Mega Thread Possible trades in 2015 for the Crows

[1990crow]

Steven Motlop has been dropped this week for not meeting club standards. Comes out of contract at the end of the season.

What... he was BOG for them on the weekend

 

[Mattrox]

Jesus, no. A 40 goal key forward and a first round pick??

I think he's "anti-basketballer"

 

[Mr MysteryGuest]

Do people want Carlisle as a forward of a defender? (or swingman?)

if it's defence, does he replace hartigan as the 2nd or does he become the 3rd/rebounding defender?

If we want him took take hartigans spot, given what would have to give for him, I'd pass

 

[Golumless]

Do people want Carlisle as a forward of a defender? (or swingman?)

if it's defence, does he replace hartigan as the 2nd or does he become the 3rd/rebounding defender?

If we want him took take hartigans spot, given what would have to give for him, I'd pass

Swingman for me, replaces Lynch in the lineup.

 

[Dewy006]

Gotta love Crows fan logic.

"Jenkins is overrated, doesn't use his body, skirts packs and the majority of his goals come over the top when he cheats out the back."

Bring him up as trade bait

"He's a 40 goal forward! Integral to our structure, minimum first rounder at least!"

 

[fabs33]

Gotta love Crows fan logic.

"Jenkins is overrated, doesn't use his body, skirts packs and the majority of his goals come over the top when he cheats out the back."

Bring him up as trade bait

"He's a 40 goal forward! Integral to our structure, minimum first rounder at least!"

Different people, different opinions.

 

[Pugsley]

Different people, different opinions.

Opinions are like buttholes. Everyone has one.

 

[Tex200]

Swingman for me, replaces Lynch in the lineup.

Lynch plays a supporting role and we have a rookie breathing down his neck to take it over.

I think Carlisle would be very expensive to bring in for that purpose.

But I'm sure we could slot him in somewhere

 

[Team DJ]

Jeez its funny to hear how peoples thoughts on Jenkins change from thread to thread.
Here "Hes a 40 goal forward and is worth a top 20 pick"

Others - "He doesnt do this this and this and is on the fringes of the team"

 

[Golumless]

Jeez its funny to hear how peoples thoughts on Jenkins change from thread to thread.
Here "Hes a 40 goal forward and is worth a top 20 pick"

Others - "He doesnt do this this and this and is on the fringes of the team"

I think that's more person to person.

Jenkins is one of those players that some will see what he does and be happy with it, understanding his limitations but there will always be some that will just see what he doesn't do (i.e he doesn't crash packs).

That said, you're deluded (more to anyone) if you don't see Jenkins as a first round minimum in value purely due to the position he plays being one of the hardest to fill/most valuable being the main reason to his high value (KPF/Ruck) and that in the end, he's decently successful at it.

 

[Bicks]

What... he was BOG for them on the weekend

http://www.afl.com.au/news/2015-04-09/motlop-stood-down

 

[fabs33]

Jeez its funny to hear how peoples thoughts on Jenkins change from thread to thread.
Here "Hes a 40 goal forward and is worth a top 20 pick"

Others - "He doesnt do this this and this and is on the fringes of the team"

People's opinions don't change that easily. In all likelihood the people claiming he's worth a first round pick are the very same who defended him in other threads.

 

[Sanders]

Do people want Carlisle as a forward of a defender? (or swingman?)

if it's defence, does he replace hartigan as the 2nd or does he become the 3rd/rebounding defender?

If we want him took take hartigans spot, given what would have to give for him, I'd pass

Whatchu talkin bout Willis?

Hartigan is not very good at football! Carlisle is a top shelf defender

Making that substitution should cause us no concerns at all.

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

We have too many players of the same type. Lyons, Grigg, M Crouch, Wright, Martin are all similar types. We will obviously keep Crouch, but not sure how many of the others will end up being required. Not sure if any have value either.

After this season under Walshy, I reckon we would have an idea of letting go of 2, even if it is just for a pick upgrade.

I would keep in order - M Crouch, Lyons, Grigg, Wright & Martin ... but if we were offered good value for say Lyons, then we would be silly not to consider.

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

I would prioritise Carlisle over Aish as it would give us 3 AA-standard KPP's.

 

[Red mist]

After this season under Walshy, I reckon we would have an idea of letting go of 2, even if it is just for a pick upgrade.

I would keep in order - M Crouch, Lyons, Grigg, Wright & Martin ... but if we were offered good value for say Lyons, then we would be silly not to consider.

Weren't Carlton interested in Lyons at some stage? Or was it the Saints? Don't mind Menzel from Carlton.

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

Weren't Carlton interested in Lyons at some stage? Or was it the Saints? Don't mind Menzel from Carlton.

Melbourne were keen, but I think a few Melbourne clubs were... however, Lyons preference was to stick with the Crows.

 

[Red mist]

Melbourne were keen, but I think a few Melbourne clubs were... however, Lyons preference was to stick with the Crows.

Good lad.

 

[Bonkers000]

Weren't Carlton interested in Lyons at some stage? Or was it the Saints? Don't mind Menzel from Carlton.

I thought it was Melbourne. Before we gave them Vince.

 

[Red mist]

I thought it was Melbourne. Before we gave them Vince.

2 say The D's. Probably was the D's a couple of seasons back.

 

[I Lost My Keays]

If we got Aish , would we trade Lyons?

 

[BRL121]

I would prioritise Carlisle over Aish as it would give us 3 AA-standard KPP's.

Strongly agree. Carlisle would be my first choice of player to poach from any team: I'm pleased that others agree. He has fantastic abilities, but perhaps needs some mental conditioning. Aish seems fairly vanilla to me: OK if he wants to come home, but not one to chase ferociously.

 

[I Lost My Keays]

Strongly agree. Carlisle would be my first choice of player to poach from any team: I'm pleased that others agree. He has fantastic abilities, but perhaps needs some mental conditioning. Aish seems fairly vanilla to me: OK if he wants to come home, but not one to chase ferociously.

Did you see the 2012 grand final? Aish annihilated westies

 

[MRB37]

Weren't Carlton interested in Lyons at some stage? Or was it the Saints? Don't mind Menzel from Carlton.

Melbourne mostly, but he supposedly had a meeting with Carlton at some point over the off-season before he re-signed.

 

[BRL121]

Did you see the 2012 grand final? Aish annihilated westies

Sorry, as I'm not in Adelaide, I can only go by viewing AFL on Foxtel. Cheers.