- Joined
- May 8, 2017
- Posts
- 10,230
- Reaction score
- 27,960
- AFL Club
- St Kilda
- Other Teams
- Red sox
Well that explains your level of interest, you would find Melbourne massively changed in the built environment and the population size.Ease up buddy, I'm an Aussie too - got a passport and everything. I lived in Melbourne for 8 fantastic years and loved every minute of it. Got a lot of love for the city and Victoria in general. And I agree it's probably the most tolerant place in Australia - or was when I was there. I haven't been there for a while but still got plenty of friends there, plus of course this forum which provides somewhat of an insight.
That summary is pretty much my recollection. I understand there are a few more black folks there who are African immigrants - really don't want to get into yet another debate about the positives of this as this has been done to death on this forum already.
Anyway this may be why sadsainter didn't hear of any "chunky black women" getting upset about the cartoon - there aren't many around. Even on the internet, if you stick to Aussie media you won't find much from a black perspective.
This is one of the points of the original article. We comment on a black person in a way that black people find offensive because we are either oblivious to or uncaring of those issues. Even if there were black people in the Herald Sun, the easy going tolerance of Australia is a world away from the tinderbox of race politics in the USA where every gesture is significant. Maybe that's a good thing, but in the age of global communication we ought to be a bit more responsible IMO.
If Knight had just depicted Williams as a baby or something, the cartoon would have got zero negative commentary. He accidemtally or deliberately chose to evoke tribal Africa or the racist imagery of the early 20th century and got pulled up on it. To suggest this is just a cynical way of detracting from her poor behaviour is a pretty low act.
Well not totally ignorant, but it's like reading about something in a book. The African American or even black perspective is missing from Melbourne conversations. But the very fact that Melbourne can have this conversation points to a great deal of intelligence and sensitivity towards this subject.
That's exactly the point the article and I made initially. In a way, we may find American and Afro-American attitudes too sensitive but since the subject is them, it's always a good idea respect those sensitivities.
Yeah not much point, and really don't see why you're being defensive. I didn't scour anything, I came across an article about the country/city I love which confirmed one of the negative points I saw/see in it. I think it could be better in this area. I sometimes wonder why it has to be this way. Sorry if you think Australia or Melbourne is perfect, or you don't have a problem with this negative. I'm sorry to say though being the national education leader just makes Melburnians better educated than the rest of Australia, is that really any surprise?
But like I said, I should have known better really coming on here with this stuff is always a recipe for frustration and ultimately is unproductive. Waste of time.
IIRC Yawkey, you're from the US yourself or have a history there. I've read stuff from you before and it's always interesting to take in your pov on issues like these, as you have first hand experience in that culture unlike myself and I try to remember that despite our different political leanings colouring our differing views.
No Melbourne is far from perfect but it’s a tolerant liveable city by any standard and a very multicultural one, I do get annoyed when I think Melbourne, the US or anyone has been unfairly attacked. I thought some responses to the cartoon we’re unfair and over the top.
US history is not Australian history, people being aware of things is not living them. Im not convinced you need that level of awareness/sensitivity it would see a whole range of things that can still be debated here completely shut down. The age is now taking so many pieces straight from the US that some days it seems there’s more about Trump and the US than the PM and Australia. I don’t like it, if anything Australia is still in a polititical sense imo quite British in many ways and I hope it stays that way. Yes globalisation is impacting just about everyone including Australia, I still hope Australia has its own conversations and makes its own decisions rather than just importing other peoples.
I know exactly what people are seeing or reading into Knights cartoon, I’m still not convinced on balance by the selective nature of the outrage or how the debate about her behaviour developed. I wouldn’t have drawn it or printed it simply because I know exactly how some will view it. It’s a fine line between being sensitive to injustice, historical or current and shutting down debate on anything you don’t agree with. There’s a trend here and in many places towards violent protest to stifle any opinions you don’t agree with. There have been attempts to ban speakers from the country and even secret locations for events. I much prefer that people have the chance to put forward their views, if it’s garbage most people will see right through it. Think of the Williams cartoon in that context if you like, it’s being talked about and debated people are learning some things and thinking about it and deciding how it fits into this society.
I must admit I remembered you were visiting but had forgotten about you living here if you have posted about it in the past. I was just amazed about the reach of the cartoon, I was beginning to think it was developing into another only in Australia piece that you sometimes see.
It’s almost impossible to discuss topics like this in this space, what can be discussed over lunch or a beer would take pages and pages.



