Preview R23: Changes vs. Collingwood

[skam85]

Year	Player	Club
2024	Will Ashcroft	Brisbane Lions
2023	Bobby Hill	Collingwood
2022	Isaac Smith	Geelong
2021	Christian Petracca	Melbourne
2020	Dustin Martin	Richmond
2019	Dustin Martin	Richmond
2018	Luke Shuey	West Coast Eagles
2017	Dustin Martin	Richmond
2016	Jason Johannisen	Western Bulldogs
2015	Cyril Rioli	Hawthorn
2014	Luke Hodge	Hawthorn
2013	Brian Lake	Hawthorn
2012	Ryan O'Keefe	Sydney Swans
2011	Jimmy Bartel	Geelong Cats
2010 (replay)	Scott Pendlebury	Collingwood
2010	Lenny Hayes	St Kilda
2009	Paul Chapman	Geelong Cats
2008	Luke Hodge	Hawthorn
2007	Steve Johnson	Geelong Cats
2006	Andrew Embley	West Coast Eagles
2005	Chris Judd	West Coast Eagles
2004	Byron Pickett	Port Adelaide
2003	Simon Black	Brisbane Lions
2002	Nathan Buckley	Collingwood
2001	Shaun Hart	Brisbane Lions
2000	James Hird	Essendon
1999	Shannon Grant	North Melbourne
1998	Andrew McLeod	Adelaide
1997	Andrew McLeod	Adelaide
1996	Glenn Archer	North Melbourne
1995	Greg Williams	Carlton
1994	Dean Kemp	West Coast Eagles
1993	Michael Long	Essendon
1992	Peter Matera	West Coast Eagles
1991	Paul Dear	Hawthorn
1990	Tony Shaw	Collingwood
1989	Gary Ablett	Geelong Cats
1988	Gary Ayres	Hawthorn
1987	David Rhys-Jones	Carlton
1986	Gary Ayres	Hawthorn
1985	Simon Madden	Essendon
1984	Billy Duckworth	Essendon
1983	Colin Robertson	Hawthorn
1982	Maurice Rioli	Richmond
1981	Bruce Doull	Carlton
1980	Kevin Bartlett	Richmond
1979	Wayne Harmes	Carlton

I'll die on the hill that Houli or Rance deserved it more in 2017, and Tom Boyd in 2016

 

[skam85]

You are a terrible poster.

In this instance that's a bit unfair on Bicks, that list isn't exactly a who's who of one hit wonders.

 

[AFC979810]

In this instance that's a bit unfair on Bicks, that list isn't exactly a who's who of one hit wonders.

Bobby Hill is though.

List his accolades apart from the Norm Smith.

 

[AFC979810]

And you're a terrible poseur...

 

[FR0GGY]

Clearly you didn't watch the Pies defence last week after Howe went off...

You didn’t see the pies defence before Howe went off

 

[AFC979810]

You didn’t see the pies defence before Howe went off

Kane has been backed into a corner. He was wrong. We have 3 of our best 22 missing. Collingwood have 2.

Should just put the hand up and say I was wrong, but unfortunately he wont.

 

[Mutineer]

 

[Cromulant]

Year	Player	Club
2024	Will Ashcroft	Brisbane Lions
2023	Bobby Hill	Collingwood
2022	Isaac Smith	Geelong
2021	Christian Petracca	Melbourne
2020	Dustin Martin	Richmond
2019	Dustin Martin	Richmond
2018	Luke Shuey	West Coast Eagles
2017	Dustin Martin	Richmond
2016	Jason Johannisen	Western Bulldogs
2015	Cyril Rioli	Hawthorn
2014	Luke Hodge	Hawthorn
2013	Brian Lake	Hawthorn
2012	Ryan O'Keefe	Sydney Swans
2011	Jimmy Bartel	Geelong Cats
2010 (replay)	Scott Pendlebury	Collingwood
2010	Lenny Hayes	St Kilda
2009	Paul Chapman	Geelong Cats
2008	Luke Hodge	Hawthorn
2007	Steve Johnson	Geelong Cats
2006	Andrew Embley	West Coast Eagles
2005	Chris Judd	West Coast Eagles
2004	Byron Pickett	Port Adelaide
2003	Simon Black	Brisbane Lions
2002	Nathan Buckley	Collingwood
2001	Shaun Hart	Brisbane Lions
2000	James Hird	Essendon
1999	Shannon Grant	North Melbourne
1998	Andrew McLeod	Adelaide
1997	Andrew McLeod	Adelaide
1996	Glenn Archer	North Melbourne
1995	Greg Williams	Carlton
1994	Dean Kemp	West Coast Eagles
1993	Michael Long	Essendon
1992	Peter Matera	West Coast Eagles
1991	Paul Dear	Hawthorn
1990	Tony Shaw	Collingwood
1989	Gary Ablett	Geelong Cats
1988	Gary Ayres	Hawthorn
1987	David Rhys-Jones	Carlton
1986	Gary Ayres	Hawthorn
1985	Simon Madden	Essendon
1984	Billy Duckworth	Essendon
1983	Colin Robertson	Hawthorn
1982	Maurice Rioli	Richmond
1981	Bruce Doull	Carlton
1980	Kevin Bartlett	Richmond
1979	Wayne Harmes	Carlton

Your point being ??

What's he done since then ?? Or even before.

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

Kane has been backed into a corner. He was wrong. We have 3 of our best 22 missing. Collingwood have 2.

Should just put the hand up and say I was wrong, but unfortunately he wont.

I would admit I was wrong if I were, but I cant help you have nfi

 

[kirky]

yet gave them an early goal or 2 he does do that remember .

So two of their 12 goals came directly from his errors - and whats worse, they were only 30-35m out.

 

[AFC979810]

How you can still post after saying Dustin Martin wasn't worth the trouble in 2016 is incredible to me.

I have been on Big Footy for over 16 years and thats still the worst take of all time. After your call he won 3 flags, 3 norm smiths, a Brownlow, 3 all Australians, 3 Gary Ayres medals, a B&F and a Leigh Mathews Trophy.

But then again you said we didn;t need to chase Izak Rankine because we had James Rowe who has shown more in SANFL than Rankine had shown in the VFL.

 

[CrowBloke]

Certainly an easier game on paper than recent wins we've had against Hawthorn, Gold Coast and Bulldogs.

Dunno. Even with our OUTS (Rachele, MM, Laird)?
Peatling is a Test, but likely to play. Is Butts ready?

After a 9-day recovery, the Pies will be very keen to stay Top-4 if not Top-2.
If our blokes are not switched ON for 4-quarters (ie nothing like the tepid shit they served up last week --- 4 or 5 blokes carried us over the line), we'll be in trouble
+
there's the danger of losing 2-3 more % points, finish second and play Collingwood again in the QF .

We've had several testing games over the last 6-7 weeks, but none moreso than this one which has become crucial for momentum and belief.

 

[AFC979810]

I would admit I was wrong if I were, but I cant help you have nfi

You said - and I quote

"Pies will be missing more key players than us."

Pies will be missing Howe and Hill (2) and we will be missing Laird, Max, Rachele (3).

Doesn't matter how you try and spin it - you were 100% wrong.

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

You said - and I quote

"Pies will be missing more key players than us."

Pies will be missing Howe and Hill (2) and we will be missing Laird, Max, Rachele (3).

Doesn't matter how you try and spin it - you were 100% wrong.

Clearly you dont understand what the term key is!

I spelled this out before, but clearly you are beyond help, so argue with someone else who is happy to waste time.

 

[jakson68]

Frampton vs Thilthorpe is a contest I would love to see as a Crows fan!

Watch the replay of the May 17th game and you will see this contest.
Whilst I don't think Thilthorpe will be kept goalless again, Billy did his job well last time.

 

[Mutineer]

How you can still post after saying Dustin Martin wasn't worth the trouble in 2016 is incredible to me.

I have been on Big Footy for over 16 years and thats still the worst take of all time. After your call he won 3 flags, 3 norm smiths, a Brownlow, 3 all Australians, 3 Gary Ayres medals, a B&F and a Leigh Mathews Trophy.

But then again you said we didn;t need to chase Izak Rankine because we had James Rowe who has shown more in SANFL than Rankine had shown in the VFL.

 

[AFC979810]

You are the best! Maybe a few more posts about how good Ned and Chayce Jones are!

Your reputation is stellar mate!

 

[AFC979810]

Clearly you dont understand what the term key is!

Max and Rachele are not key players for the Crows. Got it.

I spelled this out before, but clearly you are beyond help, so argue with someone else who is happy to waste time.

Its fine. You were wrong. You said Cwood were missing more key players than we were.

We are missing 3 of our best 22, they are missing 2. It's okay to just say you were wrong.

 

[Mutineer]

Your point being ??

What's he done since then ?? Or even before.

My point is spuds don't walk off the MCG Grand Final day with the Norm Smith medal's hanging around their neck.

 

[AFC979810]

My point is spuds don't walk off the MCG Grand Final day with the Norm Smith medal hanging around their neck.

But yet you didnt want Dustin Martin at the Crows. You know the bloke who won it 3 times....

My only hope is that Rankine wins it for us. Just so I can highlight how you didnt want him at Adelaide because we had a better SANFL performer in James Rowe.

#bicksforprimeminister

 

[skam85]

You are the best! Maybe a few more posts about how good Ned and Chayce Jones are!

Your reputation is stellar mate!

You two are the Brokeback Mountain version of George and Jenny. NTTAWWT

 

[skam85]

Max and Rachele are not key players for the Crows. Got it.



Its fine. You were wrong. You said Cwood were missing more key players than we were.

We are missing 3 of our best 22, they are missing 2. It's okay to just say you were wrong.

Technically only one key player for Pies since Bobby has only fluked a Norm Smith and done nothing else

 

[Cromulant]

My point is spuds don't walk off the MCG Grand Final day with the Norm Smith medal's hanging around their neck.

Hows the rest of his career gone ??

Or are you just not willing to admit you're wrong on this one ??

 

[AFC979810]

Hows the rest of his career gone ??

Or are you just not willing to admit you're wrong on this one ??

Bicks - admit he is wrong?

C'mon. That shit will never happen.

 

[AFC979810]

You two are the Brokeback Mountain version of George and Jenny. NTTAWWT

Stop it Skam. Your acronym doesn't absolve you of you blatant homophobia. #banskam