Prediction Nuffies Phantom Draft Hub.. for the non experts.

[M Malice]

I thought I would create a thread for those not so expert Draft nerds like myself who don't look at it as closely as the likes of Knightmare, Pie4life, PMbangers etc. who just want to have a crack at as much of the draft as they want to without the need to do profiles. I'd love to see yours briztoon . Mutineer ?? Procrastinator35 ??

I'll kick it off with my 1st round, I may have a go at the 2nd round before draft night.
Here is each clubs current selections, thank you Lore


1- Matthew Rowell > Suns.
2- Noah Anderson > Suns.
3- Hayden Young > Demons.
4- Luke Jackson > Giants.
5- Tom Green > Giants.
6- Lachlan Ash > Swans.
7- Dylan Stephens > Crows.
8- Deven Robertson > Dockers.
9- Brodie Kemp > Dockers.
10- Sam Flanders > Blues.
11- Liam Henry > Dockers.
12- Caleb Serong > Demons.
13- Fischer McAsey > Hawks.
14- Kysaiah Pickett > Power.
15- Cody Weightman > Bulldogs.
16- Miles Bergman > Cats.
17- Will Gould > Suns.
18- Will Day > Power.
19- Josh Worrell > Cats.
20- Jay Rantall > Power.
21- Elijah Taylor > Tigers.

 

[briztoon]

Jason mp can I wait until Cal Twomey and Emma Quayle post theirs on Monday night or Tuesday.

I don’t know other teams lists well enough to guess at their list needs.

And my view of a teams list management strategy is more than likely different than the actual professionals.


For example Sydney. My view is Sydney is most likely a bottom 6 team next year, regardless of who they draft.

So at Sydney’s first pick, I’d be going the best inside mid available with a long term view, and for me that would be Brodie Kemp.

Yes he might miss the year, but he long term he’s a player you can build a midfield around, like Cripps or Bontempelli.

But I’ll give it a go when I get home from work tonight or tomorrow night.

 

[Lore]

I thought I would create a thread for those not so expert Draft nerds like myself who don't look at it as closely as the likes of Knightmare, Pie4life, PMbangers etc. who just want to have a crack at as much of the draft as they want to without the need to do profiles. I'd love to see yours briztoon . Mutineer ?? Procrastinator35 ??

You don't need to be an expert to post a phantom draft thread, the more expert posters tend to have draft watcher medals and use the draft watcher prefix. But if you're just wanting to have a guess without a dedicated thread that's okay too! Perhaps we should change this to a 'prediction' thread prefix to take the pressure off a little more?

I think once the draft order has been finalised we'll set up a bit of a bit of a competition too.

 

[Procrastinator35]

I think once the draft order has been finalised we'll set up a bit of a bit of a competition too.

Teams can still trade picks on the night of the draft, so the final order will never actually be 'final', until it's over.

 

[Procrastinator35]

Here's my Top 25....Not in any specific order other than where it's currently projected for the Top 10.

Rowell
Anderson
Jackson
Flanders
Green
Young
McAsey
Robertson
Kemp
Henry
Serong
Ash
D. Stephens
Worrell
Day
Sharp
Bianco
C. Stephens
Taylor
Pickett
Rivers
Williams
Mead
Maginness
Schoenberg

Over-rated in my books: Weighman, Gould & Bergman.
Under-Rated: Sharp, Williams & Schoenberg.

 

[Lore]

Teams can still trade picks on the night of the draft, so the final order will never actually be 'final', until it's over.

Yes I'm aware. Makes it trickier but still doable.

 

[Procrastinator35]

Yes I'm aware. Makes it trickier but still doable.

Sure, it's possible....If you're Nostradamus.

 

[GWS Goose]

I'll have a crack at the first round (how I think it will go not who I would pick)
1. Suns- Rowell
2 Suns- Anderson
3. Melbourne-Jackson (I think this is crazy, but seems to the mail.
4. GWS - Ash (think I'd rather Young but happy with either)
5 GWS -Tom Greene (matched) hope Twoomey is right and the bid comes later
6 Sydney- Flanders (this pick shapes it, Sydney could pick any number of players, have a few needs)
7. Adelaide- Dylan Stevens (think they'll take the local boy)
8. Fremantle - Young
9. Fremantle -Deven Robertson (taking the local option)
10. Carlton- Serong
11. Melbourne - McAsey
12. Hawthorne- Will Day
13. Freemantle- Henry (matched)
14. Port Adelaide- Bergman
15. Bulldogs- Weightman
16. Geelong- Josh Worrell
17. Suns- Brodie Kemp
18. Port- Pickett
19. Cats- Bianco
20. Port- De Konning
21. Richmond- Cooper Stephens

 

[Smythe]

only cooper stephens for me at richmonds first, no one else (hopefully)

 

[briztoon]

Ok this what I would do if I was each club.
NOT what I am expecting on the night.

Jason mp

1. Gold Coast - Matt Rowell
2. Gold Coast - Noah Anderson
3. Melbourne - Hayden Young
4. GWS - Luke Jackson
5. GWS - Tom Green (Sydney bid)
6. Sydney - Brodie Kemp
7. Adelaide - Dylan Stephens
8. Fremantle - Deven Robertson
9. Fremantle - Lachlan Ash
10. Carlton - Caleb Serong
11. Melbourne - Cody Weightman
12. Fremantle - Liam Henry (Hawthorn bid)
13. Hawthorn - Fischer McAsey
14. Port - Josh Worrell
15. Bulldogs - Sam Flanders
16. Geelong - Miles Bergman
17. Gold Coast - Will Day
18. Port - Will Gould
19. Hawthorn - Finn Maginness (Geelong bid)
20. Geelong - Trent Rivers
21. Port - Kysaiah Pickett
22. Richmond - Cooper Stephens

23. Gold Coast - Trent Bianco
24. Brisbane - Jay Rantall
25. Adelaide - Cameron Taheny
26. Adelaide - Sam De Koning
27. Geelong - Harrison Jones
28. Sydney - Thomson Dow
29. Port - Jackson Mead (North Bid)
30. North - Dylan Williams
31. North - Mitch O’Neill
32. Melbourne - Jeremy Sharp
32. Brisbane - Elijah Taylor
33. North - Fraser Phillips
34. Essendon - Sam Philp
35. Sydney - Hugo Ralphsmith
36. Essendon - Charlie Comben
*Brisbane trade then pick 35 to Fremantle - points used to wipe points deficit from Henry bid. Brisbane get pick 66 and Fremantle’s future second round pick.
38. Collingwood - Mitch Georgiades
39. Geelong - Cooper Sharman
40. Adelaide - Harry Schoenberg
41. Richmond - Darcy Cassar
42. Richmond - Ned Cahill

 

[weltschmerz]

only cooper stephens for me at richmonds first, no one else (hopefully)

He certainly looks ready.

 

[Suma Magic]

A very uninformed power rankings, based on who I would want the Eagles to select. So I've rated tells a bit lower as we don't really need them. Just from (limited) videos, articles, vibe - I'm not confident at all but thought I'd give it a crack anyway.

1. Green
2. Rowell
3. Stephens
4. Ash
5. Anderson
6. Gould
7. Kemp
8. Flanders
9. Robertson
10. Jackson
11. Young
12. Serong
13. Sharp
14. Rivers
15. Henry
16. McAsey
17. Day
18. Maginness
19. Schoenberg
20. Weightman
21. C. Stephens
22. Philp
23. Pickett
24. Rantall
25. Bianco
26. Bergman
27. Worrell
28. Mead
29. Byrnes
30. Cahill

 

[M Malice]

Ok this what I would do if I was each club.
NOT what I am expecting on the night.

Jason mp

1. Gold Coast - Matt Rowell
2. Gold Coast - Noah Anderson
3. Melbourne - Hayden Young
4. GWS - Luke Jackson
5. GWS - Tom Green (Sydney bid)
6. Sydney - Brodie Kemp
7. Adelaide - Dylan Stephens
8. Fremantle - Deven Robertson
9. Fremantle - Lachlan Ash
10. Carlton - Caleb Serong
11. Melbourne - Cody Weightman
12. Fremantle - Liam Henry (Hawthorn bid)
13. Hawthorn - Fischer McAsey
14. Port - Josh Worrell
15. Bulldogs - Sam Flanders
16. Geelong - Miles Bergman
17. Gold Coast - Will Day
18. Port - Will Gould
19. Hawthorn - Finn Maginness (Geelong bid)
20. Geelong - Trent Rivers
21. Port - Kysaiah Pickett
22. Richmond - Cooper Stephens

23. Gold Coast - Trent Bianco
24. Brisbane - Jay Rantall
25. Adelaide - Cameron Taheny
26. Adelaide - Sam De Koning
27. Geelong - Harrison Jones
28. Sydney - Thomson Dow
29. Port - Jackson Mead (North Bid)
30. North - Dylan Williams
31. North - Mitch O’Neill
32. Melbourne - Jeremy Sharp
32. Brisbane - Elijah Taylor
33. North - Fraser Phillips
34. Essendon - Sam Philp
35. Sydney - Hugo Ralphsmith
36. Essendon - Charlie Comben
*Brisbane trade then pick 35 to Fremantle - points used to wipe points deficit from Henry bid. Brisbane get pick 66 and Fremantle’s future second round pick.
38. Collingwood - Mitch Georgiades
39. Geelong - Cooper Sharman
40. Adelaide - Harry Schoenberg
41. Richmond - Darcy Cassar
42. Richmond - Ned Cahill

Considering who was available I like Jay Rantall and Elihah Taylor for us Briz and the pick trade.

If Trent Rivers or Cooper Stephens slid to us I'd take one of them over Jay Rantall, I like Dylan Williams as well.

 

[briztoon]

Considering who was available I like Jay Rantall and Elihah Taylor for us Briz and the pick trade.

If Trent Rivers or Cooper Stephens slid to us I'd take one of them over Jay Rantall, I like Dylan Williams as well.

I agree in regards to Rivers, but I have him going earlier because he’s a better talent.

You can only pick from who’s on board. When I did this Phantom I tried really hard it to my Lions bias come through.

 

[THE_GUN]

Richmond - Cooper Stephens
Collingwood - Mitch Georgiades
Carlton - Caleb Serong

Just about every phantom/mock is going with these selections
Either good mail or follow the leader

 

[briztoon]

Richmond - Cooper Stephens
Collingwood - Mitch Georgiades
Carlton - Caleb Serong

Just about every phantom/mock is going with these selections
Either good mail or follow the leader

For mine they were a combination of best available and needs fit at each of those selections.

 

[Blugazi]

Had a crack...

GC Matt Rowell
GC Noah Anderson
MELB Luke Jackson
GWS Lachie Ash
GWS (academy bid) Thomas Green
GEEL (Geelong offer 14 + 17 for 6) Fisher McAsey
ADE Sam Flanders
FREM Hayden Young
FREM Dylan Stephens
FREM (academy bid) Liam Henry
CARL Caleb Serong
MELB Kysiah Pickett
HAW Brodie Kemp
HAW Finn Maginess (f/s bid)
PORT Miles Bergman
WBD Cody Weightman
SYD (from GEEL) Deven Roberston
GC Will Day
PORT Cooper Stephens
SYD (from GEEL) Sam Philp
PORT Sam De Koning
PORT (f/s bid) Jackson Mead
RICH Trent Bianco
GC Josh Worrell

 

[M Malice]

Had a crack...

GC Matt Rowell
GC Noah Anderson
MELB Luke Jackson
GWS Lachie Ash
GWS (academy bid) Thomas Green
GEEL (Geelong offer 14 + 17 for 6) Fisher McAsey
ADE Sam Flanders
FREM Hayden Young
FREM Dylan Stephens
FREM (academy bid) Liam Henry
CARL Caleb Serong
MELB Kysiah Pickett
HAW Brodie Kemp
HAW Finn Maginess (f/s bid)
PORT Miles Bergman
WBD Cody Weightman
SYD (from GEEL) Deven Roberston
GC Will Day
PORT Cooper Stephens
SYD (from GEEL) Sam Philp
PORT Sam De Koning
PORT (f/s bid) Jackson Mead
RICH Trent Bianco
GC Josh Worrell

Kinnear Beatson said today that the Swans wont put in a bid for Tom Green.

 

[Procrastinator35]

Kinnear Beatson said today that the Swans wont put in a bid for Tom Green.

Don't see why not when he's a Top 3 pick......One can only put it down to yet More AFL shenanigans.

 

[nahnah]

Does anyone want me to post my phantom draft largely based off names I like? I've got Emerson Jeka as a draft bolter at this stage

 

[weltschmerz]

Does anyone want me to post my phantom draft largely based off names I like? I've got Emerson Jeka as a draft bolter at this stage

I mentioned to my sister when I was doing the Dogs board phantom draft that people had sniped my three top choices for my next pick, and she said to go with the coolest name. I would probably have picked Trent Bianco anyway, but that solidified it, he has a pretty cool name.

 

[Procrastinator35]

Does anyone want me to post my phantom draft largely based off names I like? I've got Emerson Jeka as a draft bolter at this stage

A club will take him, based on his marking abilities alone.....But that goal=kicking of his has Levi Casboult mark 2, written all over it....Needs some serious work to over-come those yips.