(New) Player Comparison Thread

[chrisknights]

Similar to the trade thread, just comparing players.
answer some one else's comparison, ask your own. discuss
ill start off with:


Swan vs Corey + 25k

 

[maximus15]

Similar to the trade thread, just comparing players.
answer some one else's comparison, ask your own. discuss
ill start off with:


Swan vs Corey + 25k

Corey +25k
corey will go back to the midfield now with the injury of gablett and return of harley so should become one of the top 4 from now on and you never know what you could do with 25k

 

[Bert1]

Yeah I agree. Corey +25k. What about in a few weeks time Didak or Franklin?

 

[chrisknights]

Yeah I agree. Corey +25k. What about in a few weeks time Didak or Franklin?

i recon they will score pretty much the same. so i woud pick up the cheaper player.
didak is 392k with a BE of 179.
Buddy is 346k with a 132 BE

i would say buddy

 

[Hodges]

Pav vs Scotty Thompson - can either of them get back to their best?

 

[spence]

Pav vs Scotty Thompson - can either of them get back to their best?

I don't think Scotty will make the top 8 midfielders of the year, hence I don't think he is a trade in option.

I thin wait with Pavlich, he has scored alright in 2 wins however i don't think Freo will win anymore than 6 or 7. Yes Pavlich is cheap but its not a worry he will probably be that cheap numerous times this year.

Riewoldt should come down to around 400 k soon I think he is a must have if you don't have him.

Chapman will be hard to bring in until he has a bad game, and he will have one.

If Stevie Johnson fails to crack the ton tis week, he will be a tasty upgrade option.

I think these 3 forwards are important in determining your rankings.

 

[Bert1]

Im upgrading T.Tuck and Hocking over the nexrt few weeks. Any thoughts on which one I should be more urgent on trading? Which one would be better value holding onto for those few weeks?

 

[Hodges]

I don't think Scotty will make the top 8 midfielders of the year, hence I don't think he is a trade in option.

I thin wait with Pavlich, he has scored alright in 2 wins however i don't think Freo will win anymore than 6 or 7. Yes Pavlich is cheap but its not a worry he will probably be that cheap numerous times this year.

Riewoldt should come down to around 400 k soon I think he is a must have if you don't have him.

Chapman will be hard to bring in until he has a bad game, and he will have one.

If Stevie Johnson fails to crack the ton tis week, he will be a tasty upgrade option.

I think these 3 forwards are important in determining your rankings.

Who would you rate as your top 8 mids then? I would have Bartel, Ablett, Corey and Swan as the obvious ones, after that its a lottery.

 

[amazingjoshy]

Stevie J or Deledio +$22k

 

[Loud Eagle]

Who would you rate as your top 8 mids then? I would have Bartel, Ablett, Corey and Swan as the obvious ones, after that its a lottery.

Gibbs, Kornes, Boyd?

 

[HibSam]

Stevie J over Deledio I would say, but both have high BE's i think so try and wait another week if u can before getting either.

Ok boys, Bartel or Swan + 40K

 

[Hodges]

Gibbs, Kornes, Boyd?

If your including those, you would have to count Hayes, Thompson, Murphy, Montagna, Stanton, Pendlebury and possibly Dal Santo. Outside those top four, its too hard to call.

 

[chrisknights]

Stevie J over Deledio I would say, but both have high BE's i think so try and wait another week if u can before getting either.

Ok boys, Bartel or Swan + 40K

bartell, now that ablett has gone for 3 bartell will rack em up. if u are gettting him later, swan and save the money i say

 

[premiers06]

ok got richo to trade out i do have 30 k in the bank but im looking just at pretty much at a straight swap the two im thinking are

pavlich v franklin +25k

other contenders are petrie, davey and goodwin

 

[foley4brownlow]

marc murphy or lenny hayes? both will average 100 but who to get. there dosnt seem much in it. both guns, both playing in good sides and both dont get tags. i was leaning toward murphy for the simple reason that hayes usually gets niggling injuries throughout the season which could see him miss a few. but i want hayes as well as i dont have any saints in my team and he has the potential to get bigger scores than murphy. can i get some opinions on this one. cheers

 

[Saint KFC]

Who would you rate as your top 8 mids then? I would have Bartel, Ablett, Corey and Swan as the obvious ones, after that its a lottery.

IMO, the top 8 will be:

Ablett, Bartel, Corey, Swan, Murphy, Kornes, Gibbs, Thompson/Stanton

 

[PowerForGood]

Pav vs Scotty Thompson - can either of them get back to their best?

I'm inclined to say Pavlich, he doesn't score too badly even when Freo are losing (which is forever), Thompson is suffering from a lack of supply from the inexperienced ruck combination of Griffen / Tippett / Moran / Maric.

< rest snipped - sorry - wrong thread >

 

[IbbosBFF]

Who will score better form this point on in the season. I know Cooney is underdone still...

Cooney

vs

Hodge

 

[Hodges]

Tough one, but I would say Hodge. Cooney still looks to be pretty hampered by his injury (and lack of fitness). Hodges scores will pick up once Birchall and the like return.

 

[peekaye]

Franklin (346k) vs Brown (351k) vs Pavlich (372k) vs Davey (374k)? Very confused on this one, upgrading Walker and can afford anyone but looking for one of these 4...

 

[spence]

Who would you rate as your top 8 mids then? I would have Bartel, Ablett, Corey and Swan as the obvious ones, after that its a lottery.

1. Ablett
2. Bartel
3. Swan
4. Corey
5. Montagna
6. Gibbs
7. Murphy
8. Sewell
9. Kornes
10.Thompson

Unlucky - Stanton, Judd, Mitchell

Top 3 are well ahead of the rest, all will avg over 112 for me.
The rest should all average 100.

 

[spence]

Franklin (346k) vs Brown (351k) vs Pavlich (372k) vs Davey (374k)? Very confused on this one, upgrading Walker and can afford anyone but looking for one of these 4...

Hawthorn not far from their best

 

[peekaye]

1. Ablett
2. Bartel
3. Swan
4. Corey
5. Montagna
6. Gibbs
7. Murphy
8. Sewell
9. Kornes
10.Thompson

Unlucky - Stanton, Judd, Mitchell

Top 3 are well ahead of the rest, all will avg over 112 for me.
The rest should all average 100.

No Dal Santo? Are you saying you would get buddy over those other 3 I suggested? I would get Brown but Buddy vs dons in a week where I'm desperate for a win is tempting

 

[Cruiser23]

Hodges scores will pick up once Birchall and the like return.

I've heard a few people say that but i just don't see it. What makes you say that? Last year Birchall benefited from Hodge, not the other way round. Grant coming back isn't going to stop opposition teams putting a stopper on Hodge which is what is causing Hodge's downfall right now.

 

[spence]

I've heard a few people say that but i just don't see it. What makes you say that? Last year Birchall benefited from Hodge, not the other way round. Grant coming back isn't going to stop opposition teams putting a stopper on Hodge which is what is causing Hodge's downfall right now.

F*** you have good profile pictures.

Yeah don;t have Hodge, and I am really not looking to pick him up.

a bit off topic but I think Harley coming in will free up Mackie considerably and also benefit Enright. I think that incusion will have the biggest fantasy discrepancy in DT.