Autopsy Overrun by GWS

[LukeParkerno1]

I hope next week there are some big changes.

Out;
Francis
McLean (injured)
Rampe
Maybe Papley (put your money where your mouth is)
Rowie (very poor effort. I think he has had a poor season as far as disposals go, only 9 on the weekend. Mind you Sheldrick wasn't much better, 12. Those are piss poor for mids)
If Hamling is not fit then Snell. blood the new guy.

In;
McCartin
Florent
Datoli
Cleary
Ladhams

If Florent is going and he is there's utterly no point playing him now. Build for next year and we don't need Ladhams. The guy isn't ready but do we contemplate a debut for Green, with the thought of subbing him after 3/4 just to give him a taste.

If Cleary plays he has to play midfield none of this forward rubbish

 

[wolftone57]

I don't know, i'd consider a comeback against this very team in a final less than 12 months ago and then winning 4/5 to keep our season alive after a horror start, much of it off the back of our "so called best players" to be "standing up" but maybe I'm just stupid.

We weren't the only team to do that to them. They just ran out of legs in those finals. Made all the play in the first half. Their team was far younger than ours, still is. But we don't stand up in GF and that is what we brought on the weekend

 

[wolftone57]

Need to beat Essendon by 112 to improve the maths of finishing top 8.

Um, we actually can't finish Top eight

 

[Donza]

Um, we actually can't finish Top eight

Umm yeah the swans can.

Its possible. Albeit unlikely.

 

[wolftone57]

If Florent is going and he is there's utterly no point playing him now. Build for next year and we don't need Ladhams. The guy isn't ready but do we contemplate a debut for Green, with the thought of subbing him after 3/4 just to give him a taste.

If Cleary plays he has to play midfield none of this forward rubbish

who says Ollie is going?

 

[Donza]

 

[JackHiscoxWasFast]

I hope next week there are some big changes.

Out;
Francis
McLean (injured)
Rampe
Maybe Papley (put your money where your mouth is)
Rowie (very poor effort. I think he has had a poor season as far as disposals go, only 9 on the weekend. Mind you Sheldrick wasn't much better, 12. Those are piss poor for mids)
If Hamling is not fit then Snell. blood the new guy.

In;
McCartin
Florent
Datoli
Cleary
Ladhams

I wouldn’t rush Tommy Mac back at all. Give him the rest of the year off.

 

[LukeParkerno1]

who says Ollie is going?

You seriously think he’s staying to play VFL? Even Francis is getting games. He’s also a guy where we can get value and get a more pressing type of player in

 

[wolftone57]

Umm yeah the swans can.

Its possible. Albeit unlikely.

Um no it's not. Suns have one game more due to Opening Round and that's against Dons. While you might find it numerically possible it relies on Suns losing 5 matches. Not gonna happen.

 

[wolftone57]

You seriously think he’s staying to play VFL? Even Francis is getting games. He’s also a guy where we can get value and get a more pressing type of player in

No, I seriously think he will play AFL.

 

[Donza]

Um no it's not. Suns have one game more due to Opening Round and that's against Dons. While you might find it numerically possible it relies on Suns losing 5 matches. Not gonna happen.

No. It relies on at worst. The suns going 1-4. 0-5 would be fine as well.
They would finish on 13 wins. Then % would come into play.

I mean its unlikely. Much like a team coming back from 46 points down to win after the siren.

 

[LukeParkerno1]

No, I seriously think he will play AFL.

FG or another side he will. We get to get out of his ridiculous contract. It will be a win-win

 

[LukeParkerno1]

No. It relies on at worst. The suns going 1-4. 0-5 would be fine as well.
They would finish on 13 wins. Then % would come into play.

I mean its unlikely. Much like a team coming back from 46 points down to win after the siren.

Lol we ain’t beating Brisbane or Geelong anyway

 

[Donza]

Lol we ain’t beating Brisbane or Geelong anyway

Why not?
Bloody pessimists.

 

[Olian]

I have to question whether you watch our games or just tuned in recently with comments like that.

Just looks at the stats. To be fair the bombers were playing at the same time.

 

[wolftone57]

If Florent is going and he is there's utterly no point playing him now. Build for next year and we don't need Ladhams. The guy isn't ready but do we contemplate a debut for Green, with the thought of subbing him after 3/4 just to give him a taste.

If Cleary plays he has to play midfield none of this forward rubbish

Green is nowhere near ready to play AFL. This could destroy him. Leave that one be. Snell we could play. I prefer Edwards but he is injured. Datoli, Hanily, Cleary, maybe Bowman to HB. I think Robby Fox will probably retire so I'd like to see him and Rampe sent off.

We have some pretty good players coming from the draft, all Academy Boys. King, Carmichael, Chamberlain (hope he is more decisive than Neville), McNamara looks a talent and we will probably need to go into debt with next years picks to pick him up. Harry Kyle mightr be there at Rookie time.

Max King 191cm Forward/Mid
Lachy Carmichael 183cm Defender
Noah Chamberlain 192cm Tall Forward think Gunston
Kaiden McNamara 186cm Defender
Harry Kyle 188cm Defender/Mid

 

[LukeParkerno1]

Why not?
Bloody pessimists.

We aren’t good enough for starters and we always suck against Brisbane

Just come 10th take the 8th selection to the post season. Give the players a break after what’s been a trying year. Get a softer draw.

 

[bedford]

Green is nowhere near ready to play AFL. This could destroy him. Leave that one be. Snell we could play. I prefer Edwards but he is injured. Datoli, Hanily, Cleary, maybe Bowman to HB. I think Robby Fox will probably retire so I'd like to see him and Rampe sent off.

We have some pretty good players coming from the draft, all Academy Boys. King, Carmichael, Chamberlain (hope he is more decisive than Neville), McNamara looks a talent and we will probably need to go into debt with next years picks to pick him up. Harry Kyle mightr be there at Rookie time.

Max King 191cm Forward/Mid
Lachy Carmichael 183cm Defender
Noah Chamberlain 192cm Tall Forward think Gunston
Kaiden McNamara 186cm Defender
Harry Kyle 188cm Defender/Mid

Think Gunston , who Norman

 

[LukeParkerno1]

Green is nowhere near ready to play AFL. This could destroy him. Leave that one be. Snell we could play. I prefer Edwards but he is injured. Datoli, Hanily, Cleary, maybe Bowman to HB. I think Robby Fox will probably retire so I'd like to see him and Rampe sent off.

We have some pretty good players coming from the draft, all Academy Boys. King, Carmichael, Chamberlain (hope he is more decisive than Neville), McNamara looks a talent and we will probably need to go into debt with next years picks to pick him up. Harry Kyle mightr be there at Rookie time.

Max King 191cm Forward/Mid
Lachy Carmichael 183cm Defender
Noah Chamberlain 192cm Tall Forward think Gunston
Kaiden McNamara 186cm Defender
Harry Kyle 188cm Defender/Mid

You are overrating what these kids are worth for starters. King and Carmichael are the big two but neither will go before a mid to late teens bid. Chamberlin will be lucky to go in the ND, McNamara if he goes will be ultra late we can match with a late pick they are worth nothing anyway it’s just match at the nearest one basically. We won’t take Kyle. Basically our second, third plus the pick we get for Florent (let’s say pick 26 for arguments sake) is plenty

No issue with anyone retiring getting a send off I’d be fine giving Dlorent one in the last round he’s given us good service

Snell should have played last week we wasted a week with Francis playing

 

[Bloods86]

Snell should have played last week we wasted a week with Francis playing

Snell is a KPD, Francis played forward

 

[Punts]

Will they make the call the Mccartin for the year?

No risk

 

[LukeParkerno1]

Snell is a KPD, Francis played forward

He was sub which in itself was hilarious

 

[Bloods86]

He was sub which in itself was hilarious

So you think Snell should have been sub and played forward?

 

[legend166]

Also just one other thing to note we're still challenging for the worst contested marking season since that stat began in 1999, and likely in modern history since if anything the volume of contested marks has decreased over time.

We're averaging 6.7 for the year. It's a race against the 2005 Bulldogs who had Brad Johnson

Brad Johnson

Age

49

Ht

182cm

Wt

87kg

Pos.

Fwd

Career

Season

Last 5

D

19.7

5star

K

14.1

5star

HB

5.6

4star

M

5.9

5star

T

1.6

4star

G

1.5

5star

No current season stats available

D

12.8

4star

K

10.2

4star

HB

2.6

3star

M

2.2

3star

T

1.2

3star

G

0.6

3star

as their leading contested mark winner and finished on 6.7.

We lost this stat 21-7 on the weekend.

 

[bedford]

You are overrating what these kids are worth for starters. King and Carmichael are the big two but neither will go before a mid to late teens bid. Chamberlin will be lucky to go in the ND, McNamara if he goes will be ultra late we can match with a late pick they are worth nothing anyway it’s just match at the nearest one basically. We won’t take Kyle. Basically our second, third plus the pick we get for Florent (let’s say pick 26 for arguments sake) is plenty

No issue with anyone retiring getting a send off I’d be fine giving Dlorent one in the last round he’s given us good service

Snell should have played last week we wasted a week with Francis playing

I'm glad your not a Swans recruiter