Premiership Coach 2017 AFL lists

[Fizzler]

Just quickly simmed through another season and probably got the closest and best results so far with these lists. With concerns over the ladder, obviously Collingwood and Essendon are the two who seem a little too high but the rest I am very very happy with. Think I may have figured out how to not have a ruckman win the Brownlow medal every year with Luke Parker winning the Brownlow this season. The closest ruckman to winning was Matthew Kreuzer who was ranked 9th in the Brownlow counting.
Also, pretty happy with that All-Australian team with the likes of Michael Talia and Corey Gregson the only 2 who I'd think would be extremely unlikely to make an All-Aus team ever!.

Brownlow is spot-on. Top 5 goals are way off. Disposals are pretty fair. Marks seem fair. All-Aus looks about right. Ladder seems off but Grand Final looks right.

 

[TheHairyGamer]

Certainly does look a lot closer to the real thing that is for sure

 

[Schods]

Hawthorn

Some changes I would make:
Burgoyne to a Small Defender
Howe to an Inside Midfielder
Pittonet to a Tall Forward (TF 72, RU 71)

BTW
You have two Josh Dunkley's in the Bulldogs positions

 

[Schods]

West Coast

Some changes I would make:

Nelson and Cole to Small Defenders
Masten to Small Forward

 

[Schods]

Geelong

Some changes I would make:

Cowan, Cockatoo, Lang, Motlop and S.Selwood to Small Forwards

Blicavs to an Inside Midfielder

EDIT
Gregson to an Outside Midfielder

 

[saintkildaman]

Geelong

Some changes I would make:

Cowan, Cockatoo, Lang, Motlop and S.Selwood to Small Forwards

Blicavs to an Inside Midfielder

EDIT
Gregson to an Outside Midfielder

Disagree with Cockatoo, Selwood and Lang. They're midfielders.

 

[TheBeardAmigos]

Geelong

Some changes I would make:

Cowan, Cockatoo, Lang, Motlop and S.Selwood to Small Forwards

Blicavs to an Inside Midfielder

EDIT
Gregson to an Outside Midfielder

Cowan, Cockatoo, Lang, Mots and Selwood are all midfielders.
Blicavs is hard to make a mid due to his current stats, but im sure haydo169 could find a way to make him a mid.
Gregson is a small fwd

 

[haydo]

Hey lads,

Just something quickly from me.

This Movember I'm growing my moustache for 30 days and (because I like a challenge!) I'm also going to get active and take on a Move challenge. I'm doing it to raise funds for the Movember Foundation, and I need your support:

http://mobro.co/haydo169

I'm supporting the Movember Foundation because they’re tackling some of the most significant health issues faced by men. Your donations will help them stop men dying too young.

Donate online at http://mobro.co/haydo169

Learn about the important work Movember is funding and the impact your donation will have: https://au.movember.com/programs/cause

There's a lot riding on this moustache, so thank you. I appreciate your support!

 

[NimFromSudan]

Brownlow is spot-on. Top 5 goals are way off. Disposals are pretty fair. Marks seem fair. All-Aus looks about right. Ladder seems off but Grand Final looks right.

The goals happen because the full forward always kicks bags. And the game plays the highest ranked forward at CHF by default. So it's basically a ranking of the second best forwards in each team.

 

[haydo]

The goals happen because the full forward always kicks bags. And the game plays the highest ranked forward at CHF by default. So it's basically a ranking of the second best forwards in each team.

That's why guys like Ben Griffiths kick 80+ goals a season while Jack struggles and only kicks 40 for the year

 

[Scullywag]

Will the file be edited to the OP?

 

[Bluey1997]

CARLTON
Positions:
View attachment 306418

Ratings:
View attachment 306419​

Buckley played as a small Forward this year
Wright played more as small forward as well (as he led our goal kicking)
Pickett is more of a small forward as well
Jaksch is a tall forward

Thomas rated to high... bloody useless as **** on a bull
Jones... Need I say more?

 

[Kony Abbott]

Western Bulldogs
Positions:
View attachment 306463

Ratings:
View attachment 306464​

good stuff
the only positional thing I'd change is that Dahlhaus is definitely an inside midfielder. The only ratings thing I'd change is that perhaps Libba is a little low, he is a considerably better player than Daniel atm and they are shown as the same rating.

 

[Kony Abbott]

Now with all the player ratings out there. We have a good 4+ months to discuss and argue over which player has been underrated or overrated!
I want to see decent discussion, heads thrown around and stabs in the back to happen.... Well, maybe not to that extent, but I do want to see discussion. Now have at it, team

They look pretty damn good from what has been posted on here, it's refreshing to see a crows fan and a port fan collaborating rather than squabbling

Is there any chance of a download even though the lists aren't completed or am I pushing my luck? haha

 

[TheBeardAmigos]

now that the national draft is done, i have gone through and put ratings and positions on them. Will post updated team lists and ratings in here after the rookie draft on Monday, they should be up on Tuesday/Wednesday

 

[haydo]

They look pretty damn good from what has been posted on here, it's refreshing to see a crows fan and a port fan collaborating rather than squabbling

Is there any chance of a download even though the lists aren't completed or am I pushing my luck? haha

It's rare isn't it?. A Crows and Power supporter getting along. No chance of a release. List will be up in due time

 

[NaturalDisaster]

It's rare isn't it?. A Crows and Power supporter getting along. No chance of a release. List will be up in due time

the adelaide/port adelaide supporter s**t fight is one of the best on bigfooty

 

[TheBeardAmigos]

the adelaide/port adelaide supporter s**t fight is one of the best on bigfooty

we will keep that to the others on other boards

 

[TheBeardAmigos]

Adelaide



​

 

[TheBeardAmigos]

Brisbane​

​

 

[TheBeardAmigos]

Carlton



​

 

[TheBeardAmigos]

Collingwood



​

 

[TheBeardAmigos]

Essendon



​

 

[TheBeardAmigos]

Fremantle



​

 

[TheBeardAmigos]

Geelong



​