*Rate A Player Thread*

[Bourky23]

hmmm i don't think we have a game like this running on the football board.. basically we'll make it the same as the rate a song or rate a poster thread etc.. except we'll go a bit more in depth.. basically you post the name of a player and the next poster rates them out of 10 and what they like and don't like about the player before listing another player.. something to fill in days like this when not much is happening..

so i'll kick it off!!

RATE A PLAYER.......... Ronaldinho!

 

[Toshowyouwhy]

8/10

Not changing games like C. Ronaldo or Messi anymore.

Also spent a bit to much time at Spanish McDonald's.

How about:

Mikel Arteta

 

[Big Kitty]

7.5/10 but for Everton would be one of their bests. I like him, a good solid player. Can't comment to much on him because i havn't seen him play a great deal.

Of course my pick is: Christiano Ronaldo.

Also just a consideration that to prevent it being bias you can't comment on players of your own team?

 

[Benno_900]

9.5/10

Not much room for criticism, other than he is a twat and a diver so 0.5 off. The world's best player ATM.

Next player: Bacary Sagna

 

[Bourky23]

Also just a consideration that to prevent it being bias you can't comment on players of your own team?

yea, i like the idea

 

[youngsaint]

9.5/10

Not much room for criticism, other than he is a twat and a diver so 0.5 off. The world's best player ATM.

Next player: Bacary Sagna

8.0

In the top group of right backs in the world.
His hair annoys me.

José María Gutiérrez or "Guti"

 

[footylover18]

8.0

In the top group of right backs in the world.
His hair annoys me.

José María Gutiérrez or "Guti"

obviously this is a bit flawed since what i consider a 7/10 will be much diff to what someone else considers a 7/10. FWIW as far as i'm concerned 7/10 is a very good player, 8/10 is elite, 9/10 should only be reserved for the best few player in the world, 10/10, doesn't exist atm.

As far as Guti goes, i'll give him a 6.75/10. Hes a good player, there was a time when he was underrated, but right now it's got to a point that everyone says he is underrated and now i think he's a touch overrated. Good solid player.

Robinho

 

[Benno_900]

obviously this is a bit flawed since what i consider a 7/10 will be much diff to what someone else considers a 7/10. FWIW as far as i'm concerned 7/10 is a very good player, 8/10 is elite, 9/10 should only be reserved for the best few player in the world, 10/10, doesn't exist atm.

Sagna is elite. Anyway what would be the official ranking system ...

10 - Not human
9 - Top 10 in the world
8 - Elite
7 - Very Good
6 - Solid
5 - Serviceable
4 - Mediocre
3 - Poor
2 - Absolute dud
1 - Emmanuel Eboue

 

[Bourky23]

Robinho

superstar. top 10 in the world on his day.. but his attitude sometimes stops that from happening.. hoping he fires at man city..

not top 10, but better than elite

8.5/10

 

[ashley12]

Im sure I made a thread like this before, we all got to laugh at Embers and his idea of playing Babel as a CM for Liverpool.

And Bourky didnt put in a player, so the next player is

Robbie Keane (Liverpool)

 

[PendlePie]

obviously this is a bit flawed since what i consider a 7/10 will be much diff to what someone else considers a 7/10. FWIW as far as i'm concerned 7/10 is a very good player, 8/10 is elite, 9/10 should only be reserved for the best few player in the world, 10/10, doesn't exist atm.

As far as Guti goes, i'll give him a 6.75/10. Hes a good player, there was a time when he was underrated, but right now it's got to a point that everyone says he is underrated and now i think he's a touch overrated. Good solid player.

Robinho

7.5. His good games are great but the others are just decent.

Gael Clichy

 

[belfast_bomber]

Sagna is elite. Anyway what would be the official ranking system ...

10 - Not human

Craig Bellamy: 10

 

[davey_magik]

Clichy I'd give a 7/10. He's a very, very good LB and will only get better.

Ryan Giggs

 

[cesc fabregas]

Ryan Giggs, was a match winner in his day and a 8/10 back then. age has hit him now and he won't be getting better. 6.25/10.

Samir Nasri

 

[Bourky23]

young promising talent and arsenal was where he was always gonna end up... still unsure how he'll go coz i still think the prem will be too tough for him.. hopefully can prove me wrong

right now 6/10

potential to be an 8 in the near future

Zlatan Ibrahimovic

 

[Cassius_Clay]

Sagna is elite. Anyway what would be the official ranking system ...

10 - Not human
9 - Top 10 in the world
8 - Elite
7 - Very Good
6 - Solid
5 - Serviceable
4 - Mediocre
3 - Poor
2 - Absolute dud
1 - Emmanuel Eboue

11 - David Villa aka Lord

 

[ShearMagic9]

young promising talent and arsenal was where he was always gonna end up... still unsure how he'll go coz i still think the prem will be too tough for him.. hopefully can prove me wrong

right now 6/10

potential to be an 8 in the near future

Zlatan Ibrahimovic

A 6 for Nasri?

He's worthy of a 7 at least, very talented player, and he's certainly in the 'very good' category. Probably not quite elite yet, but he's definitely worth a 7.

Zlatan Ibrahimovic - 7/10. Used to be elite, but he's not just 'very good' although I don't watch an awful lot of Serie A. He stinks up the joint badly in games that count though.

Alan Smith.

 

[bus24]

6 for Nasri is a bit harsh.

7 atm like FC said. But he could be anything, really. What an exceptional talent.

 

[ShearMagic9]

Not going to rate the superstar Alan Smith?

I'll do it for you.

10/10

Fit, sexy, skillful.

Everything a man could want.

 

[cesc fabregas]

but seriously, alan smith. had his days in the sun (very few), can be good player but is very average. 5/10

kaka

 

[Bourky23]

still in the best 3 in the world.. probably the most technically perfect player in the world..

9/10

Bastian Schweinsteiger

 

[bus24]

Dunno about Bastian, he's average, but his Mrs! Woah!

 

[Bradesmaen]

Dunno about Bastian, he's average, but his Mrs! Woah!

Bastians Missus - 10/10


Tim Cahill

 

[A Bit High]

Bastians Missus - 10/10


Tim Cahill

7.5 for our boy Tim

Always scores goals from Midfield.

Not quite Elite but Very Very Good.

Didier Drogba

 

[AG]

I love you Theo. 10/10