Draft Expert PMBangers 2023 Draft Thread

The_General#1 · Jul 16, 2023

Footy Heads said:
would you be able to list the next 20 - 30 players after this would be very interested to see who is in the next crop

Not even calculating Cal Twomey ever gets this range correct. It's so hard to predict after the first rnd.

Jazny · Jul 16, 2023

Tasmania hasn't had a Larke Medalist for 33 years. Today Ryley Sanders became the first Tasmanian to do it in 3 decades, and Colby McKercher also from Launceston was runner up

RedmanWasHere · Jul 16, 2023

PMBangers said:
That's the dream

Actually, you won't be in solitary confinement.

You'll be in with the guy who put a bid on Harry Rowston.

Dee Snuts · Jul 17, 2023

Hey PM, what are your thoughts on Luamon lual as a small defender?

PMBangers · Jul 17, 2023

Dee Snuts said:
Hey PM, what are your thoughts on Luamon lual as a small defender?

I am one of, of not THE, biggest Luamon Lual fans. His movement through traffic, athleticism and attack on the game with ball in hand are really appealing traits heading into AFL level, but I've probably found his improvement through the season as the thing I've loved most. Production, skill execution, decision making, positioning have all improved dramatically

Wild Bill · Jul 17, 2023

Demon 16 said:
I know Watson is pretty incredible but I’d spew if we spent pick 5 (or 4) on a 170cm small forward who doesn’t defend.

With Pickett locked away a small goal kicking forward may not be the prioity - but he is in the convo for top 5.

Wild Bill · Jul 17, 2023

Jazny said:
Tasmania hasn't had a Larke Medalist for 33 years. Today Ryley Sanders became the first Tasmanian to do it in 3 decades, and Colby McKercher also from Launceston was runner up

Hopefully we get both - like an Anderson/Rowell combo!!

Jazny · Jul 17, 2023

Wild Bill said:
Hopefully we get both - like an Anderson/Rowell combo!!

You will want to make sure they have zero intention of coming back to Tassie in 2028.

PMBangers · Jul 17, 2023

RedmanWasHere said:
Actually, you won't be in solitary confinement.

You'll be in with the guy who put a bid on Harry Rowston.

You say that as if Kinnear isn't the funniest bloke involved in footy

GWS Goose · Jul 17, 2023

Jazny said:
You will want to make sure they have zero intention of coming back to Tassie in 2028.

Every one is somewhat of risk of leaving. Those guys are both very appealing selections, if you get 4 good years out of them and they head back to Tasmania, you'll get something back for them. Ideally they fall in love with the club and stay.

Demon 16 · Jul 17, 2023

Wild Bill said:
With Pickett locked away a small goal kicking forward may not be the prioity - but he is in the convo for top 5.

I know he’s super talented.

I just can’t help but think that he’ll drop marginally out of the top 5 just because of his size and position.

Small forwards play an increasingly important role so I wouldn’t suggest that we don't need another. I just can’t see a club using pick 3 or 4 on one - and I stand by my observation that his defensive running and effort is almost non existent.

Better Loosen Up · Jul 21, 2023

Jazny said:
You will want to make sure they have zero intention of coming back to Tassie in 2028.

No one wants to go back to Tassie. Unless they are retirement age.

PMBangers · Jul 21, 2023

Better Loosen Up said:
No one wants to go back to Tassie. Unless they are retirement age.

You're walking into a "anythings better than North" smh

eth-dog · Jul 21, 2023

Better Loosen Up said:
No one wants to go back to Tassie. Unless they are retirement age.

Anything's better than No-

PMBangers said:
You're walking into a "anythings better than North" smh

Damn it Bangers!

PMBangers · Jul 21, 2023

eth-dog said:
Anything's better than No-

Damn it Bangers!

WYR North Launceston or North Melbourne

Jazny · Jul 21, 2023

Better Loosen Up said:
No one wants to go back to Tassie. Unless they are retirement age.

Remember all those high profile trade targets that were clamouring to get to North Melbourne?

Hodgey 15 · Jul 21, 2023

Better Loosen Up said:
No one wants to go back to Tassie. Unless they are retirement age.

Idiot.

Better Loosen Up · Jul 21, 2023

PMBangers said:
You're walking into a "anythings better than North" smh

Regardless, I would still back us told hold on to them as Sanders, McKercher, Sheezel and Wardlaw will form a tight knit little group.

I Love Lamb · Jul 21, 2023

Better Loosen Up said:
Regardless, I would still back us told hold on to them as Sanders, McKercher, Sheezel and Wardlaw will form a tight knit little group.

They will love winning clearances and losing every match due to over investing in midfielders.

Rusty Beam · Jul 22, 2023

PMBangers said:
- Michael Rudd gets his own bullet point here because he showed a contested marking side to his game I haven't seen before, traditionally more a 'smarts over strength' target up forward with his leading and repeated efforts. He's a hard one to gauge in terms of draft position given his height as a KPF and the fact he doesn't look that athletic, but his skills and smarts are up there. Will be interesting to see him against a Connor O'Sullivan type if we get that match up this Sunday

Hey Bangers,

I’ve really liked what I’ve seen of Rudd for the Falcons and during the Champs.

Saw him watching a junior’s game this morning and reckon he’d be a fair bit taller than the 192cms I’ve seen listed too.

Where would you have him on your roster extended draft board? As I wouldn’t mind the Pies having a look at him.

PMBangers · Jul 22, 2023

Rusty Beam said:
Hey Bangers,

I’ve really liked what I’ve seen of Rudd for the Falcons and during the Champs.

Saw him watching a junior’s game this morning and reckon he’d be a fair bit taller than the 192cms I’ve seen listed too.

Where would you have him on your roster extended draft board? As I wouldn’t mind the Pies having a look at him.

Not in my top 40 and I haven't thought about the prospects in a 'rankings' sense past that, he's on my list of ND worthy prospects (bout 67 long atm) and towards the back end. Just think there are others that currently bring more or look far more developable in the same role, and even past that some players that missed state selection, particularly in VIC, could push ahead with a strong end to the season.

pupstar · Jul 22, 2023

GWS Goose said:
Every one is somewhat of risk of leaving. Those guys are both very appealing selections, if you get 4 good years out of them and they head back to Tasmania, you'll get something back for them. Ideally they fall in love with the club and stay.

Well said Goose you are dead right.

pupstar · Jul 22, 2023

Mich0 said:
They will love winning clearances and losing every match due to over investing in midfielders.

You dont think Clarko has a plan.

KinderSmock · Jul 22, 2023

Wild Bill said:
Hopefully we get both - like an Anderson/Rowell combo!!

I expect you will. Easy to keep them together. Tassie will come knocking in 2028 but it’s no reason not to recruit them as if you don’t, someone else will. It’s up to clubs to start carrot farms because, although they are from Tassie, they are not bound to return.

KinderSmock · Jul 22, 2023

PMBangers said:
WYR North Launceston or North Melbourne

North Launceston. Dominated Tassie footy in recent years.

Log In or Create New Account

Draft Expert PMBangers 2023 Draft Thread

All Australian

Brownlow Medallist

Rarely in kitchens at parties.

Draftee

@Headless approved!

Brownlow Medallist

Brownlow Medallist

Brownlow Medallist

@Headless approved!

Brownlow Medallist

Brownlow Medallist

Brownlow Medallist

@Headless approved!

Tier 1 WW Player

@Headless approved!

Brownlow Medallist

Norm Smith Medallist

Brownlow Medallist

I love Lamb

Norm Smith Medallist

@Headless approved!

Premiership Player

Premiership Player

Premiership Player

Premiership Player

Similar threads