Pendlebury v J. Kennedy

[Magpie Mick]

I know one is an on baller and one is a key position player but who do you think will be the better player.

Kennedy was expected to go top 5 in the '05 draft and went at 4 but to date has been a little disapointing for such a high pick.

Pendles on the other hand was a surprise pick at 5 in the same draft and is proving to be a inspired choice.

 

[FlamingDon]

Why is there constant threads about players who havent reached 50 games yet being compared it's annoying. For all we know Pendlebury could be delisted next year and Kennedy could win Club B&F award. Both are still young and inexpierenced I wouldn't comapre for another 2 or 3 years!
Both look good future prospects too give Kennedy sometime to shine he'll be a gun.

 

[Ron]

Magpie Mick is in quite the poll making mood tonight it seems.

 

[Magpie Mick]

Magpie Mick is in quite the poll making mood tonight it seems.

Yeah just worked out how to do it! Thanks to the "How to post a poll thread" by Nardz...

 

[Dk#1]

I know one is an on baller and one is a key position player but who do you think will be the better player.

Kennedy was expected to go top 5 in the '05 draft and went at 4 but to date has been a little disapointing for such a high pick.

Pendles on the other hand was a surprise pick at 5 in the same draft and is proving to be a inspired choice.

LOL kennedy. Are you guys still jealous you didnt get murphy or wat and trying to make yourself believe that you won this one by getting scott (wat ever my name is) dud.!!

 

[KING-JAMES]

For Essendon Pendlbury and i think he will be the better player.

 

[Superster]

LOL wat a waste of a poll Pendlebury is a absolute cat and plays in the worst midfield ever.. RON carlton have a 20 times better midfield then you..Kennedy by a mile.

 

[Magpie Mick]

LOL wat a waste of a poll Pendlebury is a absolute cat and plays in the worst midfield ever.. RON carlton have a 20 times better midfield then you..Kennedy by a mile.

Can you explain what you base this on? (Certainly not on both players respective first two years in the AFL)

 

[FlamingDon]

Was that a joke if it was it wasn't funny. If you where being serious then you've gotta be the dumbest guy i've across with.

 

[Ron]

LOL wat a waste of a poll Pendlebury is a absolute cat and plays in the worst midfield ever.. RON carlton have a 20 times better midfield then you..Kennedy by a mile.

Oh good the Collingwood troll is back.
Haven't seen you for a couple of weeks, were you banned or something?
After seeing the Dogs midfield on the weekend i don't think we have much to worry about from them this year.

 

[Nardz]

Yeah just worked out how to do it! Thanks to the "How to post a poll thread" by Nardz...

lol i didnt start the thread, just posted at the end of it... but happy to take credit anyway

to answer the question i'm gonna pick pendles cause im a one eyed collingwood supporter.

That said, to say Kennedy has been disappointing is a bit short sighted because KPP usually take longer to develop.

 

[Smell The Glove]

Kennedy has shown he has a magnificent pair of hands - watch his game against Essendon last year or the last quarter against Richmond this year.

Pendlebury hasnt shown me anything to date which directly tells me he is going to be a superstar, although he has talent.

At this stage, Kennedy, although its pointless to compare the two until at least season's end.

 

[FlamingDon]

Scott Pendlebury's suprisingly a good mark 17 to date this season including 10 against West Coast where he took 1 or 2 contested marks in pressure situations.

 

[Magpie Mick]

l

That said, to say Kennedy has been disappointing is a bit short sighted because KPP usually take longer to develop.

Somebody forgot to tell that to the Hawkins kid at Geelong...

 

[NeRFaHoLIc]

Pendlebury is so much better than Kennedy it isn't funny. Carlton fans can gloat all they like about having Murphy, and how we 'unfortunately ' have Thomas. But we didn't have a chance to get Murphy. However, you had a chance to get Pendlebury, the better of the player out of him and Kennedy.

 

[trueblue_91]

Pendlebury will be a gun no doubt about it. But the more games kennedy plays the better he will get. He works hard and hasn't had a great start to the season but will improve.

Kennedy for me but i wouldn't mind pendles either