Mega Thread Possible trades in 2015 for the Crows

[hippyhippy]

Why dont we get both...and a player ie cockatoo...

 

[Jeffcrowe]

Neale is a pipe dream like bennell was .... Freo won't let him go and no doubt he doesnt want to go given he is playing amazing football under Ross Lyon who seems to have ultimate respect from his players if not his assistant coaches and they are coming off a prelim final

We can push for it but the chances are very limited

The only chance perhaps is a crushing $$ offer , what would we be willing to pay for him per season ?

 

[TheLeftFist8]

Neale is a pipe dream like bennell was .... Freo won't let him go and no doubt he doesnt want to go given he is playing amazing football under Ross Lyon who seems to have ultimate respect from his players if not his assistant coaches and they are coming off a prelim final

We can push for it but the chances are very limited

The only chance perhaps is a crushing $$ offer , what would we be willing to pay for him per season ?

Great player but I wouldn't pay crazy $$, doesn't have the silk of a Bennell.

Unfortunately it was a draft blunder we won't get back.

Did Rendell dislike Glenelg or something? Neale, Murdoch.

 

[Jeffcrowe]

Great player but I wouldn't pay crazy $$, doesn't have the silk of a Bennell.

Unfortunately it was a draft blunder we won't get back.

Did Rendell dislike Glenelg or something? Neale, Murdoch.

It's probably one of those things that when they are in your backyard you see more weakness and judge them harder

I agree re the $$ , can't spend too much cash on small mids unless they are GAJ

 

[mickfaxis]

Neale is a pipe dream like bennell was .... Freo won't let him go and no doubt he doesnt want to go given he is playing amazing football under Ross Lyon who seems to have ultimate respect from his players if not his assistant coaches and they are coming off a prelim final

We can push for it but the chances are very limited

The only chance perhaps is a crushing $$ offer , what would we be willing to pay for him per season ?

Agreed. The Neale talk is ridiculous. He won't leave Freo. He's pushing Mundy as their second best mid. We'd need to give up shedloads for him, and that's IF he wants to leave before his contract runs out.

Just because Danger is going it doesn't mean we can automatically replace him with an SA-born gun of our choice, regardless if we wave fistfulls of cash in front of his face.

We'll have to just come to terms that the best we will get for Danger will be Geelong's first and maybe a B Grade player. Almost all Geelong players are now contracted so any deal involving a player will need some serious persuading. We don't have any upper hand in this deal because Danger walked out on us. In the end, we'll be screwed anyway you look at it.

Realistically, we need to be looking long term at FA's and other uncontracted players over the next 2 years. That's where Danger's 'replacement' will come from.

 

[Vader]

Make that David Mackay and it might be in the ball park. Lyons is not a C grade talent.

Are you suggesting that he's D grade? Not even remotely close to A or B grade.

 

[anonymous Derik]

Agreed. The Neale talk is ridiculous. He won't leave Freo. He's pushing Mundy as their second best mid. We'd need to give up shedloads for him, and that's IF he wants to leave before his contract runs out.



you don't rate Fyfe??

 

[Dan2352]

accepting that it is unlikely that Neale will leave Freo (unless he sees a better opportunity at Adelaide given that he could lose his spot with Crowley coming back and talk of Bennell coming in)... what about a 4 way deal between Adelaide, Geelong, Gold Coast and Freo:

Adelaide:
In: Pick 9 2015 (Geelong), Neale (Fremantle), Geelong first Round 2016
Out: Pick 13 (Gold Coast), Van Berlo

Gold Coast:
In: Pick 13, Van Berlo
Out: Bennell (Fremantle)

Fremantle:
In: Bennell, Geelong 2nd round 2015 (pick 29)
Out: Neale, Fremantle 2nd Round pick (about 34)

Geelong:
In: Dangerfield, Fremantle second round pick
Out: Picks 9 + 29 2015, 1st round 2016

Effect:
Adelaide - we upgrade our first pick and get Neale plus a 1st round in 2016
Gold Coast - get a seasoned, professional midfielder which they are screaming for and a first round pick for Bennell (given his discipline problems, they might be willing to take this)

Fremantle - lose Neale but gain Bennell and also can use the upgraded 2nd pick in a deal for Cam Mcarthy

Geelong - Get their man while retaining their players

 

[mickfaxis]

Fyfe 1, Mundy 2, Neale a close 3rd.

 

[dylan123]

Neale isn't coming.

 

[anonymous Derik]

Fyfe 1, Mundy 2, Neale a close 3rd.

Ahh sorry I thought you meant Mundy 1st Neale 2nd,nearly choked on my lunch haha...

 

[Wouldbetackler]

Why dont we get both...and a player ie cockatoo...

Cockatoo, Murdoch and pick 9

 

[Smithalicious]

I miss people with sources. These hypothetical trades are very hypothetical.

We need some good oil people! Anyone with any info please stand up.

 

[Pugsley]

I miss people with sources. These hypothetical trades are very hypothetical.

We need some good oil people! Anyone with any info please stand up.

 

[hippyhippy]

Cockatoo, Murdoch and pick 9

Would rather next year's first

 

[blackadda]

Omg Geelong get a superstar and maintain their first round draft picks. Get stuffed Kingy. Daylight robbery. Cats must be weakened. It's a trade not FA if we match.

And we get whacked by the AFL like we did with the Tippet fiasco.. Pass

Sent from my SM-N9005 using Tapatalk

 

[Deaneus!]

i have to say people, these hypothetical trades are not complicated enough!

I propose:

Adelaide
IN: Geelong 1st round 2015, Geelong 1st Round 2016, Colin Kaepernick (SF 49ers), Anthony Martial (Man Utd), Water (Mars), Bryce Gibbs (Carlton)
OUT: David Mackay, Nathan Van Berlo, Ricky Henderson, Patrick Dangerfield

Geelong
IN: Patrick Dangerfield
OUT: Geelong 1st round 2015, Geelong 1st Round 2016

San Francisco 49ers
IN: Ricky Henderson (cheerleader)
OUT: Colin Kaepernick

Man Utd
IN: Nathan Van Berlo
OUT: Anthony Martial

Mars
IN: David Mackay (so he can almost never play for us again)
OUT: salty water for Matt Damon

Carlton
IN: Matt Wright
OUT: Bryce Gibbs

You can do most of these trades exclusively, but it's better to tie them all into one giant mess.

 

[I Lost My Keays]

i have to say people, these hypothetical trades are not complicated enough!

I propose:

Adelaide
IN: Geelong 1st round 2015, Geelong 1st Round 2016, Colin Kaepernick (SF 49ers), Anthony Martial (Man Utd), Water (Mars), Bryce Gibbs (Carlton)
OUT: David Mackay, Nathan Van Berlo, Ricky Henderson, Patrick Dangerfield

Geelong
IN: Patrick Dangerfield
OUT: Geelong 1st round 2015, Geelong 1st Round 2016

San Francisco 49ers
IN: Ricky Henderson (cheerleader)
OUT: Colin Kaepernick

Man Utd
IN: Nathan Van Berlo
OUT: Anthony Martial

Mars
IN: David Mackay (so he can almost never play for us again)
OUT: salty water for Matt Damon

Carlton
IN: Matt Wright
OUT: Bryce Gibbs

You can do most of these trades exclusively, but it's better to tie them all into one giant mess.

I don't want that spud VB at Manchester United thanks! just send him to Liverpool

 

[Draft Bored]

dazbroncos Someone else asked you for a list of players that you could see being part of a trade. Looking forward to seeing it.

Also when you get to it can you also do a list of players you could see being traded within Victoria as part of a three way trade? The only way I see this happening is in a mammoth 3 way with Carlton that would require a young Victorian player.

Remember trades are fair when all parties feel like they're losing so please don't serve up the equivalent of our Mackay/VB/Shaw/Wright etc.

Any other Geelong posters welcome to participate (Mahlepi, manboob).

 

[Draft Bored]

dazbroncos, please select young players from this list that have value and aren't "untouchable" (ignore where they would be traded to, I'm looking at three ways).

34 Walker, Joshua 33 22yr 10mth 12 Nov 1992 196cm 99kg Geelong Falcons Forward
33 Horlin-Smith, George 39 22yr 9mth 22 Dec 1992 188cm 83kg Oakleigh Chargers Midfield
39 Kersten, Shane 20 22yr 6mth 15 Mar 1993 191cm 96kg South Fremantle Forward
6 McCarthy, Lincoln 5 21yr 11mth 22 Oct 1993 177cm 79kg Glenelg Forward
24 Bews, Jed 23 21yr 9mth 14 Dec 1993 184cm 88kg Geelong Falcons Defender
41 Toohey, James 0 21yr 6mth 27 Mar 1994 197cm 93kg Oakleigh Chargers Defender
40 Thurlow, Jackson 29 21yr 6mth 28 Mar 1994 190cm 83kg Launceston Defender
36 Hartman, Bradley 5 20yr 10mth 16 Nov 1994 188cm 86kg Sturt Midfield
37 Luxford, Michael 2 20yr 7mth 23 Feb 1995 186cm 92kg - Forward
43 Bates, Zachary 0 20yr 4mth 30 Apr 1995 176cm 73kg West Adelaide Midfield
35 Jansen, Jarrad 0 20yr 4mth 2 May 1995 192cm 93kg East Fremantle Midfield
8 Kolodjashnij, Jake 9 20yr 1mth 9 Aug 1995 193cm 88kg Launceston Defender
11 Lang, Darcy 21 19yr 10mth 21 Nov 1995 183cm 77kg Geelong Falcons Midfield
31 Cunico, Jordan 0 19yr 4mth 7 May 1996 184cm 73kg Gippsland Power Midfield
15 Gore, Dean 0 19yr 3mth 26 Jun 1996 183cm 86kg Sturt Midfield
38 Read, Tom (R) 0 19yr 2mth 18 Jul 1996 200cm 90kg Sturt Forward
28 Gregson, Cory 20 19yr 4 Sep 1996 175cm 73kg Glenelg Midfield
5 Cockatoo, Nakia 11 18yr 11mth 23 Oct 1996 185cm 82kg Nt Thunder Midfield

 

[I Lost My Keays]

Out of all the players there I would choose Lang

 

[cammo6556]

dazbroncos, please select young players from this list that have value and aren't "untouchable" (ignore where they would be traded to, I'm looking at three ways).

34 Walker, Joshua 33 22yr 10mth 12 Nov 1992 196cm 99kg Geelong Falcons Forward
33 Horlin-Smith, George 39 22yr 9mth 22 Dec 1992 188cm 83kg Oakleigh Chargers Midfield
39 Kersten, Shane 20 22yr 6mth 15 Mar 1993 191cm 96kg South Fremantle Forward
6 McCarthy, Lincoln 5 21yr 11mth 22 Oct 1993 177cm 79kg Glenelg Forward
24 Bews, Jed 23 21yr 9mth 14 Dec 1993 184cm 88kg Geelong Falcons Defender
41 Toohey, James 0 21yr 6mth 27 Mar 1994 197cm 93kg Oakleigh Chargers Defender
40 Thurlow, Jackson 29 21yr 6mth 28 Mar 1994 190cm 83kg Launceston Defender
36 Hartman, Bradley 5 20yr 10mth 16 Nov 1994 188cm 86kg Sturt Midfield
37 Luxford, Michael 2 20yr 7mth 23 Feb 1995 186cm 92kg - Forward
43 Bates, Zachary 0 20yr 4mth 30 Apr 1995 176cm 73kg West Adelaide Midfield
35 Jansen, Jarrad 0 20yr 4mth 2 May 1995 192cm 93kg East Fremantle Midfield
8 Kolodjashnij, Jake 9 20yr 1mth 9 Aug 1995 193cm 88kg Launceston Defender
11 Lang, Darcy 21 19yr 10mth 21 Nov 1995 183cm 77kg Geelong Falcons Midfield
31 Cunico, Jordan 0 19yr 4mth 7 May 1996 184cm 73kg Gippsland Power Midfield
15 Gore, Dean 0 19yr 3mth 26 Jun 1996 183cm 86kg Sturt Midfield
38 Read, Tom (R) 0 19yr 2mth 18 Jul 1996 200cm 90kg Sturt Forward
28 Gregson, Cory 20 19yr 4 Sep 1996 175cm 73kg Glenelg Midfield
5 Cockatoo, Nakia 11 18yr 11mth 23 Oct 1996 185cm 82kg Nt Thunder Midfield

Hartman is a goner isnt he?

 

[FAITH]

I don't want that spud VB at Manchester United thanks! just send him to Liverpool

hed fit right in.

 

[I Lost My Keays]

hed fit right in.

Mackay too

 

[MRB37]

I kind of wish people would stop getting their hopes up for Bennell, Cockatoo, Neale, Murdoch types coming here in trade so I don't then have to scroll through so many posts calling the club crap when we don't get them.