me well over the last couple of years, is durable and doesn't get tagged.
Of the other 3 I like Stanton. Has the capacity of massive scores if the opposition chooses to tag someone else. Like Dal Sants though, he can score horribly when he is tagged...
- Oct 3, 2004
- 1,138
- 1
- AFL Club
- North Melbourne
- Other Teams
- Dream team
Yeah, already got Kornes from that list, so if I didn't have him I'd get him.
Still interested to hear how people rate the other 3 though.
I'd probably be looking at Thompson and Stanton. Stanton would probably have the better run home but Thompson looks to be hitting some form and may well get back to his 100-105 average from here on in. I'd go for Scotty.
