JDWCE
Norm Smith Medallist
exactly your thinking, plus my great team arent very accountable so you should see some good numbers for sidebottom
-
Mobile App Discontinued
Due to a number of factors, support for the current BigFooty mobile app has been discontinued. Your BigFooty login will no longer work on the Tapatalk or the BigFooty App - which is based on Tapatalk.
Apologies for any inconvenience. We will try to find a replacement.
(New) Player Comparison Thread
- Thread starter chrisknights
- Start date
- Tagged users None
🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.
- Banned
- #177
M. Pavlich or B. Mcglynn +120k
i would also go fisher because when huxghton comes back he will be freed up much more.
warren or sidebottom to start?
warren should score 60 imo but collingwood have no midfield so sidebottom should rack up 20 possesions but the wet worries me
Log in to remove this Banner Ad
For some reason, but gut feeling is telling me sidebottom might suit the wet a little. Not sure why though!
Heres a comparison:
Consistency v Upside v Uniqueness
Heres a comparison:
Consistency v Upside v Uniqueness
sidebottom will start as a mid for me
warren v walker v m brown to start in the fwds? really unsure about this one as walker is either horrible or brilliant, brown is always OK and warren should get me 50
Warren is the safe bet, as you said he'll get you 50-60 points, but not much more. Personally, I'd go with Warren (which is what I'm faced with, Warren vs Walker).
foley4brownlow
Team Captain
mackie v fisher. really having some trouble deciding who to get here.can i have some opinions on who would be the better pick up and who you rekan will average the most. cheers
iluvparis
Import Whisperer
- Apr 1, 2005
- 50,055
- 40,656
- AFL Club
- Carlton
- Other Teams
- Calgary Flames, Man Utd
For final Mids - T.Tuck v Robbo v Cockie
Thinking they are rated in that order - Robbo the riskiest but could fluke another ton. I'm just stunned how poorly T.Tuck is going but have to have him in as the experienced player over a couple of rookies.
Thinking they are rated in that order - Robbo the riskiest but could fluke another ton. I'm just stunned how poorly T.Tuck is going but have to have him in as the experienced player over a couple of rookies.
chrisknights
Senior List
- Thread starter
- #185
downgrade tuck to muston andf go from there, he should make u 180k then upgrade him to a gun
With both krakouer and higgins having concerns, i think we are all gonna have to face the choice:
Potentially tagged + Lower ceiling v Higgins injury concerns
Could be a decision that splits the pack into two i think.
Potentially tagged + Lower ceiling v Higgins injury concerns
Could be a decision that splits the pack into two i think.
Cross vs S.Thompson
I like Cross for his consistency and cheaper price but Thommo can pull out those big 130's.
I like Cross for his consistency and cheaper price but Thommo can pull out those big 130's.
JDWCE
Norm Smith Medallist
^ probably gibbs but that is a tough one
FromDaics2Dids
Team Captain
I am going to be picking up 2 of these fowards in the next two weeks, who do people rate higher and who do you think are the best options??
ROK, GOODWIN, BRENNAN, GIA, BRAD JOHNSON, FRANKLIN, JONOTHAN BROWN?
Who out of these 7 do you blokes think will have the best second half of the year?
ROK, GOODWIN, BRENNAN, GIA, BRAD JOHNSON, FRANKLIN, JONOTHAN BROWN?
Who out of these 7 do you blokes think will have the best second half of the year?
id be looking at gia, buddy and brown. personal preference. BUT all are good options and theres no way of telling which are the right guys to pick.
snowstorm_ac
Debutant
forward rookies:
wright vs austin - not considering ballantyne just yet
i'm leaning towards wright
wright vs austin - not considering ballantyne just yet
i'm leaning towards wright
I think the general consensus is wright... and I have to agree with the masses on this one
EDIT: My question: Upgrade Raines to:
Mackie or Enright or any other around that 320-350 price (I have fisher and mundy)
I'm leaning towards Mackie
EDIT: My question: Upgrade Raines to:
Mackie or Enright or any other around that 320-350 price (I have fisher and mundy)
I'm leaning towards Mackie
🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.
really a tough choice. i was faced with the same one and went enright. just dont think mackie will score like he did last year, i had him last year and was really frustrating towards the end, pulled out a few 50's and 60's IIRC.
your choice, i flipped a coin and got mackie, i still didnt feel right so i went enright.
aha not much logic but he was looking good at 73 at half time last week. pity he only got 96.
JDWCE
Norm Smith Medallist
If your unsure about Mackie and Enright, you could always have a look at Birchall
Hey guys im looking at upfrading either Coughlan or T Johnstone to Swan.
Was thinking Def Johnstone before Couglan got dropped this week.
Can anybody shed some light as to their job security and which is more likely to be back scoring alright the earliest?
Cheers
Was thinking Def Johnstone before Couglan got dropped this week.
Can anybody shed some light as to their job security and which is more likely to be back scoring alright the earliest?
Cheers
foley4brownlow
Team Captain
corey v swan. this is to complete my midfield. both premium mids who should average 110. the question is who to get. iv been really impressed with swans scoring ability this season he has i think 3 scores over 130 which makes him a great captain option. in all he has 6 100s this season. corey also has been in great form and has 7 100s this season to go with his 16 from last season. to put that into context corey has scored 23 100s in his last 31 home and awat matches now thats impressive.leaning toward corey slightly for his 100 scoring ability but swan also looks a great pick up and a great captain option.
who would be the better pickup corey or swan?
who would be the better pickup corey or swan?
Corey for league and Swan for overall. Which means more to you?
foley4brownlow
Team Captain
well i really wana beat my mates in my league but wana get as good a ranking as can in the overall. this one is really doing my head in. swan has 6 100s this season a 97,79,79 where as corey has 7 100s an 83 and an 85. but swan is averaging 8 more. i really carnt decide both look like such good buys at the moment.
